Key Takeaways

  • A consideration clause in insurance defines the policyholder’s payment obligations (premium amount, frequency, and terms) in exchange for the insurer’s promise to provide coverage.
  • Consideration is a fundamental element of any valid contract — without it, the agreement is unenforceable. In insurance, this exchange typically involves premium payments for the insurer’s assumption of risk.
  • Consideration clauses can include deferred payment terms, penalties for non-compliance, or conditions that trigger changes to coverage if payments are missed.
  • Effective drafting of a consideration clause ensures clarity on payment schedules, conditions for coverage activation, and remedies for breaches.
  • Variations of consideration clauses exist across industries, but in insurance they play a crucial role in defining the legal and financial foundation of the policy.

A consideration clause is a stipulation in an insurance policy that outlines the cost of coverage and when payments should be made.

Basics of a Consideration Clause

Consideration clauses are most commonly used in insurance policies and define the amount due for coverage. These clauses also usually define a payment schedule. Other industries also use consideration clauses. When used in industries such as real estate, consideration clauses dictate remuneration based on the terms of the contract.

Generally, consideration clauses dictate that something of value will be exchanged for a bargain. Every party that enters into and benefits from a contract must be given consideration. The best way to understand a consideration is as an exchange. For example, if you provide a service for a business, you can receive a salary in return. In real estate, you would exchange property for regular payments.

In some cases, consideration is used to indicate something of value, such as contractual rights, has been received.

Importance of Consideration in Insurance Contracts

The consideration clause in insurance is one of the most critical provisions of a policy. It establishes the legal foundation of the agreement by clearly outlining what the policyholder must provide (typically, the payment of premiums) and what the insurer promises in return (coverage against specified risks). This exchange of value is essential for the contract’s enforceability — without it, the agreement may be void or unenforceable in court.

In practical terms, the consideration clause ensures that both parties understand the conditions of their obligations. For example:

  • Insurer’s consideration: The promise to pay for covered losses or claims under the policy’s terms.
  • Policyholder’s consideration: Payment of premiums on time and compliance with any policy conditions, such as disclosing material information.

The clause often specifies payment frequency (monthly, quarterly, or annually), the consequences of late or missed payments, and whether coverage is suspended or terminated if the insured fails to meet their obligations. In life or health insurance, coverage might not become effective until the initial premium is paid, reflecting the principle that consideration must precede or coincide with performance.

Deferred Consideration and Penalties

In certain circumstances, it is possible to defer consideration. For example, when a company is acquired, the person buying the company might want to spread out their payments instead of making one large payment. When this occurs, consideration will often be based on some sort of performance goal, such as the company reaching a certain level of sales or an important employee staying with the company.

Deferred consideration is used to protect the interests of the buyer and to make sure the value they are receiving is what they were promised. When the person selling the company fails to uphold their promises, the buyer may want to recover their losses. However, in a court case, it will be difficult for the buyer to regain what they have lost, as damages will be restricted.

To make sure the buyer is able to recover their losses, they will usually make sure the acquisition agreement includes provisions for breaches by the seller. In a share purchase agreement, for example, there may be language that reduces or eliminates the deferred consideration to one company shareholder if the contract is breached or company goals are not met.

Share purchase agreements can also contain restrictive covenants, which define what the buyer considers a breach of contract. Some common restrictive covenants include:

  • A shareholder leaving the company and directly competing with their former company.
  • An undermining of the company's goodwill.
  • Failure to meet targets outlined in the acquisition agreement.

Both buyers and sellers should be very cautious when including restrictive covenants or deferred considerations in contracts. For instance, are the provisions enforceable? This means they are liquidated damages, or unenforceable, making them penalties. With a penalty clause, the person damaged receives compensation that is much more valuable than their initial loss. The reason these penalties are so expensive is to help to prevent a breach of contract.

However, parties are also allowed to accurately assess how they would be damaged by a contract breach and request a provision that reflects this assessment. This assessed loss can be more than what the damaged party would be awarded in a court case. Contracts usually require that penalties be an amount of money paid to the damaged party when a breach happens.

However, penalties do not always have to be sums of money. For instance, some penalties may involve the transfer of assets to the injured party. They can also prevent the party that breached the contract from receiving an amount of money that they would have been owed had the contract not been breached. When there is a provision requiring the transfer of assets, this is considered a penalty because it is meant to disincentivize breaches and it likely cannot be enforced.

For this clause to be enforceable, there would need to be an accurate estimate of damages that would result from a breach. This accurate estimate would make the clause a liquidated damages clause. In previous times, clauses were automatically considered penalties if they did not meet the requirements of a liquidated damages clause. Thanks to the decision in one court case, clauses will not be penalties if there is proof that the clause is commercially justifiable.

Drafting Effective Consideration Clauses

A well-drafted consideration clause in insurance provides not only the payment details but also the mechanisms for enforcement and remedies if either party fails to perform. Key elements often included are:

  1. Payment Structure: Specifies the amount, timing, and method of premium payment.
  2. Conditions Precedent: States whether coverage begins only after payment is received.
  3. Consequences of Non-Payment: Clarifies what happens if premiums are missed — e.g., a grace period, automatic termination, or reinstatement terms.
  4. Adjustments and Renewals: Explains how future premiums might change due to claims history, policy term, or regulatory changes.
  5. Refunds or Forfeitures: Defines whether and how unused premiums are refunded if the policy is canceled.

In some contracts, especially those involving complex commercial insurance or reinsurance arrangements, consideration clauses may also address performance-based payments, where premium amounts are adjusted based on loss experience or risk exposure. Such provisions protect both parties’ interests and reduce disputes over payment obligations.

Clear, precise language in the clause minimizes legal ambiguity. Courts often construe vague or incomplete consideration terms against the drafter, potentially resulting in unenforceable provisions. Therefore, insurers and policyholders alike should ensure the clause fully captures the agreed-upon exchange of value.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. What is a consideration clause in insurance?
    It’s a provision that outlines the policyholder’s payment obligations (such as premium amount and schedule) in exchange for the insurer’s promise to provide coverage.
  2. Why is consideration necessary for an insurance contract?
    Consideration is a fundamental element of a valid contract. It ensures a legal exchange of value — premiums for risk coverage — without which the contract may not be enforceable.
  3. What happens if I don’t pay my insurance premium on time?
    The insurer may suspend coverage, impose penalties, or terminate the policy, depending on the terms of the consideration clause and applicable state law.
  4. Can consideration be something other than money in an insurance contract?
    In most cases, consideration is monetary (the premium), but it can also include other obligations, such as accurate disclosure of risk-related information.
  5. Are consideration clauses negotiable?
    Yes, especially in commercial or bespoke insurance contracts. Payment schedules, conditions precedent, and remedies can often be tailored to meet the needs of both parties.

If you need help understanding consideration clause in insurance, you can post your legal needs on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.