Key Takeaways

  • An LLC S Corp election allows an LLC to retain its flexible structure while choosing to be taxed like an S corporation, potentially reducing self-employment taxes.
  • To qualify for S corp status, the LLC must meet IRS requirements, such as having fewer than 100 shareholders, one class of stock, and only eligible shareholders.
  • Electing S corp status can benefit business owners by splitting income into salary and distributions, which can reduce overall tax liability.
  • There are trade-offs: S corps require stricter IRS compliance, formal payroll, and careful documentation to avoid penalties.
  • The decision to elect S corp status depends on business size, profits, and long-term goals — consulting a tax professional or attorney is highly recommended.

LLC S Corp election allows limited liability companies to seek a new status for tax purposes. By electing S corp status, your LLC can benefit in a number of ways. This means that you can structure your company as an LLC but pay taxes as an S corporation. By taking this step, you will be able to enjoy the operational flexibility of an LLC, combined with the tax perks of an S corporation. 

What is an LLC?

An LLC or "limited liability company" is a type of legal entity that is used to run a business. This structure is designed to offer the owner(s) limited liability protection — just like a corporation. Being a hybrid entity, LLCs also have characteristics of a general partnership or sole proprietorship.

Offering many of the advantages associated with a corporation, LLCs are easier to form and are more flexible. However, the IRS does not recognize LLCs, which is why the company must file as either a sole proprietorship, partnership, or a corporation.  

In terms of the owners of an LLC, they are referred to as members. Unlike a corporation, there is no limit to the number of members involved. However, these members enjoy personal liability similar to those who own a corporation. 

When preparing for your taxes, if you are a single-member LLC, you will be considered a disregarded entity. You will pay taxes as a sole proprietorship, claiming all of the LLC's income and losses on your personal tax return. If there are multiple members involved, you will be taxed as a partnership. 

Although the majority of LLCs continue to operate under their default tax classification, some choose to be elected as an S corporation. This offers a number of tax benefits.

Why LLCs Elect S Corp Status

While many small businesses operate successfully under the default LLC tax structure, choosing to file an LLC S Corp election can unlock significant tax advantages. The main motivation is usually reducing self-employment taxes. By default, LLC owners pay self-employment tax (covering Social Security and Medicare) on all business profits. However, by electing S corp status, a portion of the income can be classified as distributions, which are not subject to self-employment tax.

For example, an LLC owner might pay themselves a “reasonable salary” as an employee, which is subject to payroll taxes, while receiving additional profits as dividends or distributions. This can result in thousands of dollars in annual tax savings. Additionally, S corps can make it easier to attract investors and may provide greater credibility with banks and lenders.

However, S corp election also brings more complexity — such as payroll processing, formal shareholder meetings, and stricter IRS reporting requirements. These factors make it most beneficial for businesses that have consistent profits and plan to grow beyond a small, single-owner operation.

LLC and S Corporations: Key Differences 

S corporations and LLCs are desirable among small business owners due to "pass-through" tax treatment. In comparison to a C corporation, neither an S corp or an LLC pay taxes on the business itself. Instead, all of the company's profits are passed onto the owners. 

Although similar, there are some key differences, including:

  • From an administrative point-of-view, an LLC is easier to run.
  • LLCs require fewer forms and filings, resulting in lower start-up costs.
  • An LLC also benefits from greater flexibility in regards to ownership percentages. 
  • An S corporation, however, provides greater flexibility in how owners are paid. 
  • S corporations also offer greater benefits in terms of taxation. 

Tax Implications of LLC S Corp Election

The tax treatment of an LLC S corp differs significantly from that of a default LLC. Key distinctions include:

  • Pass-Through Taxation: Both LLCs and S corps are pass-through entities, but S corps allow owners to split income into salary and distributions, potentially lowering self-employment taxes.
  • Payroll Requirements: Once an LLC elects S corp status, the owner becomes a company employee and must pay themselves a reasonable salary through payroll.
  • Qualified Business Income (QBI) Deduction: Both structures may qualify for the 20% QBI deduction, but S corp owners often have more control over taxable income levels, which can maximize this benefit.
  • State Taxes: While S corp election affects federal taxes, some states impose additional franchise or excise taxes. Business owners should review local tax laws before electing S corp status.

It’s also important to remember that certain deductions and credits may change once S corp status is elected. For example, while employee benefits like health insurance can still be deducted, how they’re reported may differ.

Electing S Status for a Corporate Entity Under the Check-the-Box Rules

As discussed, you can seek S corporation election for your LLC. If you do make this election, you will:

1. Need to transfer all of your company's assets and liabilities to the corporation.

2. Distribute stocks to your owners. 

This is a tax-free transfer, as long as you meet certain requirements. For example, your liabilities cannot exceed your assets. To complete this process, you will typically need to file Form 8832.

How to File for LLC S Corp Election

Filing for S corp status is a straightforward but time-sensitive process. To make the election:

  1. Form 2553: File IRS Form 2553, “Election by a Small Business Corporation,” signed by all members. This must generally be done within 2 months and 15 days of the start of the tax year.
  2. Meet Eligibility Requirements: The LLC must have no more than 100 shareholders, only one class of stock, and shareholders must be U.S. citizens or residents.
  3. Review Operating Agreement: Amend the LLC operating agreement to reflect S corp requirements, such as equal distribution rights.
  4. Set Up Payroll: If the owner will receive a salary, establish a payroll system and withhold payroll taxes.
  5. Update State Filings: Some states require additional forms or elections for state-level S corp recognition.

Missing the election deadline may result in delayed S corp status until the next tax year, though the IRS sometimes grants relief for late elections if there’s a reasonable cause.

Potential One-Class-of-Stock Issues

If you do elect S status, you will need to ensure that all of your paperwork conforms to the requirements of an S corporation. This is particularly true in relation to your operating agreement. For example, if your current LLC operating agreement allows for special treatment of certain members, this would mean that you have more than one stock. In this case, you would not be eligible for S corporation status. 

Please note that an S corporation's shareholders must all be of the same class. This means that you cannot distribute special rights among different shareholders. This is where your operating agreement may differ if you were previously operating as a partnership. If you are unfamiliar, it is recommended that you thoroughly understand the" one class of stock requirement" as stated by the IRS. 

Overall, being classified as an S corporation offers some clear advantages in how you distribute your money and in turn, pay taxes. There are some restrictions, however, S corporation requirements do not often cause issues for small businesses. For example, you cannot have more than 100 shareholders. If you are unsure whether your LLC would benefit from S corp election, it is best to seek professional advice. 

Compliance and Common Mistakes to Avoid

Once your LLC has elected S corp status, maintaining compliance is essential. Common pitfalls include:

  • Unreasonable Salary: Paying yourself too little can trigger IRS audits. Salaries should reflect what similar businesses pay for comparable roles.
  • Multiple Classes of Stock: Introducing preferred distributions or different voting rights can disqualify your S corp election.
  • Ineligible Shareholders: Non-resident aliens, corporations, and partnerships cannot be shareholders.
  • Improper Recordkeeping: Failing to document shareholder meetings, payroll records, or distributions properly may lead to penalties or revoked S corp status.

Regularly reviewing IRS guidelines and working with a tax professional can help avoid these errors and preserve the benefits of S corp status.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. Can any LLC become an S corporation?
    Not all LLCs qualify. The business must have fewer than 100 shareholders, only one class of stock, and shareholders must be U.S. citizens or residents.
  2. How do I know if electing S corp status is worth it?
    If your business generates consistent profits above the owner’s reasonable salary, S corp election may significantly reduce self-employment taxes.
  3. What happens if I miss the Form 2553 deadline?
    You may have to wait until the following tax year to gain S corp status. In some cases, the IRS grants late election relief.
  4. Can I reverse an S corp election?
    Yes, but once revoked, you generally must wait five years before re-electing S corp status unless the IRS grants an exception.
  5. Do state tax laws recognize S corp status?
    Not always. Some states treat S corps differently or require additional elections, so it’s important to check your state’s specific tax requirements.

If you need help understanding LLC S corp election, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.