Key Takeaways

  • LLCs offer more flexibility in management and taxation, making them ideal for small to midsize businesses that want pass-through taxation and fewer formalities.
  • Corporations (C Corps and S Corps) are better suited for businesses planning to raise capital through investors or go public.
  • Corporations provide strong legal precedent, continuity, and growth potential, but come with more regulatory requirements and double taxation for C Corps.
  • Ownership structure, profit distribution, and employee benefits differ significantly between LLCs and corporations.
  • Choosing between an LLC and a corporation depends on growth plans, investor involvement, administrative preferences, and tax strategy.Comparing LLC vs. corporation pros and cons? Limited liability companies (LLCs) and corporations are the two most popular business structures available.

Comparing LLC vs. corporation pros and cons? Limited liability companies (LLCs) and corporations are the two most popular business structures available.

With incorporation, a business becomes a separate legal entity, which is legally considered a new "person." A business entity can:

  • Enter into its own contracts.
  • File its own taxes.
  • Have its own bank account.
  • Be essentially distinct from its owners. 

A business entity can do many things a person can do. However, a corporation can protect its shareholders from business-related liabilities. An LLC also offers corporate-style liability protections.

What Is a Limited Liability Company?

An LLC is a type of business that combines characteristics of a partnership and a corporation. LLC owners, who are referred to as "members," are not personally liable for business obligations and debts.

Unlike a corporation, an LLC isn't taxed directly. Instead, profits and losses pass through the company to the members, who then report the finances on their personal tax returns. As such, LLCs are perfect for small-business owners who need liability protections but don't need to raise much capital from investors. LLCs are so popular, in fact, that most small businesses started in the last decade have been LLCs.

Forming an LLC is easier than forming a corporation, although you may need to pay the same amount in filing fees. File an articles of organization within your state, and if required, publish a notice of the business's formation in your local paper.

Although it isn't required, you should also consider creating an operating agreement for your LLC, which details member's rights and interest percentages. Also, be sure to obtain the necessary permits and licenses required to conduct business in your area.

Advantages

An LLC's advantages include:

  • Personal liability protection
  • Less recordkeeping than corporations
  • Easily divided responsibilities and profits
  • Easy setup
  • Being inexpensive to establish
  • Fewer restrictions than corporations
  • Flexible organizational structure.

Disadvantages

An LLC's drawbacks include:

  • Ongoing formation costs
  • Less legal precedent
  • Inability to raise venture capital
  • More difficulty in transferring ownership than in corporations
  • Income is subject to self-employment taxes.

LLC vs Corporation: Fundraising and Investment Potential

Corporations, especially C Corps, are typically preferred by investors and venture capital firms due to their well-defined stock structures, legal clarity, and growth readiness. They can issue multiple classes of stock and attract foreign investors (except for S Corps).LLCs, on the other hand, are more limited in raising capital. They can't issue stock and may face challenges attracting institutional investors. This makes them better suited for businesses that plan to remain privately owned or family-operated.

LLC vs Corporation: Management and Decision-Making

LLCs provide a choice between member-managed and manager-managed structures, offering flexibility in how day-to-day decisions are made. This is especially useful for small businesses where all owners want to participate actively in management.Corporations follow a more formalized structure with a board of directors and officers. Major decisions must go through board resolutions and shareholder meetings, making the process more complex but also more suitable for accountability in larger businesses.

LLC vs Corporation: Ownership and Profit Distribution

LLCs allow members to distribute profits in any manner they choose, regardless of ownership percentage, as long as it is outlined in the operating agreement. This provides flexibility in rewarding active members or structuring investments creatively.In contrast, corporations must distribute profits based on the number of shares owned. Shareholders receive dividends proportionate to their ownership stake, which limits customization. This rigid structure may be less suitable for small businesses wanting unequal profit allocation among founders or investors.

What Is a Corporation?

There are two types of corporations: S corporations (S corp) and C corporations (C corp).

C Corporations

A C corp is a company that shareholders own. The company itself is liable for legal and financial issues. The company is directly taxed on profits, and shareholders are taxed on dividends, resulting in "double taxation."

A C corp structure is a good choice for startups with long-term goals of going public or for businesses requiring ample investment capital.

Most states require the following steps to form a C corporation:

  • File an articles of incorporation.
  • Establish bylaws and resolutions detailing the company's operating rules.
  • Appoint a board of directors.
  • Appoint a registered agent.
  • Issue stock to the initial shareholders.

The main advantage of having a C corp is the personal liability protection. A corporation is also considered an established business entity, which looks more attractive to investors.

The downside is that corporations:

  • Are expensive to establish.
  • Require extensive paperwork.
  • Are subject to double taxation.

S Corporations

An S corp is not an official business entity. Rather the term refers to the way in which the business chooses to be taxed. The IRS classifies an S corp under subchapter S of the Internal Revenue Code.

The biggest advantage of electing S corp status is that S corps are taxed like partnerships, so they aren't taxed twice. Instead of the company itself being taxed, income passes through the business to the shareholders. The shareholders then report their income on personal tax returns, and the income is then taxed at the shareholder's rate.

Unlike C corporations, an S corporation cannot have foreign investors and is limited to no more than 100 shareholders. Forming an S corp is also similar to forming a C corp.

S corp advantages include:

  • Personal liability protection.
  • Pass-through taxation.
  • Tax benefits for excess profits.
  • Cash accounting method.
  • Enhanced credibility.
  • Perpetual operation even if an owner dies or leaves the company.
  • The company pays employees' salaries while deducting payroll expenses.
  • Remaining profits after paying reasonable salaries, which are dispersed to owners as dividends.

There are also some drawbacks:

  • S corps are subject to closer IRS scrutiny.
  • Stock ownership restrictions.
  • Less flexible ownership structure.
  • Expensive to form.
  • Shareholders must adhere to all requirements.
  • Additional state taxes may apply.

LLC vs Corporation: Compliance and Paperwork

LLCs require minimal compliance — typically just an annual report and state fees. There's no need for formal minutes or annual meetings unless mandated by the operating agreement.Corporations face stricter requirements. These include holding annual meetings, keeping detailed minutes, issuing stock certificates, and complying with SEC regulations if public. This administrative burden is a key consideration when comparing LLC vs corporation pros and cons.

LLC vs Corporation: Continuity and Succession

Corporations benefit from perpetual existence — they continue operating even if shareholders leave, sell their shares, or pass away. This stability is attractive for long-term growth and is often a requirement for large-scale contracts and partnerships.LLCs, however, may dissolve upon a member’s departure unless otherwise stated in the operating agreement. While many states now allow perpetual existence for LLCs, it's not the default and may require additional planning.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Which is better for taxes — an LLC or a corporation? LLCs generally offer pass-through taxation, avoiding double taxation. C Corps are subject to corporate and dividend taxes, while S Corps also offer pass-through taxation but have more restrictions.

2. Can I convert an LLC to a corporation later? Yes, you can convert an LLC to a corporation, which is common when seeking outside investors or planning to go public.

3. What’s easier to maintain: an LLC or a corporation? An LLC is easier to maintain, with fewer formal requirements like annual meetings or detailed recordkeeping.

4. Which structure is better for raising capital? Corporations are preferred by investors, especially venture capitalists, due to their stock structure and regulatory clarity.

5. Can an S Corp have multiple types of shareholders? No, S Corps cannot have more than 100 shareholders and must be U.S. individuals or certain trusts — no foreign or corporate shareholders are allowed.

If you need help weighing LLC vs. corporation pros and cons, post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.