Key Takeaways

  • A deadlock occurs when company owners or managers cannot reach a decision, causing operational paralysis and potentially harming the business.
  • Without a deadlock provision, unresolved disputes may lead to costly litigation, judicial dissolution, or forced liquidation.
  • Effective deadlock provisions include mediation, arbitration, auction clauses, or buy-sell mechanisms to resolve impasses.
  • Courts often require evidence of harm to the business — not just disagreement — before intervening.
  • Proactive measures in the operating agreement, like tiebreakers, governance structures, and exit strategies, can prevent deadlocks.

A deadlock provision is a procedure for resolving disputes. It specifies the process that must be followed if a deadlock exists. A deadlock is a tied vote, occurring when an equal number of votes that were cast both for and against the decision in question. It can also refer to the failure to reach a unanimous decision if one was required to pass a resolution.

Deadlock provisions help a company to deal with decisions for which there is no majority vote because if shareholders cannot agree on a decision they will be stuck and unable to move on. Many issues may be subject to a vote by a company's shareholders — the election of directors, various management decisions, company strategy, and more. This is one of the most important reasons why every company needs a strong contract, or operating agreement, that contains a deadlock provision.

What Happens Without a Deadlock Provision?

An LLC that does not have a deadlock provision in its operating agreement often requires the intervention of a court case. This results in judicial dissolution, or some other alternative measure for resolving the deadlock. This is just one of the events that may lead to the dissolution of the company, which means that the company shuts down and its business affairs are completed. These are some situations that require shutting down the business and its activities:

  • Any event that causes dissolution under the company's operating agreement.
  • Consent of all of the members in the affirmative.
  • Lack of company members for 90 consecutive days.
  • A judicial ruling that the company's activities are unlawful or management have acted in a fraudulent manner.
  • A judicial ruling that it is no longer possible to conduct company business as required by the certificate or organization and operating agreement.
  • A statement of administrative dissolution is filed by the Secretary of State.

Legal Consequences of a Deadlock

If no deadlock provision exists, unresolved disputes can severely disrupt business operations and invite judicial involvement. Courts generally step in only when the deadlock results in significant harm to the company, such as financial losses, reputational damage, or operational standstill. Merely disagreeing is not enough — there must be an inability to act that jeopardizes the company’s future.

When courts do intervene, common outcomes include:

  • Judicial Dissolution: The company may be dissolved if continued operation is no longer feasible.
  • Appointment of a Custodian or Receiver: A neutral third party may temporarily manage company affairs.
  • Forced Buyout: One party may be required to purchase the other’s interest.

These remedies are typically drastic, expensive, and disruptive, underscoring the importance of including clear deadlock provisions in governing documents.

Deadlock Provision Options

There is more than one type of deadlock provision. Companies may choose between several options:

  • Mediation Clause: The matter may be resolved with the assistance of a neutral party, or mediator. This clause can also require shareholders to hold an extended meeting to resolve the problem.
  • Arbitration Clause: An outside expert must be called in to study the facts and circumstances of the dispute, and that person may make a decision about the issue.
  • Auction Deadlock Clause: The shares held by dissenting shareholders may be bid on by other shareholders.
  • Chairman Deadlock Clause: One shareholder is given the power to serve as Chairman, and therefore has the power to end the deadlock by making the final decision.
  • Liquidation Deadlock Clause: The shareholders will be forced to liquidate the business in the event of an unresolved deadlock.

Strategic Drafting Tips for Deadlock Clauses

When drafting a deadlock provision, clarity and foresight are crucial. Poorly drafted clauses can create ambiguity, prolong disputes, or inadvertently favor one party. Consider the following best practices:

  • Define the Scope: Clearly specify what decisions constitute a “deadlock.” For instance, limit it to strategic or financial matters rather than routine operations.
  • Establish a Clear Process: Outline each step — from negotiation to mediation to arbitration — and set time limits to prevent indefinite stalemates.
  • Balance Control and Fairness: Avoid mechanisms that give one party undue power. Instead, consider neutral third-party decision-makers or rotating leadership roles.
  • Include Exit Strategies: Allow for buy-sell options or dissolution provisions if resolution proves impossible.

Including these elements not only streamlines conflict resolution but also minimizes the risk of litigation and business disruption.

Operating Agreement Mechanisms Preventing Deadlock

An LLC's operating agreement may include various mechanisms for addressing deadlock and solving the problems it causes. One of these is the Buy-Sell Provision. The appraisal model brings in an expert to make an independent appraisal to determine the value of an ownership interest.

The “shotgun” model allows one member to make a purchase offer to the deadlocked member for a pre-set price with established terms. The person receiving the offer is required to accept the price and terms or else purchase the ownership interest of the offeror at the same price and terms. However, “shotgun” provisions are often unfair because parties have different opinions about the interests' value and differences in their financial ability to purchase other shareholders' interests. If everything goes smoothly, however, this strategy can be effective because it provides an incentive to shareholders to work things out first.

Another method of dealing with a deadlock is the use of tiebreakers, which can be either external or internal. In the case of a tied vote, the decision will be given to the tiebreaker. This can be a group, a professional advisor or mediator, or an industry expert. The problem with this is that the decision is placed in the hands of people who may be unfamiliar with the company and lack the insight to make the decision properly.

Put or Call mechanisms are commonly used as tiebreakers in LLC operating agreements, though they must be drafted and applied carefully. The most important issue is determining the triggering event, which is the situation that allows a party to exercise a “put” or “call.” When putting together an operating agreement with this type of provision, consider what types of deadlocks should use it.

Proactive Steps to Avoid Deadlock

The most effective way to address deadlock is to prevent it before it occurs. Businesses can adopt governance structures and communication practices that reduce the likelihood of stalemates, such as:

  • Odd Number of Decision-Makers: Structuring boards or management teams with an odd number of members reduces the chance of tied votes.
  • Defined Decision Thresholds: Not all decisions need unanimous consent. Requiring a supermajority or simple majority for certain actions can keep operations moving.
  • Regular Communication Protocols: Scheduled meetings, clear documentation, and structured negotiation sessions can resolve disputes early before they escalate.
  • Pre-Agreed Valuation Methods: If a buy-sell is triggered, having a valuation formula in place can streamline the process and avoid disputes.

Taking these proactive steps builds resilience into the company’s governance structure and reduces the risk of destructive deadlocks.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. What is a deadlock in a business?
    A deadlock occurs when decision-makers, such as shareholders or LLC members, cannot agree on a critical issue, preventing the business from moving forward.
  2. Why is a deadlock provision important?
    It provides a clear process for resolving disputes, preventing expensive litigation, and ensuring the company continues to operate smoothly.
  3. Can a court dissolve a company over a deadlock?
    Yes, if the deadlock threatens the company’s operations or causes significant harm, a court may order dissolution or appoint a custodian.
  4. What are common deadlock resolution methods?
    Mediation, arbitration, buy-sell agreements, and tiebreaker provisions are among the most effective strategies.
  5. How can companies prevent deadlocks?
    They can design governance structures with odd-numbered boards, set clear decision thresholds, and include proactive conflict-resolution mechanisms in their operating agreements.

If you need more information or help with a deadlock provision, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.