Key Takeaways

  • The fiduciary duty of board of directors includes the core duties of care, loyalty, and obedience, applicable across for-profit and nonprofit sectors.
  • Directors must act in good faith and in the best interest of the organization, using reasonable diligence and sound judgment.
  • Conflicts of interest must be disclosed and managed appropriately under the duty of loyalty.
  • Fiduciary duties evolve with emerging risks such as cybersecurity, ESG factors, and stakeholder accountability.
  • Breach of fiduciary duty can result in personal liability, legal claims, and reputational damage.
  • Board members can reduce liability exposure by documenting decisions, attending training, and seeking legal advice.

Board of directors' fiduciary duty refers to the highest standard of care. Board members and officers are fiduciaries, and by statutory and common law mandate, they must act with the utmost responsibility.

The term fiduciary refers to a person who has unique responsibilities related to monitoring, distribution, administration, and/or investment of property, such as public or charitable assets of the business, in addition to intangible assets, like the company's reputation and its role within the community.

What are the Fiduciary Duties of an Institution?

When referring to an educational institution, the fiduciary responsibility requires board members to make good-faith decisions that put the best interests of the institution in alignment with its charitable or public mission. This must be kept independent from undue influence by any person or any other financial interests. These are known as the fiduciary duties of care, loyalty, and obedience.

  • With regard to the duty of care, these individuals must perform their responsibilities in a manner that is in line with the care, diligence, and skill of an ordinarily prudent person who would find themselves in a similar situation in a corresponding position.
  • The duty of loyalty mandates board members and officers to behave in a manner that is in good faith and believed to put the interests of the institution before any personal interests or those of another person or organization. The fiduciary cannot act out of avarice or expedience either.
  • Obedience is the duty board members have to ensure the university or college is operating in a manner that furthers its stated purpose and is always operating in compliance with all statutes and regulations.

Core Principles Guiding Fiduciary Duties

Fiduciary duties are grounded in three legal principles:

  1. Duty of Care: Board members must act with the care a reasonably prudent person would take in similar circumstances. This includes staying informed, reviewing materials before meetings, and asking critical questions.
  2. Duty of Loyalty: Directors must place the institution’s interests above personal gain. They are expected to disclose any conflicts of interest and recuse themselves from decisions where impartiality could be compromised.
  3. Duty of Obedience: Directors must ensure that the organization complies with its stated mission, governing documents, and applicable laws and regulations.

These principles are not static—they evolve with governance standards, legal expectations, and stakeholder interests.

Fiduciary Duties of Board of Directors in a Corporation

In a corporation, the board of directors is the governing body that assists with high-level direction and helps advance the corporation's objectives. In addition to these responsibilities, directors also have a fiduciary duty. A corporate director has to conduct themselves in a good faith manner that he or she believes is in the best interest of the business and is in line with how an ordinarily prudent person would behave.

Board of directors have a fiduciary duty to exercise due care in how they manage a corporation's affairs and also have the duty of loyalty and obedience to the corporation. A fiduciary duty means that both directors and officers handle their powers only for the collective benefit of the corporation and its stockholders.

Fiduciary Responsibilities in For-Profit vs. Nonprofit Settings

While the fiduciary duty of board of directors applies broadly, its expression can differ between corporate and nonprofit settings:

  • For-Profit Corporations: The primary duty is to maximize shareholder value while maintaining legal and ethical compliance. This includes oversight of strategic direction, financial performance, and risk management.
  • Nonprofit Organizations: Fiduciary duties are aligned with the public or charitable mission. Directors must ensure that funds are used appropriately and that the organization remains true to its exempt purpose.

In both settings, directors should maintain transparency, act independently, and manage risk proactively.

Board Members' Roles and Responsibilities

A board member in a corporation is a person who is charged with directing the organization towards a more sustainable future through the adoption of ethical, legal, and sound management decisions and policies while ensuring the business has ample resources to carry out its mission statement. Businesses have to hire a responsible and talented Executive Director/CEO to handle the day-to-day management duties.

In a non-profit organization, board members are still called fiduciaries because they have a legal responsibility to properly manage the non-profit's assets. Board members in a non-profit must make numerous important decisions include appointing and recruiting new board members, hiring and firing managers and staff, conducting an annual audit, and monitoring financial reports. All of these activities fall under the three main duties — care, loyalty, and obedience.

Common Misconceptions About Fiduciary Duties

There are several myths around fiduciary duties that can lead to governance errors:

  • Myth 1: Fiduciary duty only applies to financial matters.
    In truth, it extends to legal compliance, strategic decisions, and protecting the organization’s reputation.
  • Myth 2: Only board officers have fiduciary duties.
    All board members, regardless of title, are held to fiduciary standards.
  • Myth 3: Abstaining from a vote avoids liability.
    Failing to act can still be seen as a breach of duty of care.

By debunking these myths, boards can operate more confidently within their legal boundaries.

Breach of Fiduciary Duty

All board members must understand their duties and how they fall into each category of fiduciary duties. Not understanding or being well-informed about fiduciary duties does not relieve members from their obligations or any subsequent liabilities they encounter by failing to fulfill these critical duties. A board director who diligently performs his or her fiduciary duties responsibly will help protect the organization's reputation, which also qualifies as a fiduciary duty.

When a court determines whether there has been a breach of fiduciary duty, they may consider a variety of factors:

  • Business condition
  • Character of corporation
  • How the corporation is usually managed
  • Other relevant facts

There are circumstances that make a director liable to the corporation, and sometimes to its creditors, shareholders, or other people, for any losses caused by his or her inability or failure to exercise due care. A director typically breaches his or her duty in one of two ways:

  • He or she commits overt acts that constitute mismanagement
  • No action can also be construed as a failure to direct

Emerging Trends in Fiduciary Governance

Modern governance requires directors to stay ahead of evolving responsibilities:

  • Cybersecurity Oversight: Boards are increasingly expected to monitor data privacy, cyber risk frameworks, and response plans.
  • Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG): Directors must weigh ESG risks and opportunities in long-term strategy.
  • Stakeholder Accountability: There’s a shift from shareholder primacy toward a broader duty to employees, communities, and the environment.
  • Digital Transformation and AI Ethics: Fiduciary duties now include understanding the impact of emerging technologies on operations and compliance.

Boards that fail to evolve may find themselves out of step with regulatory expectations and public trust.

Consequences of a Fiduciary Breach and How to Avoid Them

When board members violate their fiduciary responsibilities, the outcomes can be severe:

Potential Consequences:

  • Legal action by shareholders, stakeholders, or regulatory bodies
  • Personal liability for damages if gross negligence or bad faith is proven
  • Loss of insurance protection if actions fall outside the scope of coverage
  • Damage to the organization’s credibility and public trust

Preventive Measures:

  • Keep accurate and detailed board minutes
  • Disclose conflicts of interest and use recusal protocols
  • Regularly review governing documents and compliance obligations
  • Participate in ongoing board training
  • Use independent legal and financial counsel when appropriate

These steps help reinforce sound governance and mitigate legal exposure.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. What is the fiduciary duty of board of directors?
    The fiduciary duty of board of directors refers to their legal obligation to act in the best interest of the organization, including the duties of care, loyalty, and obedience.
  2. Can a board member be held personally liable for a fiduciary breach?
    Yes, especially if the breach involves gross negligence, conflict of interest, or failure to act in good faith.
  3. How can board members avoid breaching their fiduciary duties?
    By staying informed, disclosing conflicts, maintaining transparency, and seeking legal advice when needed.
  4. Does fiduciary duty apply to nonprofit board members?
    Absolutely. Nonprofit directors have the same legal responsibilities, tailored to their mission-driven purpose.
  5. What role does the duty of care play in decision-making?
    The duty of care requires directors to make well-informed decisions with diligence, skill, and prudence.
     

If you need help with understanding a board of director's fiduciary duty, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel only accepts the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.