Key Takeaways

  • The liability of the owner varies based on business structure—sole proprietors and general partners face unlimited liability, while LLCs and corporations offer protection.
  • Owners can still face personal liability if they fail to maintain corporate formalities, personally guarantee debts, or engage in misconduct.
  • “Piercing the corporate veil” is a legal mechanism that allows courts to hold business owners personally liable in specific circumstances.
  • Certain industries or actions, such as fraud, wage violations, or environmental harm, may trigger direct liability regardless of the business structure.
  • Business liability insurance and sound legal practices reduce risk, but don’t fully shield against all types of owner liability.

Risks of Unlimited Liability

Business owners who do not protect their personal liability may be subject to four different categories of risk: business, financial, unsystematic, and systematic.

  • Financial risk occurs if the business defaults from obligations to lenders and creditors. If the business itself cannot meet these obligations, the business owner is responsible.
  • Business risk occurs if the business does not generate the cash flow to meet its operating expenses. If vendors and service providers cannot be paid, the owner must close the business.
  • Systematic risk is the risk for all business owners in a down economy.
  • Unsystematic risk is the industry-specific risk for business owners in an economic downturn.

When Courts Disregard Limited Liability

Even if a business is organized as an LLC or corporation, courts may still “pierce the corporate veil” to hold owners personally liable. This typically happens when:

  • Owners fail to keep business and personal finances separate
  • Corporate formalities like annual meetings and recordkeeping are neglected
  • The business is undercapitalized or used to commit fraud
  • Owners use the business for personal transactions or to evade legal obligations

Courts look for these red flags to determine whether the business is merely a facade for individual dealings. If so, they may hold the owner liable for company debts and legal judgments.

Common Business Liabilities

A liability is any financial obligation of your business. Some of the most common business liabilities for which an owner can find him or herself personally responsible include:

  • Loans, mortgages, and other types of debt
  • Income tax and other taxes payable
  • Employee wages and salaries
  • Prepayments and deposits
  • Personal injuries that occur on the business property
  • Employee injury that results from lack of safety training or neglect of safety regulations
  • Injury caused by a defective product
  • Violation of wage laws
  • Malpractice and other forms of negligence
  • False advertising
  • Leaking customer or employee data
  • Environmental damage
  • Negligence of local zoning laws
  • Violation of intellectual property laws

If your business is sued, it doesn't necessarily mean you will be found guilty. It's important to retain an experienced attorney who can protect your business and personal interests.

High-Risk Scenarios That Trigger Personal Liability

Certain business actions increase the chances of personal liability, even when limited liability protections are in place:

  • Signing contracts in a personal capacity instead of on behalf of the business
  • Personally guaranteeing business loans
  • Failing to remit payroll taxes or sales taxes to the government
  • Engaging in fraudulent or negligent conduct, such as misleading investors or violating safety laws
  • Misclassifying employees as independent contractors

These actions can result in legal claims against the individual owner and may expose personal assets to creditors.

The Role of Business Structure

Creating a separate legal entity for your small business is the first step to separating your personal liability from your business liability. If you are running a business but have not established a legal structure, you own either a sole proprietorship or general partnership by default. Although these are the most basic business structures, they do not provide legal separation. That means if your business gets sued, you are personally getting sued. Your personal property, savings, and assets can all be seized in a court judgment if you are found at fault.

A limited liability company (LLC) is relatively simple to establish and manage and provides limited liability, which means that you are not personally liable for business debts and obligations beyond the amount of your investment in the business. That's because an LLC is legally recognized as a separate entity.

However, even with an LLC, you can still be found personally liable for business debts if:

  • You have provided a personal guarantee for a business loan.
  • You have signed a business contract not in the name of the business, but in your own name.
  • You commit a crime in the course of running your business.
  • You injure someone in the course of business.
  • You do not maintain your LLC in good standing. This requires you to keep up with annual fees and filings as well as to keep separate accounts for your business and personal finances.

How to Reduce the Liability of the Owner

While the right business structure offers liability protection, owners must actively maintain that shield. Best practices to minimize liability of the owner include:

  • Keeping clear records and separating business and personal accounts
  • Using the full legal name of the business when entering into contracts
  • Staying compliant with corporate governance requirements (e.g., filing annual reports, maintaining a registered agent)
  • Having clear employee policies and following labor laws
  • Maintaining appropriate insurance coverage
  • Seeking legal advice before making major business decisions

These steps can help prevent disputes and reduce the risk of personal exposure if the business faces lawsuits or debt collection.

Business Liability Insurance

Purchasing this type of policy can insulate your small business from property damages or personal injury lawsuits. The exact business liability insurance you need depends on the type of company you have, so it's important to consult an insurance agent who is familiar with your industry.

The three main types of business liability policies include:

  • General liability insurance to protect against property damage, advertising claims, negligence claims, and personal injury claims. Many businesses only need general liability insurance.
  • Product liability insurance protects you if you manufacture and sell a defective product that causes injury.
  • Professional liability insurance protects against omissions, negligence, errors, and malpractice for businesses which provide a service.

Some types of professionals, such as doctors and lawyers, are required to have business insurance.

Industry-Specific Liability Considerations

The liability of the owner can also depend on the industry. For example:

  • Construction companies may face personal liability for building code violations or contractor licensing issues
  • Healthcare professionals can be personally liable for malpractice
  • Environmental regulations can expose manufacturing business owners to cleanup costs if violations occur
  • Data breaches in tech and e-commerce businesses may result in lawsuits over negligence in protecting sensitive information

Understanding the liability trends and legal requirements in your specific industry is critical to effective risk management.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. Can an LLC owner be held personally liable?
    Yes, in cases of fraud, co-mingling funds, or personal guarantees, courts can hold an LLC owner personally liable.
  2. What does “piercing the corporate veil” mean?
    It’s a legal action where a court holds owners personally liable when they misuse the corporate structure.
  3. How can I protect myself from personal liability as a business owner?
    Choose the right structure, separate finances, follow legal formalities, and get adequate insurance coverage.
  4. What business actions make owners personally liable?
    Personally signing contracts, failing to pay taxes, committing fraud, or violating regulations may lead to personal liability.
  5. Does business insurance fully protect against owner liability?
    No. Insurance helps manage risk but doesn’t cover illegal acts, personal guarantees, or poor corporate practices.

If you need help with business owner liability, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.