Key Takeaways

  • A promissory note is a negotiable instrument if it is unconditional, in writing, signed, and payable to order or bearer.
  • It must meet the criteria outlined in the Uniform Commercial Code (UCC) to qualify as negotiable.
  • Non-negotiable promissory notes still have legal force but lack the transferability and holder-in-due-course protections.
  • Negotiability adds value by making promissory notes transferable, enforceable by third parties, and easier to use in financial transactions.
  • Exceptions exist—certain clauses or conditions may disqualify a note from being negotiable.Is a promissory note a negotiable instrument? Yes; this type of negotiable instrument can be transferred by its holder just as cash can be transferred. Promissory notes are used for many reasons, such as to create debt between private parties that can be legally enforced and by limited liability company (LLC) members to make capital contributions to the business.

Elements of an Enforceable Promissory Note

A promissory note is not considered legally binding unless it meets all these conditions:

  • No conditions are to be fulfilled prior to payment being made.
  • It must have a written statement in which one party promises to pay the other party a specific sum of money.
  • The principal amount indicated on the note must be static, though the interest amount can be variable. However, it must also be considered reasonable by the court.
  • It must contain the words "pay to the order of" with either the person's name or the term bearer.
  • It must be payable either on demand or within a specific time frame, such as "two weeks after the note is presented for payment."
  • It does not require the indebted individual to act in any way besides making the required payment.
  • It must be payable in money. A promissory note to pay back $1,000 in gold or diamonds is not valid.

UCC Requirements for Negotiability

To answer the question "is a promissory note a negotiable instrument," one must refer to the Uniform Commercial Code (UCC) § 3-104, which outlines the key requirements:

  • Written and Signed: The note must be in writing and signed by the maker.
  • Unconditional Promise: It must contain an unconditional promise or order to pay.
  • Fixed Amount of Money: The amount to be paid must be specific and not subject to change (excluding interest).
  • Payable on Demand or at a Definite Time: The payment date must be certain.
  • Payable to Order or Bearer: It must state that it is payable either to a specific person (order) or to whoever holds the instrument (bearer).

Failure to meet any of these requirements renders the note non-negotiable, although it may still be legally binding.

Types of Negotiable Instruments

Drafts and notes are the main types of negotiable instruments. While a note is a promise, a draft is an order and must involve three parties. The promissory note only involves two parties, the person who makes the note and the one who pays it. Notes focus on debts while drafts are specifically used only for payments.

Notes represent a bank or private loan in an official way that makes the debt legally enforceable. A promissory note does not simply indicate that a debt exists; it must also indicate the exact amount and terms for repayment.

Common uses of promissory notes include obtaining capital to run a business or borrowing money to finance a real estate purchase. For example, the promissory note for a mortgage would indicate the total loan amount, the interest rate, and the maturation date.

Promissory notes are subject to somewhat stringent government regulations since left unchecked they could constitute private currency. In fact, promissory notes once served exactly that purpose. Paper money is actually a promissory note since it contains a promise that the government bank will pay the bearer of the bill a specific amount. These notes could once be exchanged for gold.

Unlike a promissory note, a draft or check requires three parties: the person who writes the check, the person to whom the check is payable, and the drawee, or the bank, that pays the specified amount when presented with the check.

A time check or draft is payable at a specific time and date. A sight draft is payable when it is accepted. Goods are often sold with trade acceptance, a type of draft that can be sold to a third party to raise money.

A certificate of deposit (CD) is a type of note in which a bank indicates that it has received funds from an individual and promises to repay that amount plus interest on a certain future date. CDs are a good investment because of their high interest rates.

Benefits and Risks of Negotiable Promissory Notes

Negotiable promissory notes offer several advantages:

  • Transferability: They can be endorsed and transferred like cash.
  • Enforceability: A holder in due course can enforce the note even if there are issues between the original parties.
  • Liquidity: These notes can be sold to third parties for immediate cash flow.

However, they also carry risks:

  • Limited Defenses: The maker of the note has fewer defenses against a holder in due course.
  • Potential for Fraud: Because of their transferable nature, unauthorized endorsements or misuse can lead to disputes.

The Concept of Negotiability

A negotiable instrument must be a written document signed by the person who created it. It must contain a promise to pay a certain amount without conditions. This must be an exact amount, with or without interest, that is either payable at a specific future date or on demand to a specific individual. The negotiable instrument gives someone credit or serves as a substitute for money, and must be easy to transfer while remaining collectible.

Checks, bills of exchange, and promissory notes are all considered negotiable instruments because the person who holds these notes can claim payment provided that they are taken:

Because the endorser has the liability of ensuring that a promissory note is in good title, this is a very secure type of negotiable instrument.

Real-World Applications of Promissory Notes

Promissory notes are used across various sectors:

  • Real Estate: Mortgage loans often involve promissory notes that specify payment terms and interest rates.
  • Business Financing: Startups and small businesses use promissory notes to secure loans from investors or founders.
  • Personal Lending: Friends or family members may use promissory notes to document informal loans with legal backing.

These applications rely on the negotiability of the note to ensure legal enforceability and the ability to sell or assign the obligation if needed.

Non-Negotiable Promissory Notes

A promissory note that does not meet the UCC's standards is non-negotiable, meaning it:

  • Cannot be transferred in a way that allows the transferee to become a holder in due course.
  • Lacks the same legal protections for third-party holders.
  • Must still meet contract law standards to be enforceable.

Common reasons a note may be non-negotiable include:

  • Inclusion of conditions for repayment.
  • Unspecified repayment dates.
  • Missing “pay to the order of” or “bearer” language.

While these notes still represent binding agreements, their transfer and enforcement are more limited.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What makes a promissory note negotiable? A promissory note is negotiable if it is written, signed, contains an unconditional promise to pay a fixed sum, is payable on demand or at a definite time, and is payable to order or bearer.

2. Can a promissory note be non-negotiable and still enforceable? Yes, a non-negotiable promissory note is still enforceable as a contract but lacks the transferability and holder-in-due-course protections of a negotiable instrument.

3. What’s the difference between a promissory note and a check? A promissory note is a promise to pay and involves two parties. A check is an order to pay and involves three parties: the drawer, the payee, and the drawee (usually a bank).

4. Who benefits from a negotiable promissory note? Both the payee and any third-party holder (such as a lender or investor) benefit due to the ease of enforcement and transferability.

5. Can you add terms like collateral or interest to a negotiable note? Yes, as long as these terms do not make the promise to pay conditional or otherwise violate the UCC's requirements for negotiability.

If you need help with a promissory note or negotiable instrument, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.