Key Takeaways

  • When both parties agree to cancel a contract, the agreement is nullified by mutual consent, but legal and procedural steps may still apply.
  • Mutual termination can occur through prior agreement, impossibility of performance, breach of contract, or rescission due to misrepresentation or illegality.
  • Parties must clearly define how cancellation works—often through written notice, cancellation clauses, or settlement agreements.
  • Consideration, such as returning deposits or compensating for expenses, may be necessary to make mutual rescission enforceable.
  • Clear communication and documentation (e.g., termination letters or mutual rescission agreements) help avoid disputes later.

Both parties agree to cancel a contract results in the terms and conditions of the contract becoming null and void, upon mutual consent of both (or, all) parties involved. With that said, even though all involved parties may agree to cancel the contract, there may exist stipulations that have to still be met. Additionally, it is worth noting that only the parties who entered into the contract may make the decision to cancel it.

What is a Contract?

A contract is a legally-binding document that has been agreed upon by all the parties involved, either via written or oral consent. Generally, there are activities that must be completed by either one or all parties before a contract is considered to have been completed.

Understanding Mutual Agreement to Cancel

When both parties agree to cancel a contract, this is known as mutual rescission. It recognizes that obligations under the contract will no longer apply and that neither party can enforce the terms moving forward. However, the parties must usually show evidence that they intended to release each other from their responsibilities. A mutual rescission can be:

  • Express – documented in writing and signed by all parties.
  • Implied – inferred from the conduct of both parties, such as ceasing performance and returning consideration.

Mutual cancellation does not erase what has already occurred under the contract. Payments or services already delivered are typically not undone unless specifically agreed.

Impossibility of Performance

Perfomance, within the context of a contract, applies to the duties that have to be carried out in accordance with the terms and conditions spelled-out. For example, you may hire a painter to come and paint your house. Once the painter has painted the rooms or areas that he was hired to do, that is considered performance.

However, if for some reason, the painter is unable to do, or complete, the job for which he was hired, then it is known as impossibility of performance. At this point, you have the right to terminate the contract. Additionally, depending upon the circumstances, you may be within your right to pursue damages for breach of contract.

Practical Considerations in Cancellation

Even if both parties agree to cancel, it’s important to consider how this affects outstanding obligations. For instance, deposits may need to be refunded, or one party may need to compensate the other for partial work already completed. Many contracts include termination clauses spelling out these obligations.

Practical steps when both parties agree to cancel include:

  • Reviewing the contract’s cancellation or termination clause.
  • Drafting a short mutual rescission agreement confirming the release of obligations.
  • Clarifying what happens to deposits, intellectual property, or work in progress.

This ensures that neither party can later claim damages or try to enforce performance.

Breach of Contract

Breach of contract occurs when one of the parties, with whom written or oral consent is given, and who is involved in the contract, intentionally does not fulfill their end of the agreement. A breach of contract can occur either as a result of none of the terms and conditions having been met, or as a result of only a partial job having been done. As such, there are different classifications of a breach of contract:

  • Material breach, which allows for the injured party (for example, the homeowner in the aforementioned example) to seek damages.
  • Immaterial breach, which does not allow for the injured party to seek monetary damages.

A material breach essentially creates hardship for the injured party. For example, if the previously mentioned housepainter either never shows up to complete the job for which they were hired, or if they do a subpar job, causing you to then have to hire someone else to fix it, then that could be seen as a material breach. Meanwhile, if the house painter completed the job and did so sufficiently, but was a day or two late in completing the job, then that may be seen as an immaterial breach.

The Role of Consideration in Rescission

In most cases, courts require consideration to enforce a mutual rescission. Consideration refers to something of value exchanged between the parties. In contract cancellation, this could include:

  • Returning deposits or prepaid funds.
  • Providing partial payment for services rendered.
  • Agreeing not to pursue legal action.

The presence of consideration ensures that the cancellation is legally binding and not just an informal promise. Without it, one party could later argue that the rescission is unenforceable.

Prior Agreement

Some contracts allow for a prior agreement between the involved parties, to terminate a contract, for specific reasons. However, the contract must specifically spell-out what the reasons may be for the parties to agree to cancel the contract, and both parties must agree on those reasons, upon signing the contract. For example, if you want your house painted a specific color, bought at a specific price, you and the house painter may put a provision in your contract that if he cannot find that paint color, or cannot find it at the price you are expecting, then you can mutually agree to cancel the contract.

Additionally, the contract should specifically state what actions need to be taken by one, or all, parties in order to cancel the contract. Generally speaking, a written notice provided by one party to the other, is sufficient in cancelling a contract.

Written Notice and Documentation

Even when both parties agree, written documentation is strongly advised. A termination letter or mutual rescission agreement should include:

  • Identification of the original contract.
  • A clear statement that both parties agree to cancel.
  • Allocation of responsibility for any outstanding obligations.
  • Signatures of all involved parties.

This written record prevents disputes and provides legal clarity. Many businesses use a simple contract cancellation template to ensure the document is legally sound and covers essential terms.

Rescission of a Contract

If one of the parties, who has entered into a contract, turns out to have misrepresented themselves, or acted illegally, then the contract termination is known as rescission of a contract. This essentially serves a complete eradication of the contract. Many contracts will include a cancellation clause to address such issues; should you find yourself in a position of needing or wanting to rescind a contract, you will want to ensure that you are doing so in accordance with what the appropriate clause in the contract states. Some reasons as to why rescission of a contract may occur, include:

  • One of the parties being under the age of 18 and therefore not being legally capable of entering into a legal agreement
  • One of the parties lacking the mental capacity to enter into a contract
  • One of the parties being coerced (threats, blackmail, etc.) into signing the contract

There are any number of reasons as to why a contract may be cancelled or terminated. Obviously, the ideal scenario is when all of the parties involved are in agreement as to doing so and the reasons as to why.

Alternatives to Cancellation

Sometimes, instead of canceling outright, both parties agree to modify the contract. Modifications allow the relationship to continue under new terms without fully rescinding the original agreement. For example:

  • Changing delivery timelines if circumstances shift.
  • Adjusting payment schedules to accommodate financial hardship.
  • Narrowing the scope of work instead of canceling the project.

This approach preserves the business relationship while still addressing practical concerns. It is particularly useful when both parties want to maintain goodwill and avoid the appearance of breach.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. Can both parties agree to cancel a contract at any time?
    Yes, but the agreement must be mutual, and consideration or documentation is often needed to make the cancellation enforceable.
  2. Do both parties need to sign something to cancel a contract?
    While verbal agreements may be valid, a written rescission agreement or termination letter is strongly recommended for legal clarity.
  3. What happens to money already paid if a contract is canceled?
    It depends on the agreement. Parties may return deposits, retain partial payments for work completed, or otherwise negotiate a settlement.
  4. Is mutual rescission the same as breach of contract?
    No. Breach occurs when one party fails to perform without consent. Mutual rescission is a voluntary agreement by both parties to end the contract.
  5. Can a contract be modified instead of canceled?
    Yes. If both parties agree, they can amend terms such as timelines, payments, or obligations rather than canceling outright.

If you need help with both parties agree, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel’s marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.