Key Takeaways

  • Converting a nonprofit to a for-profit organization is possible but requires legal and financial restructuring.
  • The process involves dissolving the nonprofit, distributing assets properly, and forming a new for-profit entity.
  • Reasons for conversion include greater access to funding, fewer regulatory restrictions, and potential for business expansion.
  • Nonprofits must be cautious of tax implications and legal compliance when transitioning.
  • Some organizations choose to create for-profit subsidiaries rather than fully converting.
  • Consulting an attorney or accountant is essential to navigate the legal complexities.

Converting a nonprofit to a for-profit organization changes how the company is run and its legal responsibilities. Nonprofit organizations are considered public entities. The managers of a nonprofit don't have any ownership interest. Because it isn't owned by individuals, a nonprofit can't simply transform into a for-profit company.

When a nonprofit organization is created, the founders are required to file documents that detail its activities and state that the organization won't be earning money for a specific individual. They must also agree that when the organization is dissolved, the assets will be given to another nonprofit organization. One of the biggest benefits of electing nonprofit status is that the organization is tax-exempt and can accept grants and donations.

Reasons to Become For-Profit

It takes lots of paperwork to earn tax-exempt status, which is very valuable and saves the organization lots of money. For that reason alone, many people wonder why a nonprofit organization would ever want to become for-profit. However, there are numerous reasons why an organization would give up its nonprofit status, including:

  • It can help the organization get loans and other funding to provide more services.
  • Some causes are better served by a for-profit organization.
  • More capital is needed that can be gained from public loans and grants, and the organization wants to reach out to potential investors.
  • It can free an organization from the regulations that come with nonprofit status.

Legal Considerations in Converting a Nonprofit

Before a nonprofit can transition into a for-profit entity, it must comply with strict legal guidelines. These considerations include:

  • State Regulations – The process varies by state, as nonprofits are chartered under state laws.
  • IRS Compliance – The nonprofit must notify the IRS of its dissolution and comply with tax obligations.
  • Asset Distribution – Nonprofit assets must be transferred to another nonprofit before dissolution to maintain compliance with tax laws.
  • New Business Formation – The new for-profit entity must be registered under state law, obtain a tax ID, and adhere to for-profit regulations.

Given the legal complexities, consulting an attorney specializing in nonprofit law is highly recommended.

Changes in Health Care

The move from nonprofit to for-profit is happening more frequently in the health care industry, where many hospitals and clinics are becoming private, for-profit organizations. Instead of following the traditional nonprofit model, these new types of companies follow the model of a corporation.

Changing to for-profit status doesn't impact the revenue streams of these health care organizations because they get funding from Medicare, Medicaid, insurance reimbursements, and payments from patients. Many investors are eager to support for-profit health care organizations and believe the companies should make a profit because they help the sick.

This trend in the health care field is also brought on by difficulties of operating as a nonprofit. Economic troubles have made it difficult for many nonprofits to obtain the funding they need in order to operate. People aren't giving as much to charities, and grants are offered less frequently and are becoming more competitive. Many nonprofits used to be able to count on grants to cover most of their operating costs, but that is no longer the case.

Steps to Convert a Nonprofit to a For-Profit

Converting a nonprofit to a for-profit involves several critical steps:

  1. Board Approval – The board of directors must approve the decision to dissolve the nonprofit.
  2. File Articles of Dissolution – The organization must officially dissolve by filing paperwork with the state.
  3. Distribute Remaining Assets – Assets must be donated to another nonprofit before conversion.
  4. Form a New Business Entity – A new for-profit corporation or LLC must be registered.
  5. Apply for Business Licenses – The new entity must secure necessary licenses and permits.
  6. Tax Registration – The business must obtain an Employer Identification Number (EIN) and register for state and federal taxes.
  7. Operational Transition – Adjust operations to align with for-profit business strategies, including pricing, revenue generation, and marketing.

Each step requires careful legal and financial planning to ensure compliance.

Nonprofit Ownership

Under nonprofit 501(c)3 status, every board member has equal voting power. This is to ensure that the founder or executive director can't make decisions on their own and that the organization must follow the wishes of the people who are contributing the funds.

Donations to nonprofits are tax-deductible. Those tax deductions mean the government isn't receiving money it would have otherwise, so the government assumes ownership of every nonprofit's assets.

With that in mind, a nonprofit's board members are considered representatives who are supposed to act according to the will of the government. The problem is that doing what is best for the government isn't always in line with doing what is best for the nonprofit and its cause.

Tax Implications of Converting to a For-Profit

Shifting from nonprofit to for-profit status has significant tax consequences:

  • Loss of Tax-Exempt Status – The organization will now be subject to corporate income taxes.
  • Capital Gains Tax on Assets – Any assets transferred to the new entity may trigger capital gains taxes.
  • Employment and Sales Taxes – Unlike nonprofits, for-profit businesses must pay employment and sales taxes.
  • Private Inurement Issues – If nonprofit leaders personally benefit from the transition, they may face IRS penalties.

To mitigate tax liabilities, it’s advisable to work with a tax professional familiar with nonprofit transitions.

For-Profit Subsidiaries

A common practice for nonprofits is to combine services with business activities, such as an employee development center running a restaurant as a job training site, or a women's shelter selling items made by its residents. These activities can occasionally fall under the nonprofit umbrella, but in most cases the organizations form a separate for-profit entity for the business activity. The revenue from the for-profit arm is donated back to the nonprofit in a practice known as wholly owned for-profit subsidiaries.

Creating for-profit subsidiaries allows organizations to leverage their existing goods and experience in order to earn funds for their organization. Because earnings from subsidiaries are often related to the nonprofit's mission, they are often considered related income and are not taxed.

Adding a subsidiary or changing tax-exempt status can be a long process. It is best to talk to an experienced lawyer and accountant to understand the long-term effects of electing either status.

Alternative to Conversion: Creating a For-Profit Arm

Rather than fully converting, some nonprofits choose to establish a for-profit subsidiary. This approach allows them to:

  • Generate Revenue – The for-profit subsidiary can engage in commercial activities while financially supporting the nonprofit.
  • Maintain Nonprofit Status – The main organization retains tax-exempt benefits while expanding revenue streams.
  • Separate Legal Liabilities – The nonprofit and for-profit entity operate as distinct businesses, reducing legal risks.

However, this structure requires strict compliance with tax regulations, as excessive commercial activity within a nonprofit can jeopardize its tax-exempt status.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Can a nonprofit legally become a for-profit business?

Yes, but it requires dissolving the nonprofit, redistributing its assets, and registering a new for-profit entity under state law.

2. What happens to a nonprofit’s assets when converting to a for-profit?

By law, nonprofit assets must be transferred to another nonprofit. They cannot be distributed to private individuals or shareholders.

3. Can a nonprofit create a for-profit subsidiary instead of converting?

Yes, many nonprofits establish for-profit subsidiaries to generate revenue while maintaining their tax-exempt status.

4. What are the main reasons nonprofits convert to for-profits?

Common reasons include easier access to funding, fewer regulatory restrictions, and the ability to expand business operations.

5. Do I need a lawyer to convert my nonprofit to a for-profit?

Yes, due to legal and tax complexities, consulting an attorney specializing in nonprofit law is highly recommended.

If you need help with converting nonprofit to for-profit, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.