Key Takeaways:

  • Converting a C corporation to an LLC can offer tax advantages, management flexibility, and reduced paperwork, but it also has drawbacks such as potential tax liabilities and difficulties in attracting investors.
  • The IRS does not provide a simple form for conversion; businesses must follow a legal process, including filing a Certificate of Conversion and completing necessary state and federal tax forms.
  • Some states allow statutory conversions, making the process simpler, while others require dissolution of the corporation before forming an LLC.
  • Tax consequences of conversion depend on whether the business is an S-Corp or C-Corp, with potential capital gains and recapture taxes being factors.
  • After conversion, businesses must update tax elections, licenses, and employer identification numbers (EINs) to remain compliant.
  • The transition affects liability protections, ownership structures, and compliance requirements, so consulting a business attorney is highly recommended.

To change a corporation to an LLC is simple in most states, and forming a Limited Liability Company or LLC is a smart choice for many small businesses. The tax factors of converting are not as simple, though. And, the conversion can result in a large tax bill.

Converting a Corporation to a Limited Liability Company

Pass-through federal taxation is one major advantage of an LLC over a corporation. The reason this is an advantage is that profits of a corporation are taxed two times. First, when the company earns the money and again, when the profits are passed to the owners in the form of wages. When an LLC earns profits, they are not taxed. So, when you convert from a corporation to an LLC without dissolving your corporation, the IRS requires you to file a document called a Certificate of Conversion. You must file it with the state agency that registers business organizations.

There are a number of reasons that corporations wish to change the form of their organization to an LLC, including concentrating the ownership into a smaller group or to take advantage of an LLC's unique tax options. However, you can't just fill out a form to change a corporation to an LLC. Plus, there are advantages to corporations, too. 

First, you must fully dissolve the corporation. Then, you form a new LLC, and all assets are transferred to the new company before the transition is complete. You need to know the positives of converting a corporation to an LLC and the cost of changing from a corporation to know if it makes sense for your business. 

Understanding the IRS Requirements for Converting a C Corp to an LLC

The IRS does not provide a single, standardized form to convert a C corporation into an LLC. Instead, businesses must follow a multi-step process involving state and federal filings. The required IRS filings depend on whether the corporation was classified as a C corporation or an S corporation prior to the conversion.

For a C corporation, the process generally includes:

  • Filing IRS Form 8832 (Entity Classification Election) if the new LLC elects to be taxed as a corporation.
  • Completing a final corporate tax return (Form 1120) to report any gains or losses from the liquidation of corporate assets.
  • Reporting any distributions of assets to shareholders on their personal tax returns.

For an S corporation, the IRS may require:

  • Filing a final Form 1120-S and issuing Schedule K-1s to shareholders.
  • Notifying the IRS that the business entity classification has changed, which may require Form 2553 if the LLC elects to be taxed as an S-corp.

Additionally, the business may need to apply for a new Employer Identification Number (EIN) if the IRS considers it a new entity.

Differences Between Corporations and LLCs

The protection of personal liability for business obligations is the same whether you're doing business as an LLC or corporation. The way corporations and LLCs are managed, owned, and taxed is different. LLCs are more flexible with taxes and offer owners more options than corporations. 

State-Specific Considerations for Converting a C Corp to an LLC

Each state has different requirements for converting a C corporation into an LLC. Some states, like Delaware and California, allow a statutory conversion, meaning businesses can file a Certificate of Conversion with the Secretary of State without dissolving the corporation. This simplifies the transition and reduces paperwork.

In states that do not allow statutory conversions, businesses must follow a two-step process:

  1. Dissolve the corporation by filing Articles of Dissolution and liquidating corporate assets.
  2. Form a new LLC by filing Articles of Organization and creating an operating agreement.

States may also impose additional fees, franchise taxes, or reporting requirements during the transition. Business owners should consult their state’s business filing office or a legal professional to understand specific obligations.

Benefits of an LLC Over a Corporation

  • Corporations need to have a board of directors, and LLCs can choose their management structure.
  • The profits and losses are distributed among owners of a corporation based on how many shares are owned, while LLC members may distribute losses and profits in any way they choose.
  • The tax flexibility and recordkeeping requirements are more flexible with LLCs than corporations.

Tax Implications of Converting a C Corp to an LLC

The tax consequences of converting a C corporation into an LLC depend on how the transition is structured. The IRS treats the conversion as a liquidation event, meaning:

  • The corporation must recognize capital gains on appreciated assets.
  • Any assets distributed to shareholders may be subject to capital gains tax at both the corporate and individual levels.
  • If the corporation has any depreciation recapture, the business may owe additional taxes.

For an S corporation, the tax impact is generally lower since pass-through taxation already applies. However, shareholders should still expect potential capital gains tax implications.

To minimize the tax burden, business owners should consider structuring the conversion strategically, such as by spreading distributions over multiple tax years or electing to be taxed as an S-corp under the LLC structure.

Advantages of Converting From a Corporation to an LLC

There are numerous reasons that companies may choose to switch from a corporation to an LLC. Below are a few:

1. Take advantage of pass-through taxes.

  • There are advantages to pass-through taxation. The IRS taxes the money corporations make when the company earns money, and then, owners pay taxes again on the money they make.
  • Some corporations are able to avoid being taxed twice by conducting business as an S corporation. 

2. Gain flexibility.

  • In a corporation, you receive profits and losses in proportion to the number of shares you own.
  • Members of an LLC divide profits in whatever way they choose.
  • Losses and profits of an LLC do not have to be split among members based on their ownership.

3. Gain management flexibility.

  • The board of director, officer, and shareholder structure might not work for small businesses.
  • An LLC allows you increased flexibility.
  • Corporations have a strict structure. 

4. Avoid paperwork. 

  • Switching to an LLC might save you from all of that corporate paperwork.
  • Corporations have to file required paperwork like meeting minutes.

Disadvantages of Converting From a Corporation to an LLC

In addition to there being advantages to converting a corporation to an LLC, there are some disadvantages you should be aware of listed below:

1. The business may pay more taxes.

  • The business is taxed on assets and gains on assets which have appreciated since the business was acquired.
  • The business must pay the tax even if they do not actually receive the money.
  • When a corporation converts to an LLC, the business may be required to pay taxes at the corporate and at the individual level.
  • Typically, when an S corporation converts the business, they will likely only pay taxes at the individual shareholder level.

2. Investors are not as interested in LLCs.

  • Pretty much all investors, including angel investors, want to invest in corporations, not in LLCs.
  • If you switch from a corporation to an LLC, you may have to change back to pursue funding.

3. Transferring membership in an LLC is more difficult.

4. Corporations are better for giving employees stock incentives.

So, there are important advantages for converting your business from a corporation to an LLC. However, there are also drawbacks, especially with taxes.

Post-Conversion Compliance and Legal Considerations

After successfully converting from a C corporation to an LLC, business owners must update various registrations and tax elections to remain compliant:

  • Update EIN and tax status: If required, apply for a new Employer Identification Number (EIN) and update IRS records regarding entity classification.
  • Revise business licenses and permits: Local and state business licenses must reflect the new LLC structure.
  • Notify financial institutions: Banks and lenders may require updated operating agreements and tax status before maintaining accounts or approving loans.
  • Inform investors and stakeholders: If external investors were involved in the corporation, their interests may need to be adjusted to fit the LLC structure.

Ensuring compliance with these updates prevents legal complications and keeps the business in good standing.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. What IRS form is needed to convert a C Corp to an LLC?
    There is no direct IRS form to convert a C corporation to an LLC. However, businesses may need to file Form 8832 (Entity Classification Election), a final Form 1120 or 1120-S, and potentially apply for a new EIN.
  2. Can a C corporation convert to an LLC without dissolving?
    Some states allow statutory conversions, which let businesses convert without formally dissolving. If statutory conversion is not available, the corporation must dissolve and form a new LLC.
  3. How does converting a C Corp to an LLC affect taxes?
    The conversion is treated as a liquidation event, which may trigger capital gains tax and depreciation recapture at both the corporate and shareholder level.
  4. How long does it take to convert a corporation to an LLC?
    The timeline varies by state but typically takes a few weeks to a few months. The IRS processing of tax elections may add additional time.
  5. Do I need a lawyer to convert a C Corp to an LLC?
    While not legally required, a business attorney can help navigate state-specific regulations, minimize tax liabilities, and ensure compliance with all legal requirements.

If you need help converting your corporation to an LLC, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law.