Disputed Invoice Clauses and How to Manage Them

Key Takeaways

• A disputed invoice arises when a client contests charges, leading to potential payment delays and legal risks.
• Including clear billing, payment, and dispute resolution terms in contracts can prevent misunderstandings.
• Root causes of invoice disputes often include pricing errors, scope changes, and miscommunication.
• Proactive measures like detailed documentation and communication can help resolve disputes quickly.
• Businesses should define how disputed amounts are handled and when the right to suspend services applies.

Disputed Invoice Clause Overview

A disputed invoice clause is a conflict that occurs in business when the substance of the invoice clause of a contract is not agreed upon by the parties involved in the contract. This will usually occur when an invoice–or bill for services–is presented to a client from an independent contractor and the client does not agree to some or all of the substance of the invoice. Then, a potentially time-consuming and unpleasant dispute over billing could take place, which could even require legal resolution, in some cases. Drafting a strong and easily understood invoice clause in your contract will help you avoid this sort of dispute.

Common Causes of Disputed Invoices

Disputed invoices often stem from simple errors or misaligned expectations. Understanding these causes helps businesses implement preventive strategies. Common reasons include:

• Pricing discrepancies – Charges differ from agreed-upon terms.
• Incorrect quantities or services – Billed items do not match the delivered goods or services.
• Late or missing documentation – Supporting materials like timesheets or purchase orders are absent or delayed.
• Changes in project scope – Added work without prior written approval may be challenged.
• Miscommunication – Ambiguities in contract terms or deliverables often lead to misunderstandings.

Identifying and addressing these triggers in your invoicing process and contract language can greatly reduce the likelihood of disputes.

Invoicing Basics: Billing

Invoicing, or billing, is an essential action for any independent contractor. If you do not get paid for your work, you will not be able to maintain your business, and unfortunately, you may encounter clients that are unwilling to pay. The following are some best practices that may help increase the likelihood of getting paid on time and avoiding costly or time-consuming disputes over pay:

• Invoicing should occur no less than once a month.
• If your project involves providing a series of deliverables in less time than a month, an invoice should be provided with each deliverable.
• In either case, invoicing should be done on your terms.
• Whenever you plan on invoicing should be stated in the invoice clause of your contract.
• If your normal date of invoicing occurs on a weekend or holiday, you may want to include language in the invoice clause to the effect that invoicing will occur on the last business day before your normal date of invoicing.
• In the invoice clause of a contract, it is best to use the term “calendar days” instead of “days” or “business days,” as this will eliminate ambiguity (since business days for some people are not business days for others, like Columbus Day).

Invoice Format and Clarity

The structure and clarity of your invoice can prevent confusion that leads to disputes. A well-designed invoice should include:

• Your business name and contact information
• Unique invoice number and date
• Itemized list of products or services provided
• Associated costs per item/service and total amount due
• Clear payment terms, due date, and acceptable methods of payment
• A section for comments or notes, including contact information for disputes

Use consistent formatting across all invoices and avoid jargon to ensure your client can easily understand what they're being charged for.

Invoicing Basics: Payment Duration

When you choose to bill is also important to consider. Some tips on how you may want to approach this are as follows:

• The time period between the receipt of the invoice and the payment date should be as short as it can be.
• If possible, the payment should be due before the next invoice, thereby avoiding a series of unpaid invoices.
• The consequences of late payment should be defined in the invoice clause so as to encourage your clients to pay on time. A flat fee plus an interest provision is one possibility.

Invoicing Basics: Disputing Invoices

It may be possible to resolve billing disputes before they turn into official legal matters. To provide an avenue for this, you can include a section on an invoice for the customer to voice any complaints they have with the bill. Such a practice is good customer service, although you will want to limit the time period in which a customer may dispute a bill. For instance, you could state that the client has ten days to voice any objections to the bill. If not, then it will be assumed they are in agreement with it.

If, on the other hand, a portion of the invoice is disputed, it should be insisted that the undisputed portion of the invoice be paid promptly, regardless of the state of the disputed portion. Then, once the disputed portion is resolved, such payment as is due from it should also be paid promptly.

Steps for Resolving a Disputed Invoice

Once a client disputes an invoice, a structured resolution process can prevent escalation. Recommended steps include:

1. Acknowledge the dispute – Respond promptly to confirm receipt.
2. Investigate internally – Review the original agreement, supporting documents, and your billing records.
3. Communicate with the client – Clarify any confusion and gather their perspective.
4. Negotiate if needed – Offer to revise the invoice or provide additional context/documentation.
5. Document everything – Keep records of correspondence and revised invoices.
6. Escalate professionally – If unresolved, consider mediation or legal assistance.

Always remain professional and focus on maintaining the business relationship while protecting your rights.

Invoicing Basics: The Right to Suspend

In the terms of the invoice clause, you should be sure that you retain what is called the right to suspend, or the right to halt work if payment is not received on time, as well as to be compensated for any expenses related to the disruption. This is another means by which you can dissuade parties from being late on their bills, but it is only useful if you are willing to make use of it.

Often, contractors are reluctant to use the right to suspend for fear of legal action from their clients as a result of damages incurred due to the halt of work. This can be avoided, however, if a clause is inserted in the contract stating the client will hold the contractor harmless for any damages resulting from the use of their right to suspend.

Preventing Invoice Disputes Through Proactive Practices

Prevention is often the best remedy. To avoid disputes:

• Use clear contracts – Specify scope of work, billing terms, and dispute resolution mechanisms.
• Confirm deliverables in writing – Keep signed approvals for scope changes or additional work.
• Send timely and detailed invoices – Don’t delay billing, and always include full itemization.
• Follow up professionally – A polite reminder can prevent a misunderstanding from becoming a formal dispute.
• Use automated invoicing tools – These help track time, expenses, and approvals to support your case if a dispute arises.

These habits promote transparency and professionalism, reducing friction and improving your chance of getting paid without conflict.

Handling Partial Payments and Disputed Amounts

When an invoice is only partially disputed, contractors should specify in the contract that the undisputed portion must be paid by the due date, even while the remainder is under review. This approach ensures cash flow is maintained and incentivizes good-faith dispute resolution.

Additionally, your invoice clause should address:

• Whether interest applies to the disputed amount
• Timeframes for dispute resolution
• How resolution outcomes are documented (e.g., revised invoice or credit note)

By setting these expectations upfront, you reduce the likelihood of prolonged nonpayment.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What is a disputed invoice?
   A disputed invoice is a bill that a client challenges due to perceived errors, unauthorized charges, or unmet expectations.
2. Who is responsible for resolving a disputed invoice?
   Both the contractor and client share the responsibility. The contractor should clarify charges, and the client should communicate concerns promptly.
3. Can a business stop work over an unpaid invoice?
   Yes, if your contract includes a right to suspend clause, you can halt work until payment is received.
4. What happens if a client only pays part of the invoice?
   If part of the invoice is undisputed, the client should pay that portion while resolving the rest. Contracts should clearly state this requirement.
5. How long does it take to resolve a disputed invoice?
   Resolution time varies depending on the issue’s complexity and communication efficiency. Some disputes are resolved in days; others may take weeks.

If you need help with understanding disputed invoice, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel’s marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.