Key Takeaways:

  • Consulting for equity allows consultants to gain ownership stakes in businesses, potentially yielding significant financial benefits if the company succeeds.
  • Equity agreements should clearly define compensation terms, performance expectations, and vesting schedules.
  • Common forms of equity compensation include stock options, grants, and warrants, each with unique tax implications.
  • Consultants should conduct due diligence on the company’s financial health and growth prospects before accepting equity as compensation.
  • Legal and tax professionals should be consulted to navigate potential risks and compliance with securities regulations.
  • Vesting schedules, dilution risks, and exit strategies must be addressed to protect the consultant’s interests.
  • Taxation on equity grants varies based on the structure of the agreement and jurisdiction, potentially requiring proactive tax planning.

Consulting for equity agreement is a popular avenue taken by companies in their early stages. It allows them to minimize the cash they have to outlay when there isn't a lot of cash to go around.

When Facebook went public in 2012, over 1,000 of its employees became millionaires. These employees had accepted equity as their form of compensation in lieu of cash. In this example and many others, an equity compensation agreement may allow its recipients to flourish if the company goes on to become majorly successful.

Equity Compensation Agreements

An equity compensation agreement will require a written document to explain the program's operation in detail. When companies decide to pay an employee or a consultant with equity, they usually use both cash and equity. An agreement offering 100 percent equity is uncommon because there is the risk that the provider won't receive adequate compensation.

Understanding Vesting Schedules and Equity Liquidity

When structuring a consulting-for-equity agreement, it’s essential to establish clear vesting schedules and define the liquidity of the equity. Companies may impose different vesting terms based on time, milestones, or performance metrics.

  • Time-Based Vesting: Equity is earned gradually over a set period (e.g., a four-year vesting schedule with a one-year cliff).
  • Performance-Based Vesting: The consultant earns equity when predefined milestones (such as revenue goals or product launches) are achieved.
  • Hybrid Vesting: A combination of both time and performance metrics.

A critical aspect consultants should consider is liquidity. Unlike traditional salaries, equity may not be immediately convertible to cash. Some companies offer repurchase rights, restricting when or how shares can be sold.

Calculating the Delta

One of the ways to estimate how much equity to offer an employee is to figure out the value the employee will offer the company. This is known as calculating the delta.

Let's say it's determined that an employee will increase a company's value by 15 percent. In that case, the delta will be 115 percent minus 100 percent. You'll want to take that number and divide it by 115 percent, bringing us to a total of 13 percent.

If that employee is going to receive an annual salary of $100,000, you'll want to calculate the employee's expense as 150 percent of the salary, including the margin and the overhead. Now, $100,000 really equals $150,000.

Finally, let's say the company has an estimated worth of $4 million. This makes $150,000 3.75 percent of the $4 million. The difference between 13 percent and 3.75 percent is 9.25 percent. There you have your equity offer.

Evaluating the Company's Financial Health Before Accepting Equity

Before agreeing to equity compensation, consultants should assess the financial health and growth potential of the company. Consider these key factors:

  • Revenue and Profitability Trends: Analyze financial statements to determine whether the company has a strong revenue stream or is in an early growth stage.
  • Debt and Liabilities: A company with excessive debt may struggle to deliver promised equity value.
  • Market Position and Scalability: Companies operating in expanding markets with strong competitive advantages offer better long-term equity potential.
  • Exit Strategies: Assess whether the company has clear plans for an IPO, acquisition, or liquidity event.

Conducting thorough due diligence minimizes the risk of accepting equity in a company that may not deliver returns.

Performance Standards

In an equity agreement, it's important to be clear in your definition of the work the recipient will be expected to perform, as well as the performance standards that must be met in order for the equity to be received.

Equity payments should line up with the employee's performance standards. The agreement should also specify when equity payments will be made, as well as the consequences for not fully meeting the performance standards. That is why the performance standards must be specific, attainable, and measurable.

Addressing Dilution and Protecting Your Equity Stake

One of the risks associated with consulting for equity is the dilution of ownership. If a company raises additional funding or issues more shares, existing shareholders—including consultants—may see their percentage ownership decrease.

Ways to Mitigate Dilution Risk:

  1. Anti-Dilution Clauses: Some agreements include provisions that protect consultants from excessive dilution.
  2. Pro-Rata Rights: These allow equity holders to purchase additional shares in future funding rounds to maintain their ownership percentage.
  3. Cap on Additional Issuance: Limiting how much new stock the company can issue can help consultants protect their equity value.

Consultants should negotiate these terms upfront to safeguard their ownership stake.

Forms of Equity

Equity compensation can come in many forms. Three of the most popular forms are:

  • Stock options
  • Grants
  • Warrants

In the agreement, it should clearly state which type of equity will be provided, as well as the methods for valuing the equity.

If you're considering stock grants, the agreement will need to identify voting rights, as well as the class of the stock. It should also state whether any of the grants will vest with time. Additional performance standards that could have an impact on vesting will also need to be outlined.

If you're considering stock options, the agreement must outline the strike price, exercise rules, and waiting period. Any rules concerning the ability to transfer the stock should also be included, as well as any information pertaining to tax withholding.

Tax Implications and 83(b) Election

Equity compensation carries significant tax implications, varying based on the form of equity and jurisdiction. Consultants must understand their tax obligations when accepting equity.

  • Stock Options: Typically taxed when exercised, with capital gains tax applying when sold.
  • Restricted Stock Units (RSUs): Usually taxed as ordinary income when vested.
  • 83(b) Election: Consultants receiving restricted stock can file an 83(b) election within 30 days to pay taxes on the upfront value rather than the vested amount. This can lead to significant tax savings if the company’s value appreciates.

Consultants should work with tax professionals to optimize their strategy and minimize liabilities.

Benefits and Risks of Consulting for Equity

Taking equity is a complicated matter. It's wise to hire a seasoned lawyer and a sensible accountant. First, ask your lawyer if you're able to take equity. Also, know that some states impose securities regulation exemptions. However, most states also have exemptions for companies offering less than 25 people an equity agreement.

One of the misconceptions pertaining to equity agreements is that there's no cost when taking equity. This is untrue because when someone is issued shares in a company, they'll have to declare its value and pay taxes on it. When a company is in its early stages, the value should be nominal. However, once the company starts generating revenue, the value could be more than anticipated.

Also, both parties are going to incur additional fees as they relate to legal and accounting. If your equity begins to vest over time, ask your accountant about filing an 83(b). When someone files an 83(b) within 30 days of receiving equity, it allows them to pay taxes on the upfront amount, rather than its vested amount.

Creating an Exit Strategy for Your Equity

Consultants must plan how and when they can liquidate their equity, ensuring they can capitalize on their investment.

Common Exit Strategies:

  • Acquisition: If the company is acquired, shareholders often receive cash or shares in the acquiring company.
  • Initial Public Offering (IPO): Public listing allows shareholders to sell shares on the open market.
  • Secondary Market Sales: Some investors sell shares privately before a major liquidity event.

Understanding the lock-up periods, transfer restrictions, and market conditions affecting equity sales is crucial to realizing financial gains.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. What is consulting for equity?
    Consulting for equity is when a consultant receives company equity instead of or in addition to cash compensation for their services.
  2. How do I determine if an equity offer is fair?
    Evaluate the company’s valuation, growth potential, dilution risks, and financial health before accepting an offer.
  3. What are the tax implications of accepting equity?
    Taxes depend on the type of equity received. Filing an 83(b) election early may help reduce long-term tax liabilities.
  4. Can equity compensation be negotiated?
    Yes, consultants can negotiate terms like vesting schedules, dilution protections, and exit options to maximize their benefits.
  5. What happens if the company fails?
    If the company shuts down or doesn’t achieve an exit, equity may become worthless, making due diligence crucial before accepting an offer.

If you need help with consulting for equity agreement, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.