Key Takeaways

  • Bad faith meaning refers to dishonest or deceptive behavior in legal and contractual obligations.
  • It applies to insurance claims, contract disputes, and business dealings where one party acts unfairly.
  • Indicators of bad faith include unreasonable denials, misleading statements, failure to investigate, and breach of implied good faith.
  • Legal consequences can include contract termination, financial damages, and lawsuits for unfair practices.
  • Bad faith can also apply to employment contracts, real estate transactions, and legal defenses in court cases.

The bad faith legal definition is when a person does something untrustworthy in a legal matter. This might include:

  • Not following through with legal obligations.
  • Giving the wrong idea to others about legal matters.
  • Going into an agreement knowing you won't honor it.
  • Acting dishonestly in a legal situation.

Individuals can file lawsuits over breaches of trust. Most states acknowledge "implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing." When someone violates this, the other party involved can file a lawsuit. Bad faith can be brought up as a defense in a contract suit. A bad faith offer or bad faith contract are the terms used to describe a bad faith business deal. Examples of bad faith involving business deals done dishonestly include:

  • Going into an agreement knowing you will not adhere to it.
  • Giving misleading information about something that is bought or sold.

What Is Bad Faith?

Bad faith can also include a person trying to get ahead by being dishonest with another person. Bad faith is breaking a legal commitment to another party. All commitments are affected, including paying claims or canceling an insurance policy. Insurers can be found guilty of bad faith if they:

  • Don't investigate a claim appropriately.
  • Delay a payment for a long period.
  • Deny benefits of a claim in an unreasonable way.
  • Translate policy language in an unreasonable way.
  • Don't settle a case or refuse to issue you a refund for your loss.

Some policies have a specific amount of time in which to settle a claim. If they don't, a "reasonable time" is provided, which is subjective based on each case.

A person who files a suit against someone else to harass them is doing so in bad faith. If the court proves that harassment was the reason for the filing, the defendant's attorney fees will be awarded.

If a person's main goal is to deceive and defraud him or herself or someone else, this is also considered bad faith. "Double-heartedness" goes hand in hand with bad faith. Double-heartedness involves a person acting a certain way on the surface but with bad motives.

When someone is doing something in bad faith, it's to cheat another person out of something. Take, for example, a boss promising an employee something, without ever planning to keep that promise. Or, an attorney arguing a legal position that is not true, such as his client being innocent. A person can also use bad faith against him or herself. A hypochondriac, for example, makes himself believe he is sick when he is perfectly healthy.

A person acting in bad faith might go into an agreement without intending to complete the agreement. This person might also falsely represent the details of an item, such as a home or car, being sold to someone who will then buy it under false pretenses. A person performing in bad faith is trying to lie about something to get ahead.

Contract negotiations are notorious for being involved in bad-faith situations. These include issuing cancellations and paying out insurance claims.

Types of Bad Faith in Legal and Business Settings

Bad faith behavior can arise in various areas of law and business dealings, often leading to legal disputes. Common categories include:

  1. Insurance Bad Faith – When an insurer fails to honor policy terms, denies valid claims, or unreasonably delays payments.
  2. Contractual Bad Faith – When a party enters a contract without intention to perform or actively undermines the agreement.
  3. Employment Bad Faith – When an employer makes deceptive promises or terminates an employee under false pretenses.
  4. Real Estate Bad Faith – When a seller misrepresents property details, conceals defects, or engages in predatory lending.
  5. Litigation Bad Faith – When a party files a lawsuit with malicious intent, such as harassment or delaying tactics.

Recognizing these different forms of bad faith can help individuals and businesses protect their rights.

Elements of a Bad Faith Insurance Claim

Insurance companies have more power than policyholders. They have more finances, can negotiate, and are experts in their field. Most courts find that insurance companies deal with fairness and good faith with their clients. You can file a lawsuit if your insurance company does not act fairly concerning the processing, researching, or payment of your claim. State law defines bad faith concerning insurance companies.

Legal Standards for Proving Bad Faith

To successfully claim bad faith, plaintiffs must generally prove:

  • A contractual or legal duty existed between the parties.
  • One party failed to uphold their obligations in an unfair or deceptive manner.
  • Intentional misconduct or reckless disregard of fairness.
  • Harm resulted from the bad faith conduct, such as financial loss or contract breach.

Courts may use objective standards, such as industry norms, or subjective standards, focusing on the intent behind the actions. Laws governing bad faith vary by jurisdiction, making legal advice essential.

Elements of Common Law Bad Faith

The common law components of bad faith vary between states. Several states define bad faith as behavior that has been “unreasonable or without proper cause.” Some states have a more limited view of the definition of bad faith.

When deciding whether an insurance company has acted improperly, the court might look for one of these acts of bad behavior:

  • Providing misleading facts or policy terms.
  • Not acknowledging or addressing a claim right away.
  • Not investigating and processing claims properly.
  • Not approving or denying claims promptly, even after receiving the insured's proof of loss.
  • Not giving a good reason for denying a claim.

Common Examples of Bad Faith in Business and Contracts

Examples of bad faith vary across industries but commonly include:

  • Failure to disclose important information – Hiding key details in contracts, insurance policies, or financial transactions.
  • Unjustified contract terminations – Ending agreements without cause or misrepresenting terms.
  • Deliberate misinterpretation of contracts – Twisting language to benefit one party unfairly.
  • Lowball settlement offers in insurance claims – Offering significantly less than a claim is worth with no valid reason.
  • Refusal to negotiate in good faith – Engaging in deceptive practices during contract discussions.

Businesses and individuals can take preventative measures, such as keeping records, negotiating clear terms, and consulting an attorney when facing potential bad faith scenarios.

Frequently Asked Questions

1: What is an example of bad faith in an insurance claim?     An insurer refusing to investigate a claim, denying coverage without explanation, or delaying payments beyond reasonable time limits.

2: How can I prove bad faith in a contract dispute?     Documenting misleading statements, non-performance, or contract breaches, and providing evidence of harm caused.

3: Can bad faith apply to employment contracts?     Yes. Employers may act in bad faith by making false job promises, firing employees unfairly, or withholding earned benefits.

4: What damages can be recovered in a bad faith lawsuit?      Compensation for financial losses, punitive damages for intentional misconduct, and possibly attorney fees.

5: How can I protect myself from bad faith dealings?    Read contracts carefully, keep records of agreements, communicate in writing, and consult a lawyer when in doubt.

If you need help with bad faith legal definition, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.