Key Takeaways

  • LLCs offer strong liability protection and flexible tax treatment for one or more members.
  • LLPs are ideal for professionals in licensed fields who want liability protection but shared management duties.
  • LPs are commonly used for investment projects where silent (limited) partners want limited liability without management control.
  • LLCs and LLPs provide pass-through taxation, but LLPs require at least two partners and are often restricted to certain professions.
  • LPs must have at least one general partner with full liability, unlike LLCs which limit liability for all members.
  • Choosing between LP vs LLC depends on liability preferences, control structure, and business goals.

An LLC vs LLP vs LP compares three different type of entities with individual business structures. An LLC offers tax flexibility and operational efficiency. An LLP combines the advantages of an LLC with a limited partnership. An LP is best known as a business having silent partners.

About a Limited Liability Company (LLC)

Limited liability companies are a beneficial entity for single-owner businesses and small business owners. The owners are referred to as members. The LLC can consist of as few as one or two members.

One of the advantages of an LLC is the "limited" liability part, which provides personal protection to each member. For example, a member's personal assets are protected legally even if the LLC is dissolved or sued.

LLP vs LLC: Key Differences

When comparing an LLP vs LLC, key differences emerge in formation, liability, and professional usage:

  • Ownership: LLPs must have at least two partners, while LLCs can have just one member.
  • Profession Restrictions: Many states limit LLPs to specific licensed professions (e.g., law, accounting, architecture).
  • Liability: LLP partners are not liable for the actions of other partners, which is particularly advantageous in professional fields.
  • Formation Simplicity: LLCs are often simpler to form and maintain in states that impose restrictions on LLPs.

These differences are crucial for professionals deciding between an LLP or LLC, especially in regulated industries.

Management and Liability in an LLC

In an LLC, members can choose between member-managed and manager-managed structures. In a member-managed LLC, all owners participate in day-to-day operations. In a manager-managed LLC, designated managers handle business operations, which is useful for passive investors.

Liability is limited for all members. Unlike a general partner in an LP, no individual is personally responsible for business debts. This makes LLCs especially attractive for entrepreneurs seeking liability protection without giving up control or flexibility.

Forming a Limited Liability Company

Several steps are necessary to form and register an LLC. These generally include:

  • A distinguishable name that is decidedly different from an existing business name that does not use restricted words.
  • The LLC will have a set of Articles of Confederation, which includes name and contact information for each member.
  • An operating agreement will outline each member's percentage of ownership if there is more than one member.
  • Acquisition of the appropriate permits and licenses for the specific industry.

Tax Treatment of LLCs

LLCs offer pass-through taxation, meaning profits are taxed only once on the members’ individual tax returns. However, an LLC may elect to be taxed as a C corporation or S corporation by filing the appropriate IRS forms. This flexibility allows members to optimize tax strategy based on their specific circumstances.

In contrast to LPs, where limited partners avoid self-employment tax, members in an LLC are generally considered self-employed and must pay self-employment taxes on their share of profits.

Benefits of an LLC

There are no federal business taxes with an LLC. This is due to the taxes being passed on to the LLC members.

  • Each member of an LLC is protected from personal liability.
  • The registration paperwork required to form an LLC is less than that of other business entities.
  • An LLCs startup costs are lower than other types of business structures.
  • There are fewer restrictions and more flexibility regarding an LLCs profit-sharing process.

Members of an LLC are considered self-employed. This means each member pays the higher self-employment tax that is based on the LLCs entire net income. In some states, the company is dissolved when a member leaves an LLC. The remaining members would need to form a new LLC to stay in business.

About a Limited Liability Partnership (LLP)

Unlike a limited liability company that has members, a limited liability partnership has partners who share in the company's ownership.

  • Partners have management rights, tax benefits, and liability protection.
  • Profit and Loss (P&L) is passed through to the partners as opposed to being taxed at the corporate level.
  • In some states, there are restrictions on the types of businesses that can form an LLP.

Depending on what type of restrictions a state has in place, forming an LLC is a beneficial move for professionals working on their own or in firms such as accounting, engineering, legal, or medical. With an LLP, even if a partner incurs debts due to misconduct or negligence the individual professional is protected.

Formation of an LLP

Formation of an LLP is more involved than the formation process for an LLC. The formation process begins with the verification of qualification status if the LLP is being formed in a state with restrictions regarding an LLP. The rest of the formation process includes:

  • A registered "doing business name" that is unique from other business names in the state or a personal name or names.
  • A partnership agreement that outlines the assets and liabilities of each partner.
  • An assigned registered agent who is authorized to conduct business in the state.
  • A certificate of limited liability partnership with the names of the partners, the business location, and general contact information filed with the state.
  • An Employer Identification Number (EIN).
  • A state ID number issued by the state.
  • Applicable permits and licenses allowing the business to operate legally.
  • Required insurance.
  • Publication of the formation in a local media source.

About a Limited Partnership (LP)

Limited partnerships have one general partner who has the responsibility for making management decisions and obligations. Other limited partners do not hold management or voting authority. Partners in an LP are liable only for the amount they've invested in the company. LPs are a positive move as a business structure when the goal is generating operating capital without giving up other rights and are a good choice for time-restricted projects.

An LP is formed following the same procedures as an LLP with the following exceptions:

  • A limited partnership agreement is required versus a limited liability partnership agreement.
  • The general partner usually serves as the registered agent.
  • A certificate of limited partnership is required.
  • Workers' compensation insurance may be required.

Administrative and Regulatory Considerations

Each entity type faces different levels of regulatory oversight:

  • LLCs must file annual reports and pay ongoing fees in most states. Some also impose franchise taxes.
  • LLPs may require proof of professional licensing and carry additional insurance obligations.
  • LPs typically involve more complexity due to the need to maintain the roles of general and limited partners and ensure compliance with related tax structures.

Depending on your location and business activity, these administrative differences can significantly impact operational efficiency.

LLC vs LP: Which Is Better for Investors?

In an LP vs LLC comparison focused on investing, LPs offer advantages to passive investors by shielding them from management responsibilities and limiting their liability to their investment. In contrast, LLC members typically have management rights unless the LLC is manager-managed.

LLCs, however, provide greater flexibility and liability protection for all parties involved. Additionally, LLCs avoid the requirement of having a general partner exposed to unlimited liability, which is mandatory in an LP. This makes LLCs a more attractive option for startups and small businesses.

Control and Capital in LPs

LPs are often used in investment projects, real estate ventures, and family businesses due to their unique structure. The general partner manages operations and bears full liability, while limited partners act as passive investors and enjoy limited liability.

This setup makes LPs ideal for situations where investors want to fund a business but not participate in its day-to-day management. However, because general partners are personally liable, many LPs form an LLC to serve as the general partner, mitigating personal risk.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. What is the main difference between an LP and an LLC?
    An LP has general and limited partners, with only the general partner having management authority and unlimited liability. In an LLC, all members enjoy limited liability, and management can be shared.
  2. Can a single person form an LLP?
    No, LLPs require at least two partners, whereas LLCs can be formed by a single member.
  3. Are LPs or LLCs better for investors?
    LPs are better for passive investors who want liability protection without control. LLCs are better if all members want equal protection and more control.
  4. Do LPs offer the same liability protection as LLCs?
    Limited partners in an LP have liability protection, but general partners do not. In an LLC, all members have limited liability.
  5. Can an LLC act as the general partner in an LP?
    Yes, it’s common to form an LLC to serve as the general partner in an LP to limit personal liability.

If you need help with LLC vs LLP vs LP, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.