Key Takeaways

  • The legal definition of war involves both an act and a state of conflict between parties, typically nations, recognized by law.
  • Wars can be public (civil or national) or private; public wars are either civil wars within a state or national wars between independent nations.
  • National wars can be offensive or defensive, with legal perspectives often focusing on the initiating act of violence.
  • Legal recognition of war typically requires a formal declaration by the constitutionally authorized body, such as the U.S. Congress.
  • Modern law of war also addresses international treaties, self-defense, and the United Nations Charter, which restricts the use of force.

What Is the Legal Definition of War?

A contention by force; or the art of paralyzing the forces of an enemy.

It is either public or private. It is not intended here to speak of the latter.

Historical and Modern Legal Context of War

The legal definition of war has evolved over centuries. Historically, declaring war required a sovereign state to formally announce hostilities, giving combatants lawful status under international law. However, since the adoption of the United Nations Charter in 1945, the legal meaning has shifted. Article 2(4) of the Charter prohibits the threat or use of force against another state's territorial integrity or political independence, effectively restricting traditional declarations of war.

Modern legal frameworks focus less on whether a conflict is labeled “war” and more on whether the use of force complies with international law, including self-defense and humanitarian considerations. Conflicts like the 1937–1941 fighting in Manchuria, where Japan refused to call the hostilities a war, illustrate the blurred boundaries between war and undeclared military action.

Is Public War Civil or National?

Public war is either civil or national. Civil war is that which is waged between two parties, citizens or members of the same state or nation. National war is a contest between two or more independent nations) carried on by authority of their respective governments.

Criteria for Identifying Acts of War

In addition to distinguishing civil and national wars, courts and international bodies often examine whether certain actions qualify as an act of war. These can include:

  • Armed attacks or invasions of foreign territory
  • Naval blockades or seizure of military assets
  • Attacks on a nation's armed forces, even outside its borders

Insurance policies, treaties, and domestic laws may rely on these criteria to determine liability, particularly in war-risk or force majeure cases.

Further Explanation of War

War is not only an act, but a state or condition, for nations are said to be at war not only when their armies are engaged, so as to be in the very act of contention, but also when, they have any matter of controversy or dispute subsisting between them which they are determined to decide by the use of force, and have declared publicly, or by their acts, their determination so to decide it.

International Law and the Law of War

The law of war, also known as international humanitarian law, governs the conduct of armed conflicts. It includes rules that:

  • Protect civilians and limit unnecessary suffering
  • Define combatant status and the treatment of prisoners of war
  • Restrict the use of certain weapons, such as chemical or biological arms

The Geneva Conventions and Hague Conventions are the primary sources of the law of war, which aim to balance military necessity with humanitarian considerations. Violations may lead to war crimes or international sanctions, even if a conflict is not formally declared.

Explanation of National Wars

National wars are said to be offensive or defensive. War is offensive on the part of that government which commits the first act of violence; it is defensive on the part of that government which receives such act; but it is very difficult to say what is the first act of violence. If a nation sees itself menaced with an attack, its first act of violence to prevent such attack, will be considered as defensive.

Self-Defense and Preventive Actions

The distinction between offensive and defensive wars is crucial for international legitimacy. A nation may lawfully engage in war under two main scenarios:

  1. In response to an armed attack under Article 51 of the UN Charter (self-defense).
  2. When authorized by the United Nations Security Council to maintain or restore international peace.

Preventive or preemptive strikes may be framed as defensive, but international law generally scrutinizes such actions carefully, often questioning whether they meet the self-defense threshold.

How Is War Legalized?

To legalize a war it must be declared by that branch of the government entrusted by the Constitution with this power. And it seems it need not be declared by both the belligerent powers. By the Constitution of the United States, Art. I, Congress is invested with power "to declare war, grant letters of marque and reprisal, and make rules concerning captures on land and water; and they have also the power to raise and support armies, and to provide and maintain a navy."

Consequences of Declaring or Avoiding War

Formally declaring war triggers significant legal and political consequences:

  • Domestic implications: Mobilization of armed forces, emergency powers, and wartime legislation.
  • International recognition: Establishes belligerent rights and clarifies the status of prisoners of war.
  • Insurance and commercial impact: Contracts may include war-risk clauses, and insurance coverage can change when a state of war exists.

Conversely, avoiding a formal declaration may allow states to engage in hostilities while sidestepping full legal accountability, a practice observed in many post–World War II conflicts.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. What is the legal definition of war?
    Legally, war is a recognized state of armed conflict between parties, usually nations, that triggers domestic and international laws on combat, treaties, and responsibilities.
  2. Can a war exist without a formal declaration?
    Yes. Modern conflicts are often undeclared but still subject to international law, including the Geneva Conventions and UN Charter rules.
  3. What is the difference between civil and national war?
    Civil wars occur within a single nation between internal factions, while national wars involve armed conflict between two or more independent states.
  4. Who has the authority to declare war in the U.S.?
    Under Article I of the U.S. Constitution, only Congress has the power to declare war, though military actions can occur without formal declarations.
  5. How does international law limit war today?
    International law, especially the UN Charter and Geneva Conventions, restricts the use of force to self-defense or UN-approved missions and regulates the treatment of civilians and combatants.

If you need help with understanding legal definition of war, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel’s marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.