Key Takeaways

  • An LLC protects personal assets from business liabilities, making it a strong choice for many small business owners.
  • LLCs offer tax flexibility, with options to be taxed as a sole proprietorship, partnership, S corporation, or C corporation.
  • They require fewer formalities than corporations, but may involve annual reporting, filing fees, and franchise taxes depending on the state.
  • LLCs provide credibility with customers and investors, while also allowing flexible management structures and profit-sharing arrangements.
  • However, disadvantages can include limited access to venture capital, potential self-employment tax burdens, and state-specific compliance costs.

The question of why LLC is good has multiple answers. An LLC is the least complex structure, is easily converted from another type of business structure, and has tax benefits.

The "LLC" part of a business's name stands for limited liability company. An LLC is owned by its members, which can be a single individual or multiple parties. It is formed by filing articles of organization in the state where the business is located. An LLC is easier to operate since it requires less work than a corporation. This is because shareholder meetings and corporate minutes are not required.

Benefits of Forming a Limited Liability Company

Customizing Small Businesses

An LLC is an adaptable structure for small businesses due to its flexibility. Whether it is just you or 100 investors running the business, you can create your own operating agreement with rules that suit your business needs.

Protecting Real Estate Assets

An LLC offers dual liability protection against lawsuits. This means if you were involved in rear-ending a vehicle, for example, a lawsuit will not include your investment properties as long as they are part of an LLC.

Raising Seed Capital

As the business entity of choice, with an LLC it is easier to raise seed funding through angel capital investors. Venture capitalists generally invest in larger corporations instead of smaller limited liability companies.

Estate Planning

LLCs have advantages in terms of when you do your estate planning due to asset protection. They also offer protection from creditors and protection from the cost of probate lawyers and court fees.

Short-Term Projects

An LLC is an ideal business structure for short-term projects. With an LLC, a specified dissolution date and the number of years the LLC is to remain in existence is stated within the articles of incorporation.

Minimizing Tax Burdens

Limited liability companies ease the burden of taxation due to the default partnership tax process. This means the losses that the business incurs are passed on to the members, who in turn use the losses as deductions for other income on their personal tax returns.

Flexibility

LLCs are not hindered by strict formalities. With an LLC, you have options such as:

  • Members can utilize informal decision-making processes instead of dealing with a board of directors.
  • Members can personally manage the operations of the business or hire outside help.
  • Access to broader freedom when it comes to dividing profits and setting up member's voting rights.

Customer Credibility

Visual recognition is another advantage of running an LLC. The designation can make your business appear to be more established.

Investor Participation

Because an LLC keeps business and personal assets separate, investors are more likely to invest. When they aren't kept separate, investors are less likely to provide capital.

Continuous Business

When a member of an LLC retires or dies, there is no legally binding process that closes the business. The LLC will continue to operate.

Potential Drawbacks of an LLC

While the benefits of forming an LLC are considerable, it’s also important to evaluate the potential downsides before deciding if an LLC is a good idea. Some common disadvantages include:

  • Self-Employment Taxes: LLC owners are generally required to pay self-employment taxes on their share of business income, which can be higher than corporate tax obligations.
  • State Filing Requirements and Fees: Many states impose annual reporting obligations, franchise taxes, or renewal fees that can increase operating costs.
  • Limited Access to Venture Capital: Unlike corporations, which can issue stock, LLCs often find it more challenging to attract large-scale venture capital investment.
  • Ownership Transfer Restrictions: In some states, transferring ownership interests requires approval from other members, which can complicate succession planning.
  • Variation by State: Rules and benefits of LLCs differ by state, so an LLC’s advantages may not be consistent nationwide

Limited Liability Companies and Taxes

The IRS does not have a specific tax category for a limited liability company. An LLC with one owner (member) is taxed as a sole proprietorship. LLCs with more than one are taxed as partnerships.

As noted, the LLC does not pay taxes directly. The net income is taxed on the owner(s) personal tax return. This is referred to as "pass-through taxation." Filing as a sole proprietorship uses Schedule C. Partnerships use Form 1065 and Schedule K-1.

  • Tax rates: The tax rate used for a limited liability company is based on the total income of the owner. In some instances where the level of net income is higher, the LLC may have a lower rate than a corporation.
  • Double taxation: An advantage of an LLC over a corporation is that corporate owners are susceptible to double taxation whereas LLC owners are not.
  • Franchise taxes: Some states require an LLC to pay franchise taxes.
  • All profits are taxable: Members of an LLC must pay taxes on their distributive share of the company's profits even if there has been no distribution of those profits.
  • Property tax exemption: Some states do not exempt LLCs from property tax.
  • Self-employment taxes: Owners of a limited liability company must pay self-employment taxes (Social Security/Medicare).

Flexibility in Tax Elections

One of the most significant advantages that makes people ask “is an LLC a good idea” is the tax flexibility available. By default, LLCs use pass-through taxation, but members can elect alternative tax classifications:

  • S Corporation Election: Many LLCs elect to be taxed as S corporations, which can reduce self-employment tax obligations for members actively working in the business.
  • C Corporation Election: For businesses planning to reinvest profits or pursue significant growth, an LLC can choose to be taxed as a C corporation, allowing access to lower corporate tax rates.
  • Tailored to Business Needs: This ability to choose the most tax-advantageous option allows LLCs to adapt as the business grows

When an LLC May Not Be the Best Fit

Despite their popularity, an LLC may not always be the right business structure. For example:

  • Rapid Growth Startups: High-growth businesses seeking venture capital often choose corporations because they can issue stock to investors.
  • Businesses Operating in Multiple States: Expanding an LLC into multiple jurisdictions can increase compliance complexity and cost.
  • Owners Seeking Simplicity Without Fees: In some states, the annual costs of maintaining an LLC may outweigh the benefits compared to a sole proprietorship or partnership

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Is an LLC a good idea for small businesses?

Yes, an LLC is often ideal for small businesses because it combines liability protection with flexible management and tax options.

2. What are the biggest disadvantages of an LLC?

Common drawbacks include self-employment taxes, limited access to venture capital, and annual fees or reporting requirements depending on your state.

3. Can an LLC save me money on taxes?

It can. LLCs offer pass-through taxation, but members may also elect S corporation status to potentially reduce self-employment tax burdens.

4. Why would a startup choose a corporation instead of an LLC?

Startups that plan to seek venture capital typically choose corporations because they can issue stock, which LLCs cannot.

5. Do LLC benefits vary by state?

Yes, state laws differ on fees, taxes, and compliance rules. It’s important to check your state’s requirements before forming an LLC.

If you need help understanding the advantages of an LLC, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.