Key Takeaways

  • An at will employment agreement allows termination by either party at any time, for any reason, with limited exceptions.
  • Employees cannot be fired for discriminatory or retaliatory reasons, or in violation of public policy.
  • Implied agreements, such as statements in handbooks or during interviews, can alter the presumption of at-will employment.
  • Employers benefit from flexibility, while employees often face job insecurity.
  • Employees should understand their rights and ask for clarity before signing such agreements.
  • Legal trends and public policy shifts continue to shape how at will employment is interpreted.

At will employment contracts govern at will employment, which means an employee is employed both at his/her will and the employer's will. It is legal to fire an employee at any time, for any reason, without explanation or warning. The flip side of this is that the employee can also quit for any reason, at any time, without explanation or warning. At will employment is popular in all states except Montana as it gives flexibility to both employers and employees.

A contract is also flexible in employment at will states. The employer can change an employment contract's terms without warning or penalty. However, employees have certain termination rights protected by contracts, employer policies, and state and federal law.

Employee Rights in At Will Employment Contracts

Both state and federal governments have laws governing reasons an employee cannot be fired for:

  • race
  • religion
  • citizenship
  • retaliation for a protected lawful action such as whistleblowing
  • disability
  • gender
  • age
  • sexual orientation
  • physical health
  • other protected categories

You can find which factors are protected by labor law online. You can also consult with an attorney if you think you were discriminated against.

Common Misconceptions About At Will Employment

Despite its prevalence, at will employment is often misunderstood by both employers and employees. One of the most common misconceptions is that employers can terminate an employee for any reason without consequence. In reality, terminations must still comply with federal and state laws prohibiting discrimination, harassment, and retaliation.

Another misconception is that at will status means employees have no rights. However, at will employees are still entitled to protections such as:

  • Fair wages and overtime under the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA)
  • A safe workplace under OSHA regulations
  • Leave under the Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA), if eligible
  • Protection from wrongful termination if their firing violates public policy or implied agreements

Understanding these rights can help employees avoid assuming they are completely unprotected.

At Will Employment Contract Exceptions

There are some exceptions to at will employment contracts. These include if an employee has an employment contract, is covered by a collective bargaining agreement, if discrimination is involved in termination, if public policy is violated, or if company policy gives guidelines for termination. Other exceptions include implied contracts, such as receiving an employee handbook, but this is difficult to prove in court and the burden rests on employees.

Good faith and fair dealing is another exception. This means an employer can not fire an employee to avoid paying them or any promised benefits.

Employers may not fire an employee if doing so would violate public policy. This law also prevents an employer from seeking damages against an employee who left if it benefits the public by doing so. However, eight states - Alabama, Florida, Georgia, Louisiana, Maine, Nebraska, New York, and Rhode Island - do not recognize this as a right.

Public Policy and Whistleblower Protections

Public policy exceptions protect employees from termination for reasons that violate legal norms or societal interests. For example, employers may not fire workers for:

  • Filing a workers’ compensation claim
  • Refusing to engage in illegal activities
  • Reporting safety violations or fraud (i.e., whistleblowing)
  • Performing jury duty or voting

Whistleblower laws vary by state, but many offer additional protections for employees who expose wrongdoing in government or private organizations. These laws serve to encourage ethical conduct and transparency in the workplace. While eight states do not formally recognize the public policy exception, federal laws may still offer protection depending on the nature of the complaint.

At Will Employment

Many prospective and new employees are confused by the statement that they will be employed at will. This means that in every state except Montana, employers can let you go for any reason and you have limited grounds to fight your termination. For example, you can be fired for your favorite pants being black. The law presumes you are employed at will unless your employer clearly states they will only fire you with cause, usually in written documents or oral statements.

Your employment documents probably indicate if you are an at will employee. If you have signed anything agreeing to this, that's the end of the story. If you have not, check your employer's written statements---do they say you can be fired at any time and without cause? Remember, they do not have to use the term "at will".

Some employers have a policy that requires cause for termination. If this is the case with your employer, you are entitled to rely on these rules. This is especially the case if you have a contract that states you can only be fired for cause. If you are fired for a reason not specified in the contract, you have a legal claim against your employer for breach of contract.

Statements by your employer such as "We only fire employees for repeated performance problems" constitute an implied contract, which your employer is bound by. However, if you are told you are an at will employee, that will mean your employment is at will.

Pros and Cons of an At Will Employment Agreement

Understanding the benefits and drawbacks of an at will employment agreement is crucial for employers and employees alike.

Pros for Employers:

  • Flexibility in managing workforce changes
  • Simplified termination process with fewer legal formalities
  • Faster response to poor performance or economic downturns

Pros for Employees:

  • Freedom to leave a job at any time without legal consequences
  • Increased mobility in the job market

Cons for Employers:

  • Potential for high turnover rates and reduced employee loyalty
  • Increased risk of wrongful termination claims if termination processes are poorly documented

Cons for Employees:

  • Lack of job security and predictability
  • Vulnerability to abrupt termination without severance or notice

These trade-offs highlight the importance of communication and clear policies to balance flexibility with fairness.

Signing an At Will Employment Contract

While you are not required to sign an at will employment contract, most courts have ruled that you can be fired or not hired for refusing to do so. Even if you do not sign the agreement that you are employed at will, the law presumes you are employed at will. Signing this, however, does not mean your employer will fire you without cause.

Be wary of signing an at will employment contract if your employer promises something else, such as you'll be given 90 days to learn your job and won't be fired during that time. Virtually all courts rule that a signed document stating you are employed at will supersedes any promises your employer made. If in doubt, ask about discrepancies, and get all promises in writing.

Best Practices for Employers Drafting At Will Agreements

Employers should take steps to ensure their at will employment agreements are enforceable and transparent. Key best practices include:

  • Clarity in Language: Use unambiguous terms to state that employment is at will and may be terminated at any time, with or without cause.
  • Avoid Contradictory Promises: Refrain from oral or written statements that imply long-term job security or guaranteed employment periods unless intended.
  • Update Policies Regularly: Ensure employee handbooks and internal procedures reflect the at will nature of employment.
  • Document Performance Issues: While not legally required, documenting performance issues helps mitigate potential wrongful termination claims.

Employers should also conduct exit interviews and termination meetings professionally and respectfully to reduce legal risk and maintain a strong employer brand.

When an At Will Employment Agreement May Not Apply

Even if you’ve signed an at will employment agreement, there are scenarios where it might not fully apply. These include:

  • Union Contracts: Employees covered by collective bargaining agreements are typically subject to “just cause” termination standards.
  • Written Employment Contracts: Contracts that specify a duration of employment or define termination conditions override the default at-will rule.
  • Public Employees: Many government workers have due process rights under civil service rules that limit arbitrary dismissal.
  • Promissory Estoppel: If an employee reasonably relies on a promise of continued employment to their detriment (e.g., relocating for a job), courts may recognize that promise as enforceable.

Understanding these exceptions can help employees and employers navigate the nuances of at will relationships more effectively. If in doubt, consulting a labor attorney is a smart step.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Can I be fired for no reason under an at will employment agreement? Yes, unless the termination violates a law or recognized exception, such as discrimination or retaliation.

2. Is an at will employment agreement required to be in writing? No, at will employment is presumed by default in most states, but a written agreement helps clarify the terms.

3. What if my offer letter says I can only be fired for cause? That may override the at will presumption, especially if it's detailed and signed by both parties.

4. Are there states where at will employment is not recognized? Montana is the only state that does not follow the at will doctrine; employers there must show good cause for termination after a probationary period.

5. Can I negotiate the terms of an at will agreement? Yes, you can negotiate for provisions such as notice periods or severance, though employers are not obligated to accept them.

If you need help with your at will employment contract, post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel only accepts the top 5 percent of lawyers, who come from law schools such as Harvard and Yale and average 14 years of legal experience working for or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Twillo.