Key Takeaways

  • Fiction law definition: A fiction of law is a legal assumption that treats something false as true for legal purposes, allowing courts and legislatures to achieve fairness or efficiency.
  • Origins: Rooted in Roman law, legal fictions helped adapt rigid statutes to new circumstances without formally changing them.
  • Purpose: They simplify complex legal rules, resolve disputes, or extend jurisdiction where direct legal authority is lacking.
  • Examples: Corporate personhood, constructive possession, and the legal presumption that a missing person is dead after a set period.
  • Criticisms: While they aid justice, critics argue fiction law can mask judicial overreach, blur truth, or endanger individual rights if stretched beyond their intended limits.
  • Modern use: Courts still employ fictions cautiously, ensuring they align with equity and do not conflict with reason or possibility.

The assumption that a certain thing is true, and which gives to a person or thing a quality which is not natural to it, and consequently establishes, a certain disposition, which, without the fiction, would be repugnant to reason and to truth. It is an order of things which does not exist, but which the law prescribes or authorizes. It differs from presumption because it establishes as true, something which is false; whereas presumption supplies the proof of something true.

The law never feigns what is impossible. Fiction is like art; it imitates nature, but never disfigures it. It aids truth, but it ought never to destroy it. It may well suppose that what was possible, but which does not exist; but it will never feign that what was impossible actually is.

Fictions were invented by the Roman praetors who, not possessing the power to abrogate the law, were nevertheless willing to derogate from it under the pretence of doing equity. Fiction is the resource of weakness which, in order to obtain its object, assumes as a fact what is known to be contrary to truth: when the legislator desires to accomplish his object, he need not feign, he commands. Fictions of law owe their origin to the legislative usurpations of the bench.

It is said that every fiction must be framed according to the rules of law, and that every legal fiction must have equity for its object. To prevent their evil effects, they are not allowed to be carried further than the reasons which introduced them necessarily require.

Examples of Fictions

The law abounds in fictions. That an estate is in abeyance; the doctrine of remitter, by which a party who has been disseised of his freehold and afterwards acquires a defective title, is remitted to his former good title; that one thing done today, is considered as done at a preceding time by the doctrine of relation; that because one thing is proved, another shall be presumed to be true, which is the case in all presumptions; that the heir, executor, and administrator stand by representation in the place of the deceased are all fictions of law. "Our various introduction of John Doe and Richard Roe; our solemn process upon disseisin by Hugh Hunt; our casually losing and finding a ship (which never was in Europe) in the parish of St. Mary Le Bow, in the ward of Cheap; our trying the validity of a will by an imaginary wager of five pounds; our imagining and compassing the king's death, by giving information which may defeat an attack upon an enemy's settlement in the antipodes; our charge of picking a pocket or forging a bill with force and arms; of neglecting to repair a bridge, against the peace of the king, his crown and dignity are circumstances, which, looked at by themselves, would convey an impression of no very favorable nature, with respect to the wisdom of our jurisprudence."

Purpose and Function of Fiction Law

Fiction law serves as a practical tool that allows the legal system to adapt without rewriting statutes for every new situation. Courts and lawmakers use legal fictions to:

  • Simplify procedures: For example, treating corporations as “persons” enables them to sue, be sued, and own property.
  • Extend jurisdiction: Courts may assume a defendant is present within a jurisdiction, even if physically absent, to ensure justice can proceed.
  • Resolve disputes fairly: Fictions may be used to validate contracts, protect property rights, or address inheritance questions where rigid law would cause injustice.
    By doing so, fiction law maintains consistency while allowing flexibility in judicial reasoning.

Historical Development

 The roots of fiction law trace back to Roman praetors, who introduced fictions to adapt laws without formally repealing them. This method later influenced English common law, where legal fictions became essential in property and contract disputes. For instance, the use of “John Doe” and “Richard Roe” in ejectment actions was a legal fiction designed to streamline land disputes. Over time, these fictions shaped doctrines such as corporate personhood and constructive notice, embedding themselves deeply into modern legal systems. 

Criticism and Limitations

Despite their usefulness, legal fictions are not without controversy. Critics argue they can obscure truth, reinforce outdated doctrines, or permit judicial overreach. For example, some legal scholars warn that treating corporations as people under the law can blur distinctions between natural and artificial entities, giving corporations rights not intended for them. Additionally, excessive reliance on fictions may undermine individual rights, especially when courts assume facts that contradict reality. To mitigate these risks, legal systems limit fictions to contexts where they serve equity and prevent injustice, ensuring they do not conflict with reason or impossibility.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. What is fiction law in simple terms?
    Fiction law is a legal assumption that treats something false as true so courts can apply laws more fairly or efficiently.
  2. Why does the law use legal fictions?
    They simplify complex cases, extend jurisdiction, or allow the law to adapt without constant legislative changes.
  3. What is an example of fiction law?
    One well-known example is corporate personhood, where a company is treated as a “person” for legal purposes.
  4. Are legal fictions the same as presumptions?
    No. Presumptions assume something likely to be true, while fictions deliberately treat something false as true.
  5. Can fiction law be misused?
    Yes. Critics argue that misuse can undermine fairness, blur reality, and even endanger individual rights if stretched too far.

If you need help identifying what is fiction law, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel’s marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.