Key Takeaways

  • You can sell stock certificates without a broker, but the process involves verifying ownership and working with a transfer agent.
  • If your certificate is lost, reissue it through the issuing company or its transfer agent, and expect to buy an indemnity bond and pay a reissue fee.
  • Selling stocks privately requires signing and mailing the certificate securely to the assignee, often using certified mail with insurance.
  • Many online brokers allow you to convert physical certificates to electronic form for easier selling and recordkeeping.
  • Transfer agents can assist in recording and authenticating transactions, which is essential when bypassing brokers.

"Can I sell shares without a certificate?" is a question many shareholders end up asking themselves. The answer is no because the certificate needs to be endorsed to be sold, but you can get your paper certificate reissued.

Reissuing a Certificate

If you've misplaced your stock certificate, you can follow these steps to have it reissued:

  • Contact the company
  • Contact the transfer agency
  • Buy an indemnity bond
  • Pay a reissue fee

Contact the Company

Paper share certificates are important to possess because having one means your name is on the company's share register. Being included on it gives you the option to vote as a shareholder, and you will also receive correspondence and dividends directly from the company. Having those benefits is useful if you'd like to have a say in the future of the company.

If you've lost your certificate or never received one, reach out to the investor relations department of the company that issued your shares and ask them for the transfer agent that deals with their stock certificates; this information might be available online under the company's investor relations page. Transfer agents are simply the companies that keep track of the shareholders' information. Occasionally, large companies will be their own transfer agents, but generally the transfer agents are banks or trust companies. They'll have on record the number of shares issued to each shareholder, the stock certificate numbers, and the contact information for shareholders.

Contact the Transfer Agency

After you let the transfer agency know that your certificates need to be replaced, they will do the following:

  • Request an affidavit. The transfer agency will require that that you supply them with an affidavit that details the missing certificates and how you lost them. There are several ways certificates could have been lost, such as fraud, theft, or being misplaced during a move, so make sure you are very detailed in your description.
  • Issue a stop transfer. This works much like a stop payment does for a check. No one else will be able to cash the certificates as long as a stop transfer is active.
  • Alert the Securities and Exchange Commission. The agency will also let the Securities and Exchange Commission, or SEC, know that your certificates are missing and are in the process of being reissued.

Buy an Indemnity Bond

Next, you may need to buy an indemnity bond. Should the certificates be redeemed later, the company and transfer agency will be protected by the indemnity bond. The rates are usually between 1 to 5 percent of the stock certificates' value.

Pay a Reissue Fee

Because you are asking for a paper certificate to be issued, you'll be charged a fee. This fee varies depending on the transfer agent, but expect to pay anywhere from $50 to $500. New shares will be issued after your information and payments are verified.

How to Sell a Certificate

It's not necessary to use a broker to sell your stocks; however, if you choose to use one that you do not have an account with, be prepared to pay a sizable fee. Brokerage firms no longer offer free or low prices to non-clients who only want help selling stock.

As the owner of a stock, you have the right to assign your shares to someone else, who will be known as the assignee. To transfer your stock, you must sign the back of the certificate, date the transfer, and name the assignee. The term of the sale and the price of the certificate are not written on the certificate. The new assignee can then get the certificate reissued in their name or send it to their brokerage for record keeping.

Should you decide to send the paper certificate to the assignee via mail, you need to make sure it's protected during transit. Use certified mail and get insurance through USPS. Getting delivery confirmation will also provide peace of mind, along with photocopying the front and back of the certificate to prove possession quickly should it get lost. If the certificate does get lost, contact the transfer agent for a stop transfer.

What to Do If You Inherited Stock Certificates

If you've inherited stock certificates and want to sell them, additional steps are required:

  • Verify Ownership: The transfer agent will need documentation showing your legal right to the shares. This often includes a will, death certificate, and a court-issued Letter of Testamentary or Small Estate Affidavit.
  • Retitle the Shares: Once the paperwork is approved, the shares can be transferred into your name before you sell them.
  • Proceed with Sale: You can then follow the standard procedures to sell, either privately or through an online platform.

Advantages and Disadvantages of Selling Without a Broker

Advantages:

  • Avoids broker commissions: You save on fees typically charged by traditional brokerage firms.
  • Direct control: You manage the transaction on your own terms, including negotiating sale price.

Disadvantages:

  • Complex documentation: Selling without a broker requires meticulous paperwork and potential legal oversight.
  • Risk of errors: Mistakes in endorsements or delivery could lead to delays or losses.
  • Lack of market access: You may not get the best price compared to market trades facilitated by brokers.

Online Brokers

Online brokers don't require you to have paper stock certificates. If you have paper certificates, you can deposit them with the online broker of your choice to convert them to electronic files with electronic record keeping, which will conveniently eliminate the need for you to hold paper certificates.

How to Sell Stock Privately Without a Broker

If you want to sell your shares without using a broker, you can conduct a private sale directly with a buyer, such as a friend, relative, or business partner. Here's how:

  1. Identify the Buyer: Make sure you know and trust the buyer, as this is a direct transaction without brokerage oversight.
  2. Contact the Transfer Agent: Request guidance on how to transfer the stock. The transfer agent will help facilitate the legal ownership change and issue a new certificate to the buyer.
  3. Prepare a Stock Power Form: This legal document allows the transfer of ownership. It is typically required when endorsing the back of a certificate is not enough or if additional authentication is needed.
  4. Notarize the Signature: For security, many transfer agents require the seller’s signature on the stock certificate or power form to be guaranteed under a Medallion Signature Guarantee.
  5. Deliver the Certificate: Send the endorsed certificate and supporting documents (like the power form) to the transfer agent. Use insured, trackable shipping services.

Once the transfer is processed, the buyer will receive a new certificate or have the shares deposited electronically, depending on their preference.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. Can I sell a stock certificate that is not in my name?
    No. The certificate must be in your name or legally transferred to you before selling.
  2. Do I need a Medallion Signature Guarantee to sell stock without a broker?
    Yes, most transfer agents require this for verifying the seller’s signature on the stock certificate or transfer documents.
  3. How can I find the transfer agent for my stock?
    Visit the issuing company’s investor relations page or call their corporate office to get the transfer agent’s contact information.
  4. Is there a way to avoid paying high fees when selling shares?
    Yes. Selling privately or through a low-cost online broker can help minimize fees, but be aware of associated risks and documentation needs.
  5. Can I convert a paper stock certificate into electronic shares?
    Yes. Most online brokers will allow you to deposit the physical certificate into your account and convert it to digital format for easier management and sale.

If you need help with how to sell stock certificates without a broker, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.