Key Takeaways

  • A fractional ownership agreement allows multiple parties to co-own an asset, granting usage rights and shared responsibilities.
  • Ownership can be structured through entities like LLCs or via tenancy in common (TIC).
  • These agreements must cover governance, access schedules, maintenance duties, resale rights, and conflict resolution processes.
  • Fractional ownership differs from timeshares by granting deeded ownership.
  • Legal, financial, and operational clarity is crucial to avoid disputes and ensure smooth co-ownership experiences.
  • Owners may earn rental income, but financing and resale may involve more complexity than full ownership.

A fractional ownership contract is one that is common in certain industries, including the aviation industry, vacation homes, timeshares, and other rental properties. Particularly, parties will divide an expensive asset into shares, thus allowing each owner to receive an interest in the asset for a fraction of the price. This gives the owners several privileges, including certain times to using the asset. The contract itself will allow multiple parties to share in the ownership of the asset.

Are Fractional Ownership Contracts Legal?

Yes, fractional ownership contracts are entirely legal so long as a written contract is entered into by and between the parties owning the asset. However, keep in mind that certain jurisdictions might not allow it; therefore, you should first check with the state where you want to enter into such a contract to find out if a particular city or town would allow it. States can’t prohibit it outright, but certain cities might. For such contracts, there is a certain language that should be included. You can check with the state’s website to find out if it offers such language. Note that California doesn’t offer it. Rather, the California Association of Realtors offers the language that can be used in a fractional ownership contract.

When writing this type of contract, you will need to clearly and concisely identify how the asset or piece of property will be distributed among owners, and the proportionate share each owner has over the asset or property. Additional information should be included in the contract as follows:

  1. Owner names/addresses
  2. Percentage of ownership
  3. The amount of capital each owner put into purchasing the asset
  4. Expenses, including who must pay what
  5. When and how long each owner has access to the asset
  6. Will access to it change every year?
  7. What other policies are included, i.e., one of the owners might not be able to use that asset on the allowable date during any given year
  8. Will the owners be allowed to further rent out the asset to another party? i.e., vacation home, whereby one of the owners wishes to rent out the home to unknown third parties during the time when which he can use the home

For example, let’s assume that 3 people purchased a vacation home in Florida. The contract states that John has use of the vacation home from January through April; Sue has access to it from May through August; Mary has access to it from September through December. Now let’s assume that John is unable to use the vacation home at any point during January, February, March, or April due to personal issues. How can all three of them find a solution to this? They should include such issues in the contract, for how they will handle this type of matter.

What to Include in a Fractional Ownership Agreement

To protect all parties and reduce future conflicts, a fractional ownership agreement should include:

  • Legal Structure: Specify whether the property is held under a TIC or LLC.
  • Ownership Details: Percentage ownership, capital contributions, and transfer rights.
  • Usage Schedules: How time is divided, rotation systems, and blackout dates.
  • Expense Allocation: Operating costs, taxes, maintenance, and reserves for capital improvements.
  • Management Roles: Who handles bookings, payments, and repairs—either internal or third-party.
  • Rental Terms: If permitted, how rental income is distributed and who coordinates it.
  • Exit Strategy: Procedures for selling a share, right of first refusal, and valuation methods.
  • Dispute Resolution: Mediation, arbitration, or litigation terms in the event of a disagreement.

A strong agreement ensures that all owners understand their rights and obligations from the outset.

How Are Ownership Costs Determined?

The costs will be divided among owners throughout the year. Such costs can include repairs, services, cleaning, etc. Since the costs will vary year after year, the owners should fully understand the cost variables while owning the asset. If the costs are to be predetermined in the fractional ownership contract, the parties should understand that the costs associated with the upkeep and maintenance of the asset will increase over the years. Therefore, they should include language in the contract to address the modification of the contract to meet the increase in costs.

How Does a Resale Occur?

Generally, when someone owns a piece of property, he or she will earn a profit once that property is resold; at least, that is the hope. If one of the owners of a fractional ownership asset wants to sell his or her share in the asset, there must be a process in place for approving the sale. Will the other owners require that he or she sell the ownership share to the other current owners? Or will the owners require that they first meet and interview the potential new owner before selling that ownership share to the new owner? These are all issues that should be addressed among owners before entering into a fractional ownership contract, as this will prevent legal issues down the line.

Pros and Cons of Fractional Ownership

Advantages:

  • Affordability: Makes high-value assets accessible by splitting costs among multiple owners.
  • Deeded Ownership: Unlike timeshares, fractional owners often hold a deeded interest, allowing for property appreciation and equity growth.
  • Defined Usage Rights: Agreements specify when each owner can use the property, providing structure and predictability.
  • Shared Expenses: Owners share maintenance, taxes, and other ongoing costs, easing the individual financial burden.
  • Potential Income: If allowed, properties can be rented out for additional revenue.

Drawbacks:

  • Limited Financing Options: Not all lenders offer fractional ownership mortgages, and terms may be restrictive.
  • Reduced Autonomy: All major decisions typically require group input or approval, which can delay action.
  • Resale Complexity: Selling a share can be difficult without buy-in from other owners or a willing third party.
  • Usage Conflicts: If not clearly scheduled in advance, disputes over access periods may arise.
  • Dependency on Group Harmony: Disagreements can hinder property management or future planning.

Fractional ownership can be rewarding but requires thoughtful planning and well-drafted legal agreements to avoid pitfalls.

Governance and Decision-Making in Fractional Ownership

Clear governance is essential in any fractional ownership agreement. Without a centralized authority, conflicts can arise over decisions related to usage, expenses, and repairs. To prevent disputes, agreements should establish:

  • A management structure, designating a manager, committee, or third-party firm.
  • Voting procedures for key decisions such as capital improvements or resale approvals.
  • Procedures for resolving disputes, such as mediation or arbitration clauses.

Including detailed governance provisions promotes transparency and reduces legal risk over the lifetime of the agreement.

Types of Fractional Ownership Structures

There are two primary structures for fractional ownership agreements:

  1. Tenancy in Common (TIC):
    Under this structure, each co-owner holds an individual, undivided share in the property. Ownership percentages can vary, and each owner receives a separate deed. TIC allows greater flexibility in transferring ownership, but decisions often require unanimous or majority owner approval.
  2. Entity-Based Ownership (LLC or LLP):
    In this model, the property is owned by a legal entity, such as a Limited Liability Company (LLC), and each investor owns a share of that entity. This structure simplifies governance and limits personal liability. LLC agreements typically outline management roles, dispute resolution, and resale provisions.

Each structure comes with its own implications for taxation, liability, and governance, so it's critical to choose the format that best suits the owners’ goals.

Fractional Ownership vs. Timeshares

While both models involve shared use of an asset, a fractional ownership agreement is significantly different from a timeshare.

  • Ownership: Fractional ownership gives you a legal interest (deed or share) in the property. Timeshare holders usually only purchase the right to use the property for a limited time without actual ownership.
  • Equity: Fractional owners can benefit from property appreciation and resale value. Timeshare holders generally cannot.
  • Number of Owners: Timeshares often involve dozens of owners, while fractional ownership typically limits the number of co-owners, improving access and flexibility.
  • Governance: Fractional ownership agreements usually provide structured governance and may include voting rights and dispute resolution clauses.

For those seeking actual equity in a property, fractional ownership provides a more robust investment vehicle than a traditional timeshare.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. What is a fractional ownership agreement?
    A fractional ownership agreement is a legal contract that allows multiple individuals to co-own a high-value asset, like a vacation home, and outlines their respective rights, responsibilities, and usage schedules.
  2. Can fractional ownership be used for more than real estate?
    Yes. While most common in real estate, fractional ownership can apply to aircraft, boats, art, and luxury vehicles.
  3. Is financing available for fractional ownership properties?
    Financing is possible but less common. Some banks offer fractional mortgages, though cash purchases are more typical.
  4. What happens if one owner wants to sell their share?
    The agreement should specify a resale process, which may include offering the share to other owners first or requiring approval for outside buyers.
  5. How is property management handled in fractional ownership?
    It depends on the structure. An LLC may hire a third-party manager, while a TIC may rely on owner consensus or appoint an internal manager.

If you need help learning more about a fractional ownership contract, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel’s marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law, and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.