Contract Manufacturing vs Licensing: Choosing the Right Path

Key Takeaways

• Licensing lets inventors earn royalties by granting production rights to others, with minimal operational risk.
• Manufacturing allows inventors to retain full control but comes with higher startup costs and operational complexity.
• Contract manufacturing is a hybrid option where inventors outsource production but retain branding and marketing rights.
• Each model suits different goals: licensing favors inventors seeking passive income, while manufacturing suits those wanting control and long-term scalability.
• The decision depends on factors like product complexity, funding, speed to market, and desired involvement.

When deciding between licensing vs manufacturing your invention, there are a lot of aspects to consider. Depending on your long-term goals for your product or process, one avenue may prove more beneficial or lucrative than the other. As you decide, you'll want to know the basic differences between each choice.

How to License Your Invention

When a patent owner chooses to license their invention, they simply agree to allow another party to purchase the rights to their protected intellectual property. Patent licenses are usually only for a set period of time. In return for licensing the rights to your invention, you'll receive a previously agreed-upon payment amount. Sometimes payment for licensing a patent comes in a payments sequence referred to as royalties.

The patent owner is the licenser, and the party paying for the rights to the patented invention is the licensee. Usually, the party that is licensing the invention is doing so in order to manufacture and market it.

How to Manufacture Your Invention

Some patent owners will choose to manufacture their inventions themselves rather than licensing the rights for manufacturing to another party. This means that the patent owner remains in complete control of their invention, but they also have the full responsibility of coordinating the manufacturing process either in their own country or overseas.

If choosing to manufacture your own invention, you'll need to hire a company to create or build the invention. This is appealing to inventors who have a very specific vision for their invention and therefore what to maintain control of the process. However, when an inventor manufactures on their own, they do accept some risks and potential costs that come with the process.

What Is Contract Manufacturing?

Contract manufacturing is a business arrangement where a company hires a third-party manufacturer to produce goods on its behalf. This model allows inventors and small businesses to retain control over product design, branding, and marketing while outsourcing the actual manufacturing process.

Key benefits of contract manufacturing include:

• Lower upfront investment compared to setting up your own facility
• Flexibility to scale production based on demand
• Access to experienced manufacturers with established supply chains
• Quality control through customized production agreements

This model is especially useful for entrepreneurs who want to bring a product to market quickly without the operational burden of manufacturing.

Advantages of Licensing

There are some perks that come with signing a licensing agreement for your invention. These include:

• Saved expenses on prototypes.
• Income from royalties.
• Less risk.
• Opportunity to focus on future inventions while others take the last idea to market.
• Less involvement required from the inventor in the entire process post-invention.

Disadvantages of Licensing

One of the most notable disadvantages of licensing a patent is that the inventor relinquishes quite a bit of control when it comes to the production and marketing of their invention. Once another party purchases rights to the invention, they may choose to change the name of the invention or its appearance or suggested pricing.

Negotiating the licensing agreement is a difficult and intimidating process at times, especially without the help of an experienced lawyer. Another disadvantage of licensing is the potential for delays in the product making it to market. It can also be tough to find someone to license your patent to in order for them to handle the manufacturing. If a licensing agreement goes poorly, it could lead to legal issues and loss of time and money.

Advantages of Manufacturing

When a patent owner decides to handle the manufacturing process of their invention themselves, they gain some advantages. Usually, inventions manufactured by their inventors make it to market faster when production is properly handled. The inventor retains control over the future of their invention. There's usually more potential for profit for the inventor when they manufacture themselves rather than just accepting royalties.

Disadvantages of Manufacturing

There are some disadvantages to consider when choosing between licensing or manufacturing your patented invention. For instance, it is typically less expensive to produce a virtual prototype than a physical one, but manufacturing requires a physical prototype. Along these lines, starting an inventory of your product is very costly on your own.

Some inventors will seek investors to help them cover the beginning costs of the manufacturing process. This practice helps the inventor maintain creative control while gaining some help with expenses.

Inventors who decide to handle manufacturing on their own will usually need to start a business of some sort. Corporations are a good choice because they allow for many investors, but they take time and money to start. You can see how this manufacturing process can quickly get very complicated and time-consuming.

Maintaining control of their product is worth the effort to many inventors, but others will choose the route that is usually easier by going with licensing. Basically, manufacturing offers a higher potential for reward but brings higher risk along the way. Licensing is a lower risk with a typically lower cash potential.

When to Choose Contract Manufacturing

Contract manufacturing is a suitable route if:

• You want to maintain branding and control over how your product is marketed
• You have limited capital to invest in your own production facility
• You prefer to focus on sales, distribution, and customer engagement
• Your product requires specialized manufacturing expertise you don’t have in-house
• You want the ability to switch manufacturers if quality or cost concerns arise

This model is commonly used by startups, direct-to-consumer brands, and even large companies outsourcing specialized components.

Licensing vs Contract Manufacturing: Key Differences

When comparing contract manufacturing vs licensing, it’s important to understand that these models differ significantly in ownership, risk, and control. Here’s a breakdown:

This comparison helps clarify that licensing is ideal for inventors seeking minimal operational involvement, while contract manufacturing suits those who want to scale a business with manageable risk.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What is the main difference between licensing and contract manufacturing?
   Licensing transfers production and marketing rights to another party, while contract manufacturing outsources only production—keeping control with the original owner.
2. Is contract manufacturing more profitable than licensing?
   It can be, since you retain full revenue from product sales instead of just earning royalties, though it also carries more risk and responsibility.
3. Can I switch from licensing to manufacturing later?
   Yes, many inventors license initially to reduce risk and later switch to manufacturing once they have capital and market proof.
4. What are the risks of contract manufacturing?
   Risks include quality issues, supply chain disruptions, and potential conflicts with the manufacturer. These can be mitigated with strong contracts and oversight.
5. Do I need a business entity to use contract manufacturing?
   While not legally required in all cases, having a formal business entity (like an LLC or corporation) is highly recommended for liability and contractual purposes.

If you need help with understanding licensing versus manufacturing, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.