Key Takeaways:

  • A commercial lease early termination clause offers tenants or landlords the ability to end a lease before its expiration under specific conditions.
  • Tenants seeking to terminate early without this clause may face legal liabilities and financial penalties.
  • Landlords may impose requirements like advance notice, a termination fee, or coverage for related expenses.
  • Negotiating an early termination clause can be challenging but critical for flexibility in business operations.
  • Alternatives to early termination include subleasing, assigning the lease, or negotiating a mutual termination agreement.

A commercial lease early termination clause will allow you to break a commercial lease before it is set to expire in certain circumstances. Not every commercial lease will include this clause, so you should be very careful about trying to cancel a lease early, as you may find yourself at risk for a lawsuit.

Can Commercial Leases Be Terminated Early?

If you own a business, there are countless reasons why you may want to terminate a commercial lease before it is set to expire. For example, your business could be struggling, and you simply don't have the money to keep up with your lease payments. Additional reasons to end a commercial lease early include:

  • Market changes.
  • The commercial space no longer meets your needs.
  • You wish to end your business and move on to another project.

No matter why you want to end your commercial lease, terminating the agreement will likely be a struggle. Your landlord will be counting on your continued lease payments, as looking for new tenants can be very time-consuming and costly. Also, having an empty commercial space means lost revenue. Because of these reasons, most landlords insist that commercial lease agreements include stiff penalties for ending a lease early.

Generally, you will face liability when terminating a commercial lease early. The only exception is if the lease includes an early termination clause. Typically, a commercial lease is set to last for a specific period of time. In some cases, these leases can last as long as 10 years. If you have signed a fixed-term commercial lease, you will be responsible for the lease for its entire duration, even if you're forced to close your business.

When negotiating a commercial lease, it will be very difficult to get your landlord to agree to include an early termination clause. Even if the landlord does agree, his or her lender may veto the clause.

If you are able to secure an early termination clause, you should respect certain restrictions. For instance, you will likely need to wait a few years into the lease before using the clause will be executable, and you will usually need to pay a termination fee. The landlord may also request that you cover some of their expenses, including making improvements to the commercial space.

Before signing a commercial lease, you should carefully review the agreement so that you can be sure you understand its terms, including the possibility of ending the lease early.

Here are some questions you should keep in mind when reviewing a lease agreement:

  • Can the landlord assign the lease to a new tenant if the agreement ends early?
  • Does the landlord have unlimited power to accept or reject an assignee?
  • What are the damages, if any, for ending a lease early?
  • Does the lease include a recapture clause?

Strategies for Negotiating an Early Termination Clause

Negotiating an early termination clause requires preparation and flexibility. Tenants should:

  • Highlight landlord benefits: Explain how offering this clause could attract quality tenants who value flexibility.
  • Agree to fair compensation: Offer a termination fee or commit to covering re-leasing costs to make the arrangement acceptable.
  • Propose partial liability: Suggest paying a percentage of rent until a new tenant is found.
  • Consult legal professionals: A lawyer can draft or review proposals to ensure compliance and clarity.

Liability for Early Termination

If a tenant ends a commercial lease before the agreement is set to expire and there is no early termination clause, he has breached the contract. After a breach, the landlord can sue the breaching party for monetary damages. Measuring the harm caused by a broken lease can be difficult, which is why many leases include a provision that a tenant will need to pay the landlord a flat sum if the lease is broken.

An acceleration clause may also be included in a lease. These clauses require that if a tenant breaks the contract, they must pay the entire amount that would be due to the landlord had they completed the lease. When ending a lease early, you will almost always face some form of liability. In addition to paying any outstanding rent, you also may have to pay a portion of the rent due for the remainder of the lease.

In some cases, tenants may be able to mitigate the amount that they owe the landlord by proving that the landlord could have avoided losing rent by leasing the space to another tenant.

Realistically, if you don't have the money to hire a lawyer, you will likely face an unfavorable judgment in a court case, meaning you would need to pay your former landlord the full amount they are owed. Even though it can be expensive, you should hire a lawyer when terminating a lease early, as you may end up paying much more in the long run.

Alternatives to Early Termination

If your lease lacks an early termination clause or negotiations fail, consider these options:

  • Subleasing: Transfer lease obligations to another business while retaining some liability.
  • Lease assignment: Transfer all rights and responsibilities to a new tenant with landlord approval.
  • Negotiated buyout: Offer a lump sum or other compensation to end the lease by mutual agreement.
  • Appeal to hardship clauses: Some leases may include clauses allowing for termination due to unforeseen financial or operational crises.

Potential Financial Impacts and Legal Considerations

  • Ending a lease early can lead to:
    • Termination fees: Often equivalent to several months' rent or a set flat fee.
    • Liability for remaining lease term: Landlords may invoke acceleration clauses to demand full payment for the term.
    • Legal disputes: Landlords may sue for damages if terms are unclear or contested.
    • To mitigate risks:
      • Seek legal advice: Lawyers can negotiate settlements or defend against excessive claims.
      • Document landlord mitigation efforts: If the landlord fails to re-lease the space promptly, tenants may have grounds to reduce financial liability.

FAQ Section:

  1. What is a commercial lease early termination clause?
    It is a provision allowing tenants or landlords to end a lease before its expiration under predefined terms.
  2. How can tenants negotiate an early termination clause?
    Tenants should offer fair compensation, emphasize the landlord's benefits, and consult legal experts to secure favorable terms.
  3. What happens if there’s no early termination clause?
    Tenants may face financial penalties and legal liabilities, but options like subleasing or mutual agreement may help.
  4. Are there alternatives to early termination?
    Yes, tenants can consider subleasing, assigning the lease, or negotiating a buyout to manage obligations without breaching the contract.
  5. What are the common penalties for ending a lease early?
    These include termination fees, liability for unpaid rent, and potential legal action from the landlord.

If you need help interpretting a commercial lease early termination clause, you can post your legal needs on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.