Key Takeaways

  • The CEO serves as the company’s leader, accountable to the board, stockholders, and customers.
  • The board of directors holds the power to remove a CEO, often through a majority vote.
  • CEO removal can occur due to performance issues, financial misconduct, breach of fiduciary duties, or stakeholder dissatisfaction.
  • Shareholder agreements and corporate bylaws dictate the process for CEO removal.
  • A CEO’s contract may outline severance terms and legal grounds for termination.
  • Founders can also be ousted if they lose control of voting shares or fall out of favor with investors.
  • Legal and strategic planning is essential to ensure a smooth transition and minimize legal repercussions.
  • Consulting legal professionals helps ensure compliance with corporate governance and contractual obligations.

Knowing how to remove a CEO from a corporation is a crucial tool for a company's shareholders. The role of CEO is unique within an organization because they don't have a manager to report to. Instead, they need to look after the well-being of three different groups. Investors need to be kept satisfied with profit and results, employees have to be motivated, and, last but not least, the CEO is ultimately responsible for customer satisfaction.

CEO Role

This task of pleasing such a diverse group of people is similar only to what politicians do, and it's largely the reason why CEOs command disproportionately higher salaries than anyone else within their organization.

Their roles are kept in place by contracts, and their salaries are determined by the company's board. However, there are no clear specifications regarding the amount of time a CEO needs to spend at work. While some are hands-on managers, others prefer to delegate responsibilities and only actively participate in the managing process for a few hours every month.

The pressure that comes with this job is enormous, and it is common for CEOs to have severe personal problems because they must often neglect the people around them for the sake of their job.

Legal Grounds for Removing a CEO

A CEO’s employment contract and corporate bylaws dictate the conditions under which they can be removed. Common legal grounds for ousting a CEO include:

  • Breach of fiduciary duty – If a CEO acts against the company’s best interests, such as engaging in self-dealing or conflicts of interest.
  • Financial misconduct – Fraud, embezzlement, or misrepresentation of financial statements.
  • Poor performance – Consistently failing to meet company goals or causing financial downturns.
  • Loss of board confidence – If the board determines the CEO is unfit to lead due to leadership failures or strategic misalignment.
  • Shareholder pressure – In cases where major shareholders demand leadership changes for better company performance.

Before initiating removal, it’s crucial to review the CEO’s contract, the corporate charter, and any shareholder agreements that outline dismissal procedures

Shareholder and Board Influence in CEO Removal

The balance of power between shareholders and the board determines how a CEO can be removed. In most private companies:

  • The board of directors has the final say – The board can remove the CEO with a majority vote unless restricted by company bylaws.
  • Majority shareholders can exert pressure – If a group of shareholders owns a significant percentage of voting shares, they can influence the board to act.
  • Shareholder agreements may provide direct authority – Some agreements allow shareholders to vote directly on CEO dismissal, bypassing the board.
  • Founder status does not guarantee protection – Even a company founder can be removed if they lose voting control or breach contractual obligations​.

In practice, shareholder activism and board dynamics play a major role in CEO turnover, especially when investors seek leadership changes to improve financial performance​.

CEOs and Stockholders

It's not uncommon for one or more stakeholders to get the CEO fired, even in situations where the same person founded the company. That was the case with Steve Jobs, who was pushed out of Apple for a period of time. Company founders are not spared because as companies get bigger, their stock gets diluted, making what was once a majority share shrink below 50%. Companies often outgrow their founders for various reasons, the most common being that they had a very good idea and entrepreneurial mindset, but failed to properly manage and execute afterward.

For these reasons, CEOs and company founders must take precautionary measures and establish close relationships with board members and stockholders. Recognizing the job's volatility and getting written promises by important members of the organization are the keys to longevity in such a demanding position. In any major company, there will be groups of people pushing for a new CEO, but for him or her to be fired, a decision must be made by the company's board, the very same people that share the task of protecting the CEO.

Ways to Remove a CEO

Here are some effective ways to remove an organization's CEO.

  • One way to eliminate a CEO is to make them burn out by giving more responsibilities than they can handle. Removing the chairman might do the trick because the chairman often keeps the CEO grounded.
  • Another way to destabilize a CEO is to make them feel underqualified for the position and constantly scared of someone else gunning for the role. That leads the CEO to avoid selecting the best people to be on his or her team out of fear that one of them will eventually take the top job. A bad team leads to bad results, and bad results get CEOs fired.
  • As the primary defendant of a company's image, the CEO's own image can lead to their downfall. Even the best-trained CEO can be made to look like a fool if the information he or she is getting is inaccurate. Therefore, an efficient way of forcing them out of the job is to create a fake impression of accurate information, leading to bad decisions and the board having to dismiss the CEO.
  • A different approach to removing a CEO, especially a very new one, is keeping a former CEO within the organization. Employees will have a natural tendency to report to their old boss, who in turn will undermine the new boss as much as possible. The combination of employees not properly acknowledging the new hierarchy and the old CEO actively sabotaging the new one's role will most often lead to the new one not being able to do a proper job. Dismissal by the board is only a matter of time.

The decision to remove the CEO is the hardest part of the whole process. Once that has been made, the actual firing process is relatively simple and straightforward. The company's main concern afterward should be taking precautionary measures against a potential lawsuit.

The Step-by-Step Process to Oust a CEO

  1. Assess Legal Grounds & Documentation
    • Review the CEO’s employment contract.
    • Check corporate bylaws and shareholder agreements.
    • Identify valid reasons that align with company policies.
  2. Build Board Consensus
    • Hold discussions with board members to evaluate CEO performance.
    • Secure majority board approval before initiating action.
  3. Engage Legal Counsel
    • Consult attorneys to ensure the removal process complies with corporate governance and contract law.
    • Prepare documentation to justify the decision.
  4. Notify the CEO & Negotiate Terms
    • Schedule a private meeting to inform the CEO.
    • Discuss severance packages, transition responsibilities, and legal obligations.
  5. Announce Leadership Change
    • Communicate the decision internally to employees and externally to stakeholders.
    • Appoint an interim CEO or initiate the search for a replacement.
  6. Mitigate Risks & Ensure Business Continuity
    • Prevent potential lawsuits by offering a fair severance package.
    • Secure company assets, intellectual property, and confidential information.

Proper execution of these steps ensures a smooth transition and protects the company from legal disputes​.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. Can shareholders remove a CEO in a private company?
    Yes, but it depends on the corporate bylaws and shareholder agreements. In most cases, the board of directors has the power to remove the CEO, but majority shareholders can influence the decision.
  2. What legal risks should be considered when ousting a CEO?
    Legal risks include wrongful termination lawsuits, breach of contract claims, and shareholder disputes. Consulting legal professionals helps mitigate these risks.
  3. Can a founder be fired from their own company?
    Yes, if they no longer control the majority of voting shares or if investors and the board determine their leadership is detrimental to the company.
  4. What is “termination for cause” in CEO contracts?
    It refers to dismissing a CEO due to misconduct, fraud, gross negligence, or breach of fiduciary duties. Termination for cause typically voids severance payouts​.
  5. 5. How long does the CEO removal process take?
    It depends on the company’s governance structure. In some cases, it can be swift (weeks), while in others, legal and procedural complexities may extend the process to months.

If you need help with removing the CEO from a corporation, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.