Key Takeaways

  • Employee stock option pools (ESOPs) are a strategic tool startups use to hire and retain talent by offering them equity as compensation.

  • Stock options tie employee interests to the company’s success, incentivizing them to work toward long-term growth.

  • Dilution occurs when the company issues new shares, thus lowering ownership percentages for current shareholders. Founders must strategically negotiate the timing and size of the option pool to minimize dilution.

  • Vesting schedules, which dictate when your employees earn their stock options, are designed to help companies retain employees.

  • Legal compliance is essential and complex in setting up an ESOP, including stock option plans, forms of grants, and board approval. To avoid disputes, SEC and state law must also be followed.

  • Equity splits must be negotiated between founders, employees, and investors so everyone gets a fair share.

  • Working with a startup lawyer and using legal tools is the best way to ensure the ESOP is legal and will work for the company and the employees.

  • Post a job on UpCounsel to find a startup lawyer in your state.

 

An employee stock option pool (ESOP) can be a productive way to attract top talent to your startup. But what exactly is an ESOP, and how does it work? 
 

An employee option pool is a form of compensation offered to employees who own a share in the company and ensure their interests align with the company's. 
 

This article will discuss the critical considerations for creating and managing employee stock option pools at your startup.

 

 

Introduction to Employee Stock Option Pools

 

Employee stock option pools (ESOPs) are groups of company shares set aside for employees, advisors, and stakeholders in the early stages of a venture. Startups use them to compensate and retain talent by offering stock in the pay package. 
 

Stock options give the employee the right (but not the obligation) to buy shares at a predetermined price after a certain vesting period.

How ESOPs Attract and Retain Talent

ESOPs help employees align with the company's interests by providing a sense of ownership. They also motivate employees to work toward the company's long-term success. 
 

Stock options provide a competitive edge for startups that cannot offer high salaries. They help founders attract top talent by giving them the potential for significant financial rewards when the company grows.


 

The Impact of Option Pools on Dilution

 

When forming an employee stock option pool, one of your most important considerations is how it will impact dilution. 
 

Dilution is when the percentage of the company owned by all its shareholders is reduced when new shares are issued.
 

A company's valuation before new money is added is called its pre-money valuation, whereas after adding new money, it is called its post-money valuation. 
 

When founding employees negotiate an option pool, they must decide how much of the company’s equity they give workers versus investors.
 

Consider a startup with a pre-money valuation of $5 million that is interested in granting a 15% option pool before raising a $1 million financing round. The option pool and the new money would dilute the founders' ownership. 
 

However, if the option pool were created post-money, the dilution would be split between the founders and the new investors. 
 

This explains why many founders negotiate the option pool’s timeline and size while raising funds to minimize personal dilution.


 

Vesting Schedules: Structuring for Legal Compliance and Motivation

 

Dilution can be managed through negotiation of the size and timing of the option pool during successive financing rounds. 
 

To minimize dilution for founders:
 

  • Establish a smaller initial option pool and replenish it as needed.

  • Bargain with investors to share the dilution burden by agreeing on a post-money option pool.

Vesting Schedules: Structuring for Legal Compliance and Motivation

A stock option vesting schedule defines the time period in which employees earn their options. The most popular vesting schedule is a four-year plan with a one-year cliff vesting. 

In other words, employees must stay with the company for at least one year before receiving their first portion of stock options. The rest of the options then vest incrementally over the next three years.

Legal Implications of Performance-Based Vesting

Performance-based vesting conditions the payment of stock option grants on achieving a specific milestone. 

Performance-based vesting adds complexity to an already complicated contractual regime, not only from a corporate governance perspective but also legally. 

Stock option agreements must be precise to define the milestone to be reached. The company must also ensure it conforms to state law and SEC regulations to avoid shareholder disputes and litigation.

How Vesting Schedules Influence Employee Retention and Motivation

Vesting schedules encourage employees to stay on for the long haul by rewarding them only when they don’t cash in their stock options before the full vesting period. 

Employees are given a stake in the firm’s success and become loyal and motivated to work for a company they own a piece of.

 

Legal Framework and Documentation for ESOPs

Setting up an ESOP involves several legal agreements and approvals, including:
 

  • Stock option plans that spell out the total number of shares comprising the pool.

  • Grant agreements are provided to employees, specifying their individual options and vesting schedules.

  • Board approvals are required to establish the pool and issue stock options.

Compliance with SEC Regulations and State Laws

Since ESOPs are a form of equity compensation, they are subject to SEC regulations and applicable state law. 

 

Startups that issue stock options may need to register those options with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), particularly when issuing a large number of options. 

Working with experienced legal counsel ensures you comply with regulations and laws and avoid common stock option pitfalls.

 

Best Practices for Balancing Equity and Avoiding Legal Pitfalls

 

The following best practices will help you manage ESOPs effectively while also reducing legal complications.

Negotiating with Investors to Limit Dilution

During equity negotiations with investors, founders must watch out for too much equity being conceded to the option pool. 
 

Often, it is agreed upon (pre-money option pool), but ultimately, startups need to ensure a balance between keeping the dilution for founders at a reasonable level while also satisfying the investor.

Replenishing the Option Pool During Growth Phases

As the company grows and employs more people, it might be necessary to replenish the option pool. For later funding rounds, this can even mean expanding the option pool. 
 

This will change the cap table and, in turn, the distribution of equity. Regularly monitor the option pool and replenish it when growth necessitates it.

Balancing Equity Distribution Among Founders, Employees, and Investors

One of the most challenging parts of a founder’s job is allocating equity to other stakeholders so everyone feels like the pie is divided fairly. 
 

This is where a founder’s initial thoughts about the equity to allocate to employees is tested in real-time while still retaining enough equity to maintain control over the company. Regular check-ins with investors and legal counsel are helpful.


 

Stock Option Pool: Conclusion

 

Staff stock option pools help startups attract the best talent (and retain them), ensure everyone’s alignment with the mission, and incentivize employees to grow the company. 
 

However, to do this, you need to plan carefully for the impact of the dilution, structure sensible vesting schedules, and follow several best practices around equity. 
 

Working with a startup lawyer who understands the laws and intricacies surrounding equity and stock options ensures your plan is legally sound. This also helps structure it to benefit both the company and its employees.
 

Post a job on UpCounsel today to find a startup lawyer in your state.


UpCounsel accepts only the top 5% of startup lawyers on its site. Its lawyers come from schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law. They average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.