Key Takeaways

  • Arbitration is a legally binding form of alternative dispute resolution (ADR) conducted by a neutral arbitrator or panel.
  • It is commonly used in commercial, consumer, labor, and international disputes.
  • Arbitration offers advantages over litigation, such as confidentiality, speed, and reduced cost.
  • An "arbitration lawyer" helps draft arbitration clauses, select arbitrators, and represent clients during the process.
  • Arbitration clauses in contracts often determine the scope, forum, and finality of the arbitration decision.

To define arbitration in law, you need to understand dispute resolution. Arbitration is a type of dispute resolution that happens outside of the courtroom with the intervention of an arbitrator.

What Is Arbitration?

Two parties involved in a dispute can have their resolution handled by a third party, either an arbitral tribunal, arbiter, or arbitrator. The parties agree to whatever decision this third-party arbitrator makes regarding their dispute. Arbitration is a type of alternative dispute resolution, or ADR. Other types of ADR include:

  • Mediation.
  • Negotiation.
  • Non-binding determination by expert.

These other types of ADR are different from arbitration because they are not always legally binding. The result of arbitration is just as binding as a court litigation.

Key Features of Arbitration

Arbitration is distinguished from other ADR methods by its binding outcome, which typically cannot be appealed, and by the formal process that mimics court proceedings. Core features include:

  • Neutral Arbitrator or Panel: A single arbitrator or tribunal reviews the evidence and renders a decision.
  • Voluntary or Contractual Agreement: Arbitration may be chosen by mutual consent or required under an arbitration clause.
  • Confidential Process: Unlike court cases, arbitration is private, which appeals to businesses and high-profile parties.
  • Limited Discovery and Formality: Procedures are streamlined compared to litigation, saving time and costs.

These characteristics make arbitration a hybrid between mediation and full litigation, offering both efficiency and enforceability.

How Is Arbitration Used?

Today, arbitration is most common in commercial disputes. International commercial transaction disputes and credit obligation disputes are usually resolved through arbitration. Labor, family, and consumer disputes are also frequently handled through arbitration. Certain disputes that arise in interactions between states or investors are best resolved with arbitration.

An arbitration is like a small-scale trial. This can take place before the trial for a lawsuit with the hopes that a resolution will be reached before trial and therefore negate the need for a full-scale trial.

Arbiters, or those who conduct the arbitration, are not judges and need to have their decision approved by the court. An arbitrator is an official approved to make the final decision in the dispute. Sometimes an arbitral tribunal is used, which is a panel provided by an organization like the American Arbitration Association. These third-party deciders can help avoid having the courts filled with trials that don't need a full court trial.

When arbitration is required by contract through an arbitration clause, the decision can be viewed as a legal judgment through a court petition. If one of the parties has an issue, they can protest the decision on the grounds of gross injustice, fraud, or collusion. Some states require arbitration of cases by an experienced lawyer with a non-binding decision before a decision from an arbitrator. They hope that the lawyer will show the parties the most likely result of their dispute and therefore help them better accept the arbitration's final judgment.

Because the rules regarding evidence and proceedings are not as formal in the arbitration process as they are in the court, arbitration is less expensive and quicker than a full trial.

Common Legal Contexts for Arbitration

In addition to commercial disputes, arbitration plays a significant role in:

  • Employment Law: Disputes involving wrongful termination, discrimination, or unpaid wages often proceed to arbitration under employment agreements.
  • Construction and Real Estate: Arbitration helps resolve complex matters involving contracts, defects, or delays in construction projects.
  • Financial Services: Claims related to securities, brokerage accounts, and investment mismanagement frequently go to FINRA arbitration.
  • Healthcare Agreements: Patients may unknowingly agree to arbitration clauses in provider contracts.

The broad application of arbitration demonstrates its utility across multiple legal fields.

How To Arbitrate

Arbitration might look different depending on the type of dispute it is handling. All arbitrations begin with a notice of intent. The party filing the complaint will send this notice to the accused to notify them of the dispute and their complaints. The party filing allows a certain amount of time for a response. Then the arbitrators are chosen. Finally, the hearing takes place.

Both parties usually have some input in what kind of panel or arbitrator they have. If there's a contract involved, usually the contract will specify what type of arbitration is to take place in the event of a dispute.

Role of an Arbitration Lawyer

The arbitration lawyer definition refers to an attorney who specializes in representing clients in arbitration proceedings. Their roles include:

  • Drafting Arbitration Clauses: Ensuring the agreement is enforceable and reflects client preferences (e.g., number of arbitrators, venue).
  • Selecting Arbitrators: Helping parties choose impartial and qualified arbitrators.
  • Representing in Hearings: Presenting evidence, examining witnesses, and arguing legal points similar to litigation.
  • Challenging Awards: Where permitted, lawyers may assist with court challenges based on procedural unfairness or arbitrator bias.

An arbitration lawyer ensures clients understand their rights and navigate arbitration effectively from start to finish.

When Can Parties Arbitrate?

A party can choose to arbitrate a dispute or legal problem at any time, but they have to be in agreement with the other party. If one party wants to enforce their right to a full trial, they can do so, unless they've signed a contract stating that they agree to arbitration. Arbitration is much more common than many people realize. Frequently, consumer transaction disputes are resolved through arbitration, and these happen daily.

Mandatory vs. Voluntary Arbitration

  • Voluntary Arbitration occurs when parties mutually agree to resolve a dispute outside of court, often after the dispute arises.
  • Mandatory Arbitration is required when parties have pre-committed to arbitration through a contractual clause.

Some industries and jurisdictions may require arbitration before filing a lawsuit, such as in consumer finance or certain state court systems.

What Is an Arbitration Clause?

Many different contract types include arbitration clauses including:

  • Consumer contracts.
  • Credit card contracts.
  • Employment contracts.
  • Medical care agreements.
  • Cell phone contracts.

When an arbitration clause is included in a contract, the signee is agreeing to handle any disputes that may arise regarding this specific agreement through arbitration. These clauses will also usually lay out specifics like the arbitrator selection process, the location for the hearing, and who must pay for the process.

An arbitration clause might also specify that any decisions made by the arbitrator during the hearing are legally binding. This means that the dispute cannot be taken to court after the arbitration decision has been made. The only way around this is if one of the parties involved can prove that misuse of power or fraud took place during the arbitration process.

Arbitration Clauses and Legal Enforceability

An enforceable arbitration clause typically includes:

  • Scope of Disputes Covered: Which types of disagreements must go to arbitration.
  • Rules and Procedures: Reference to a governing body (e.g., AAA, JAMS) and applicable rules.
  • Venue and Jurisdiction: The location where arbitration will take place.
  • Finality of Award: Whether the arbitrator's decision is binding and limits on court review.

Courts generally uphold arbitration clauses unless they are unconscionable or clearly disadvantage one party.

Frequently Asked Questions

  • What is the legal definition of arbitration?
    Arbitration is a private dispute resolution method where a neutral arbitrator makes a binding decision, serving as an alternative to court litigation.
  • What does an arbitration lawyer do?
    An arbitration lawyer drafts arbitration clauses, advises clients on strategy, represents them in hearings, and ensures procedural fairness throughout the process.
  • Is arbitration legally binding?
    Yes, unless the agreement specifies otherwise, arbitration decisions (called awards) are legally binding and enforceable in court.
  • Can arbitration be appealed?
    Arbitration awards are rarely appealable. Courts may only overturn them for limited reasons like fraud, corruption, or procedural misconduct.
  • When should I consider arbitration instead of litigation?
    Consider arbitration for faster, less formal, and confidential resolution—especially for commercial or contractual disputes.

If you need help understanding how to define arbitration in law, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.