Key Takeaways

  • The value of patent system lies in balancing innovation incentives with public knowledge sharing.
  • Patents act as economic assets, fostering entrepreneurship, investment, and technological progress.
  • Recent changes, such as the America Invents Act (AIA), modernized U.S. patent procedures and aligned global standards.
  • A strong patent framework benefits small inventors, startups, and corporations by protecting intellectual property rights.
  • The economic worth of patents extends beyond exclusivity — patents can generate licensing income, secure financing, and attract investors.

Valuing a Patent

There is almost no limit to the value of patents. Businesses rely on innovation to keep pace with their competitors, and one of the best ways to gain an advantage is protecting innovations by using patents. With a patent, a business can secure their inventions from their competitors for a set length of time. Because a patent counts as an asset, a company's investors need to know the exact value of a patent.

Every business needs to include the value of their patents when bookkeeping. Accounting for the value of patents of particular importance during acquisitions, mergers, the dissolution of a business, and during the course of bankruptcy or infringement litigation. The best way to learn the value of a patent is to determine the value of the invention that the patent covers. Obtaining a patent for an invention without value simply isn't practical. Due to their intangibility, finding the value of patents can be difficult. The economic-analysis method is the most common solution for valuing a patent.

In addition to protecting inventions, patents can be used to develop a company's brand and are also a useful tool for creating new markets. With the right patents, a company can raise financing for development, as well as creating streams of revenue by licensing their patents. If used correctly, a patent can help a business succeed in the short and long term.

The Broader Economic Value of the Patent System

The value of patent system extends far beyond the monetary worth of a single patent. It underpins a nation’s innovation ecosystem, ensuring inventors and businesses can confidently invest in research and development. By granting exclusive rights, patents allow creators to recover development costs and profit from their ingenuity, while also encouraging public disclosure of new ideas that stimulate future innovation.

Patents are often seen as “property rights for the weak” — a concept emphasized by The Heritage Foundation — because they empower small inventors and startups to compete with established corporations through secure ownership of their ideas. In this sense, the value of the patent system lies in its ability to foster competition and entrepreneurship across industries.

Furthermore, patents act as transferable economic assets, serving as collateral for loans or as tradable property in secondary markets. Historically, even in the 19th century, inventors leveraged patents to attract investors or fund infringement lawsuits, laying the foundation for modern innovation financing.

What is a Patent?

When an inventor is granted a patent, they own the exclusive right to their invention for a set period. The protection provided by a patent prevents other people or businesses from using an invention unless granted the right by the patent holder. Being granted a patent requires following very strict regulations.

For an invention to be patentable, it cannot fall into these three categories:

  • Abstract ideas.
  • Laws of nature.
  • Natural phenomena.

An invention must also fit into one of the following categories:

  • Human manufactured products.
  • Machines.
  • Processing methods.

Another rule for patenting inventions is that the invention must have been previously unknown. This means that the invention you are attempting to patent cannot have been previously disclosed to the public or has been included in a USPTO patent application. You also cannot patent an invention that was created by making obvious modifications to an existing invention.

When you apply for your patent, you must fully describe your invention in a manner that would allow another person to create your invention using only basic skills. There are several types of intellectual property rights, including patents. These rights are granted to brand-new inventions and give the inventor sole rights to their product for a twenty-year period. Intellectual property rights are one of the most powerful commercial tools in the world, particularly for businesses seeking to transition their products from research & development to the marketplace.

Appraising the value of patents can be important for accounting purposes, taxes, lawsuits, and transactions. You may also need to account for the value of patents during bankruptcy proceedings or during a divorce. Patents may also need to be appraised for the purpose of GAAP financial reporting. This is very common for high-tech industries undergoing an audit or valuation.

The Purpose and Evolution of the Patent System

The value of patent system stems from a constitutional foundation designed to “promote the progress of science and useful arts.” Patents provide a social contract—exclusive rights granted in exchange for disclosure. This trade-off ensures that inventors benefit from their work while society gains access to technological advancements.

However, debate exists over whether the system promotes or restricts innovation. Publications like The Economist argue that excessive patent monopolies can stifle progress, while rebuttals in Forbes highlight data showing a positive correlation between strong patent laws, R&D investment, and economic growth. Studies by the OECD also confirm that nations with robust patent systems attract more high-tech investment and knowledge transfer.

Ultimately, the patent system’s value lies in maintaining this delicate balance: rewarding innovation without impeding future discovery.

Types of Patent

If you invent or discover a new species of plant, you may be able to protect your invention using a plant patent. When a plant patent is granted, it will last for twenty years and will prevent others from using or selling your plant.

Utility patents cover a variety of inventions, including software, a new type of process, or an improvement of an existing invention. Upon filing, utility patents will be good for twenty years.

You can use a design patent to protect the appearance of an invention. These types of patent are especially useful when you've altered the style of an invention but not its functionality. Unlike other types of patents, design patents only last for fourteen years.

Modern Patent Law Developments and Trends

Recent shifts in U.S. patent law have further influenced how the value of patent system is perceived. The America Invents Act (AIA) of 2011 transitioned the U.S. from a “first-to-invent” to a “first-to-file” model, aligning it with international standards and reinforcing the need for prompt filings.

The AIA also introduced Post-Grant Review (PGR) and Inter Partes Review (IPR), mechanisms allowing third parties to challenge questionable patents, improving quality and fairness in the system. These changes reflect a trend toward greater accountability and transparency, ensuring the patent framework continues to support innovation rather than obstruct it.

In today’s global marketplace, effective patent strategies help businesses manage risks, protect investments, and leverage intellectual property for long-term growth.

Economic Analysis Approach

When using the Cost Approach, the value of your patent will be equal to the cost of replacing your patent. Whatever amount of money you would need to spend to replace your invention is the current value of your patent. The Income Approach determines the value of your patent by gauging how much revenue you could earn from your patent in the future.

Measuring the Societal Impact of Patents

While economic analysis focuses on the cost and income potential of patents, the value of patent system can also be measured by its contribution to broader social and economic development. Historical data and studies confirm a strong correlation between secure intellectual property rights and societal prosperity. As President Abraham Lincoln once observed, the U.S. patent system “added the fuel of interest to the fire of genius,” driving innovation through incentive and protection.

Today, companies like IBM, Microsoft, and Qualcomm illustrate the power of patents as strategic tools for growth. Through licensing and cross-industry collaboration, these firms demonstrate how the patent system facilitates progress rather than impedes it.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. What is the main purpose of the patent system?
    The patent system incentivizes innovation by granting inventors exclusive rights to their creations while requiring public disclosure to encourage further technological progress.
  2. How does the patent system benefit the economy?
    It promotes investment in research and development, encourages entrepreneurship, and enables inventors to leverage patents as valuable business assets.
  3. What are the main criticisms of the patent system?
    Some argue that excessive patent protection can hinder competition or slow innovation. However, evidence suggests well-structured patent laws enhance overall economic growth.
  4. How have recent changes in U.S. patent law impacted inventors?
    Reforms under the America Invents Act modernized the process, emphasizing speed and transparency while improving patent quality and dispute resolution.
  5. How can a business determine the value of its patents?
    Companies can use cost, market, or income-based valuation methods, often with expert legal and financial guidance to assess both direct revenue potential and strategic worth.

If you need help with determining the value of patents, you can post your legal needs on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.