Key Takeaways

  • A domain name can violate trademark rights if it causes consumer confusion or is registered in bad faith.
  • Trademark owners can pursue legal or arbitration routes to reclaim infringing domain names.
  • Registering your trademark strengthens your legal standing in domain disputes.
  • Not all domain name uses are infringing; context, industry, and intent matter.
  • Defensive domain registration and monitoring are essential to protect your brand online.

A domain trademark dispute is a legal issue that arises between two businesses that are trying to use the same domain name. Domain names and trademarks are protected intellectual property and can, therefore, be enforced through legal action. Domain names can face two different types of disputes:

  1. Cybersquatting.
  2. Ownership (regarding security interests).

What Is Cybersquatting?

Cybersquatting is a type of trademark law that focuses on the use of a domain name that infringes on a trademark. Using another person or entity's owned domain name is not allowed on its own, but cybersquatting takes the issue to a further degree by using a protected trademark in a domain name. This means that the offended party can sue on the grounds of trademark infringement as well as under the Anti-Cybersquatting Consumer Protection Act.

If the suit is successful, the offended party can collect damages that were proved in the case as well as transfer the ownership of the infringing domain name to the trademark holder's possession.

If you're pursing legal action against another party for use of a domain name, but you're only interested in gaining ownership of the domain, you can opt for a proceeding under the Uniform Domain-Name Dispute-Resolution Policy (UDRP). This is an arbitration case rather than a full-blown trial. This type of proceeding is internationally recognized and has been in use for a long time.

A new policy called Uniform Rapid Suspension (URS) comes online soon and is meant to offer a cheap and fast method for handling infringement disputes. This policy will work best for disputes have a clear example of infringement.

All cybersquatting disputes face the same difficulty: They all must prove the bad faith intentions of the accused cybersquatter. Trademark infringement tends to be easier to prove. Cases under UDRP and URS require that the trademark in question be registered. This is a good reminder to make sure that you register your trademarks.

Disputes that call into question the domain name's rightful owner usually look at two different aspects of ownership. First, there's trademark ownership, then domain-name ownership and registration. Registered domain names pose a new issue to courts regarding intellectual property ownership because they are relatively new to the scene.

What Are Trademarks?

Trademarks are a type of intellectual property that can be protected by law when they are registered. They are usually in the form of phrases, words, logos, or other types of creative expression. Domain names can sometimes infringe on trademarks because the domain name registrar will simply award the ownership of a domain name to the first person who requests it without double checking any trademarks.

This means that a person or business entity can accidentally infringe on a protected trademark or trade name by registering their domain name without checking the USPTO (United States Patent and Trademark Office) database. Sometimes trademarks can actually be the same words or similar words as long as the businesses or goods they represent are very different to avoid confusion. For instance, an airline company and a water faucet company both have the name "Delta" registered as their trademark. Problems are more likely to arise when two similar industries try to use the same trademark.

When Is a Domain Name Considered Trademark Infringement?

A domain name may be considered trademark infringement if it creates a likelihood of confusion with an existing trademark. This typically happens when the domain uses a name that is identical or confusingly similar to a registered mark and is related to similar goods or services. Courts will evaluate several factors, including:

  • Similarity in sight, sound, or meaning between the trademark and domain.
  • The strength or distinctiveness of the original mark.
  • Evidence of intent to profit from the trademark's reputation.
  • Whether the domain is being used to sell competing goods or services.

Even if a domain name includes a trademark, not every use is automatically infringing. For example, using a trademarked term in a non-commercial blog or as part of a domain in a different industry may be permissible depending on context.

Can Two Parties Register the Same Domain Name?

The short answer is: No, two parties cannot register the same domain name. In some cases, competitors will register domain names simply to hold them and sell them for a profit through a bidding war. This practice is called cybersquatting, and the third parties who do this are called pirates. Even if two businesses have been legitimately using their trademarks for years both want to register a domain name for their company, they still cannot both use the same domain name.

In the case of the trademark, Delta, only one of the companies using the same name can claim the domain name. This means that only one of the companies can own the delta.com while the other will need to buy a .org name or change the name somewhat to get a .com name. The issue of domain names brings about many potential problems because frequently the domain name isn't using an exact trademark, but an abbreviated or slightly adjusted version of the protected name, word, or phrase.

Best Practices to Avoid Domain Trademark Conflicts

To prevent disputes over trademark domain names, individuals and businesses should adopt proactive strategies:

  • Search Before You Register: Always check the USPTO trademark database and domain availability before purchasing a domain.
  • Secure Similar Domains: Consider buying variations of your domain (e.g., .net, .org, misspellings) to prevent third parties from capitalizing on your brand.
  • Monitor Domain Registrations: Use domain monitoring tools to watch for new registrations that could infringe on your trademark.
  • Enforce Your Rights Promptly: If you identify misuse of a similar domain, act quickly to assert your trademark rights.

How to Trademark a Domain Name

Trademarking a domain name can enhance your legal rights and prevent others from using similar web addresses. To qualify, the domain must serve as a source identifier—not just a URL. The steps include:

  • Ensuring the domain name is unique, not generic or merely descriptive.
  • Conducting a search in the USPTO database to confirm it’s not already registered.
  • Filing a trademark application with the USPTO, indicating how the domain name is used in commerce (e.g., as branding on a website or products).
  • Providing specimens showing the domain name’s use as a mark.

Once registered, a trademark grants broader protections and enforcement options against infringing domains.

Legal Remedies for Domain Trademark Disputes

When someone registers a domain name that infringes upon a trademark, the rightful owner has several legal options:

  1. Uniform Domain-Name Dispute-Resolution Policy (UDRP):
    UDRP is an arbitration process established by ICANN to handle domain disputes quickly and without litigation. To prevail under UDRP, the trademark owner must prove:
    • The domain name is identical or confusingly similar to the trademark.
    • The domain registrant has no legitimate rights to the name.
    • The domain was registered and used in bad faith.
  2. Anticybersquatting Consumer Protection Act (ACPA):
    If the domain holder is based in the U.S., trademark owners can file a lawsuit under ACPA. This law targets cybersquatting and allows for the recovery of actual damages, statutory damages (up to $100,000 per domain), and potential injunctions to transfer the domain.
  3. Cease and Desist Letters:
    A formal legal notice may resolve disputes without litigation. This letter informs the domain registrant of the alleged infringement and requests that they voluntarily transfer or cease use of the domain.
  4. Litigation in Federal Court:
    For severe or complex cases, especially those involving financial loss or willful infringement, litigation may be pursued. This is often a last resort due to cost and time.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. What happens if someone else trademarks my domain name?
    If your domain is not trademarked and someone else trademarks it for similar goods or services, they may attempt to claim infringement. Legal action or UDRP arbitration may follow.
  2. Can I trademark a domain name I’m not using yet?
    You can file an "intent to use" trademark application, but you'll need to provide proof of commercial use before it’s fully registered.
  3. Is it legal to register a domain similar to a famous brand?
    No, registering domains similar to well-known brands with the intent to profit or mislead consumers typically constitutes cybersquatting.
  4. Can I lose my domain name in a dispute?
    Yes, if a panel or court finds that your domain was registered in bad faith and infringes on a valid trademark, it may be transferred to the trademark holder.
  5. What’s the difference between UDRP and ACPA?
    UDRP is an arbitration process used internationally and is faster and less expensive. ACPA is a U.S. federal law allowing lawsuits against cybersquatters for monetary damages and domain transfer.

If you need help with a domain trademark dispute, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.