Key Takeaways:

  • LLC Owners' Liability: Generally, LLC owners are not personally liable for business debts or legal obligations, but exceptions exist.
  • Piercing the Corporate Veil: Courts may allow creditors to pursue LLC members’ personal assets in cases of fraud, misuse of company funds, or undercapitalization.
  • Personal Guarantees: If an LLC owner personally guarantees a loan or business obligation, they can be held liable.
  • Professional Liability: Certain professionals, such as lawyers and doctors, may not be able to limit personal liability through an LLC.
  • Negligence & Direct Involvement: If an LLC owner directly participates in wrongful actions, such as fraud or negligence, they can be sued personally.
  • State-Specific Laws: Rules regarding LLC owner liability vary by state, making legal consultation essential.

Can a LLC be sued? Generally, an owner of an LLC is not legally responsible for the actions of the business. Therefore, an owner cannot be sued for the obligations of the company. However, there are certain situations where an LLC owner can personally be sued for the actions of an LLC.

Can an LLC Be Sued?

A limited liability company (LLC) is a fairly modern business entity that is governed by the laws of each state. In the 1970s, Florida and Wyoming became the first states to recognize this type of business structure. By 2010, LLCs became recognized in all 50 states and in the District of Columbia, each with its own state statutes regulating the creation, management, and termination surrounding LLCs. Similar to a corporation, an LLC is individual legal entity that has the capability to sue or to be sued.

Separate legal entity: According to state laws, LLCs are considered independent entities that are legally separate from their managers and owners, who also are referred to as “members.” In the court system, LLCs and corporations basically receive the same treatment. This helps to legally protect officers, directors, and shareholders, and to stimulate commerce. LLCs can build their credit with lenders by entering into leases and other financially-based contracts.

Asset protection: One significant benefit of establishing an LLC is that it protects members' personal assets. This means that owners are not accountable for the liabilities and debts of the LLC. To specify, if an LLC is sued and owes a financial judgment, the plaintiff generally cannot pursue the members' personal assets or bank accounts. Likewise, the same rules apply for credit lenders who financially back LLCs.

In the legal system, this liability protection is referred to as the “corporate veil.” Piercing the corporate veil occurs when corporate directors and officers are held liable for a corporation‘s actions. There are cases in which the courts will use the principal of “piercing the corporate veil” to go after the personal assets of LLC members. This typically occurs when the members have been involved in fraudulent activities.

Laws regarding this doctrine vary from state to state, but there are some common factors that exist. When determining if the corporate veil should be pierced, the courts will examine the following:

  • Misuse of company funds: One or more members misuse funds by using company money for personal use or co-mingling company and personal bank accounts
  • Capitalization of the LLC: Companies with large debts and minimal capital may raise a red flag in some cases
  • If fraud was involved: One or more owners used the LLC to participate in fraudulent activity

Courts typically make this decision on a case by case basis, using a fact-based examination. Piercing the corporate veil is typically more effective with small, close companies and privately-held entities. These are corporations that have limited assets and a small number of shareholders.

Service professionals: There are many state laws that limit the ability of service professionals to create an LLC. These professionals may include lawyers, architects, doctors, and accountants. Owners of these business types may consider forming an LLC in order to reduce risk and limit liability. However, many states prohibit service professionals from starting an LLC, instead requiring them to form a professional limited liability company (PLLC). PLLCs often have different rules and regulations than LLCs.

Additionally, some states permit professionals to form PLLCs or LLCs, but restrict the entity from limiting their liability for professional malpractice. As a service provider, it's important to understand the legal rules and regulations in the state where your business entity is located.

Common Reasons an LLC May Be Sued

An LLC, like any business entity, can face lawsuits for various reasons, including:

  • Breach of Contract: If an LLC fails to fulfill contractual obligations, vendors, clients, or business partners may sue.
  • Employment Disputes: Employees can sue an LLC for wrongful termination, discrimination, or wage violations.
  • Personal Injury Claims: If someone is injured on LLC property or due to its business operations, the LLC can be held liable.
  • Intellectual Property Disputes: An LLC can face lawsuits if it infringes on trademarks, copyrights, or patents.
  • Fraud & Misrepresentation: If an LLC engages in deceptive business practices, customers or business partners may file a lawsuit.

While an LLC provides legal protection to its owners, the company itself remains vulnerable to lawsuits and legal actions.

Can an Owner of an LLC Be Sued Personally?

A major concern when starting a business is being able to protect the owner's personal assets. Many business owners are worried that if their business makes a mistake, they'll lose their business, home, and other assets. A sole proprietorship offers no protection to the owner. For example, if the owner lacks the funds to settle a lawsuit, then the owner must pay out the difference from their own personal assets.

An LLC provides protection to the owner's assets and doesn't make them liable to the business's creditors. Also, an owner is usually not able to be sued for actions taken by the business. Of course, there are situations where personal liability protection has been lost.

When Can You Sue an LLC Owner Personally?

Although LLCs are designed to shield owners from personal liability, certain circumstances can expose an LLC member to personal lawsuits, including:

  1. Piercing the Corporate Veil: Courts may hold an owner personally liable if:
    • Business and personal finances are mixed (commingling funds).
    • The LLC is undercapitalized, making it unable to meet financial obligations.
    • The LLC is used to commit fraud or wrongful acts.
  2. Personal Guarantees: If an LLC owner signs a personal guarantee for a loan, lease, or contract, they are personally responsible if the LLC defaults.
  3. Direct Involvement in Wrongdoing: LLC owners who personally engage in fraud, negligence, or illegal business practices can be sued individually.
  4. Negligence or Personal Liability in Professional Services: Some states require certain professionals (e.g., doctors, lawyers) to form professional LLCs (PLLCs) instead of regular LLCs. Even within a PLLC, an individual professional may be personally liable for malpractice claims.
  5. Employment & Wage Violations: In some cases, courts have held LLC owners personally responsible for violations of labor laws, such as unpaid wages or wrongful termination.

Understanding these exceptions helps business owners protect themselves from personal liability while maintaining the integrity of their LLC.

Protecting Yourself as an LLC Owner

To minimize the risk of personal liability, LLC owners should take the following precautions:

  • Maintain Business Formalities: Keep business and personal finances separate, follow proper LLC procedures, and document company decisions.
  • Ensure Proper Capitalization: Adequately fund the LLC to avoid claims of undercapitalization.
  • Use Contracts Correctly: Avoid personally guaranteeing business debts and obligations whenever possible.
  • Avoid Fraudulent or Negligent Actions: Always operate the business in good faith and avoid fraudulent or misleading practices.
  • Obtain Liability Insurance: General liability insurance and professional liability insurance can provide additional protection.
  • Understand State-Specific Laws: Different states have varying rules about LLC liability, making legal advice critical.

By following these best practices, LLC owners can reduce their risk of being sued personally and protect their personal assets.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. Can you sue an LLC owner for business debts?
    Generally, no. LLCs provide limited liability, meaning the business is responsible for its debts. However, an owner may be personally liable if they personally guaranteed the debt or engaged in fraudulent conduct.
  2. What happens if an LLC is sued but has no assets?
    If an LLC lacks assets to pay a judgment, plaintiffs may attempt to "pierce the corporate veil" to go after the owner's personal assets, depending on the circumstances.
  3. Can an LLC protect me from personal liability in all cases?
    No. While an LLC provides strong liability protection, owners can still be sued personally for fraud, negligence, or if they personally guarantee financial obligations.
  4. What is an example of piercing the corporate veil?
    If an LLC owner pays personal expenses from the company’s account or uses the LLC to defraud creditors, courts may disregard the LLC's liability protection and hold the owner personally responsible.
  5. Should I consult a lawyer if my LLC is sued?
    Yes. Legal guidance is essential to navigate lawsuits, protect your LLC’s structure, and ensure you do not face personal liability.

If you need help determining if an LLC can be sued, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.