Key Takeaways

  • A release clause is a contractual provision allowing parties to be released from certain obligations once specific conditions are met.
  • A meet-or-release clause gives one party the right to exit an agreement if the other cannot match a better offer.
  • Release clauses must satisfy basic contract law principles, including capacity, consent, legality, offer, acceptance, and consideration.
  • They are widely used in commercial supply contracts, real estate transactions, personal injury waivers, construction agreements, and business partnerships.
  • Understanding the legal and strategic implications of release clauses is crucial, as they limit enforcement rights and can significantly impact negotiation leverage.

A meet-or-release clause is one type of release clause within a contract. It allows contract signers to be released from the binding terms of a contract if certain circumstances occur.

Any release clause in a contract serves as an agreement between the parties, requiring one of them to forfeit their legal right to enforce the contract. The party may not sue the other party for failing to fulfill the terms of a contract. Anyone who signs such a contract needs to understand this going in.

Rules for Release Clauses

Since a release clause is considered a contract, release clauses are governed by contract law. Release clauses are legally binding, but only if the following requirements are met:

  • Both parties must be legally capable of forming a contract. They must be of legal age and sound mind.
  • Both parties must freely consent to the release clause without coercion.
  • The release clause cannot apply to any illegal action or circumstance.
  • The contract includes an offer and acceptance.
  • The release clause involves the exchange of consideration — payment or exchange of other items or services of value.

A release may either be part of a contract or a separate document. Either way, legal remedies will be severely limited. Release clauses are just as binding as the rest of the contract, and you should consider speaking with an attorney before signing a contract that includes one.

An attorney also should be consulted when release clauses are drafted. Such expert advice helps to resolve disagreements that may arise in the future and prevents them from happening in the first place.

Common Purposes and Legal Implications of Release Clauses

Release clauses serve several strategic purposes across various legal and business contexts. Fundamentally, they offer a mechanism for one or both parties to exit a contract without breaching it, provided predefined conditions are met. This can mitigate risk, promote flexibility, and encourage cooperation during negotiations.

Some key legal implications and uses include:

  • Risk Allocation: Release clauses shift potential liabilities or risks from one party to another. For example, in a service contract, a provider might include a release clause to avoid lawsuits arising from performance delays beyond their control.
  • Negotiation Leverage: They give parties a fallback option during negotiations, often leading to more favorable contract terms.
  • Settlement Facilitation: In litigation or disputes, release clauses are used to finalize settlements and prevent future claims.
  • Limiting Remedies: Once a release clause is invoked, the releasing party typically cannot pursue legal remedies related to the released matter. This finality underscores the importance of careful drafting and understanding before signing.

Suppliers' Release Clause

With a meet-or-release clause, a supplier and customer agree that if the customer finds a better price offered by the supplier's competitor, the supplier must offer the same price or a lower one. If the supplier does not “price match,” the customer is released from the contract they signed to buy products from the supplier and may go elsewhere.

Meet-or-release clauses can run into problems with competition laws because they prevent competing suppliers from having the opportunity to earn customers' business. Suppliers can use these clauses as a way to monitor the prices offered by their competitors, resulting in unfair competition.

Practical Considerations and Potential Risks

While meet-or-release clauses can offer flexibility and competitive pricing, they also come with potential legal and commercial risks that should be carefully evaluated:

  • Antitrust Concerns: In some industries, meet-or-release clauses may raise antitrust or competition law issues. They can deter competitors from entering the market or reduce price competition if used aggressively.
  • Negotiation Dynamics: Suppliers may find themselves pressured into offering unprofitable terms to retain business, undermining long-term profitability.
  • Contractual Ambiguity: Poorly drafted release clauses can lead to disputes about what constitutes a “better offer” or what timeframe applies. Clear definitions and conditions are critical to avoid litigation.
  • Strategic Usage: Businesses should consider including mechanisms like written verification of third-party offers, notice periods, or good-faith negotiation requirements to ensure the clause operates fairly and predictably.

Other Types of Release Clauses

There are many different types of release clauses in use, and they are adapted for a range of purposes. Here are just a few examples of situations in which it may be useful to draft a release clause as a separate agreement or to include it in a contract:

  • Personal Injury: When an activity involves a high risk of injury or even death, a release clause will be employed. Examples include extreme sports like hang gliding, parasailing, skydiving, rock climbing, or skiing. Instructors, property owners, or equipment rentals may ask customers to sign a release so they are not legally liable for any injuries that may occur while the customer participates in the activity.
  • Construction Projects: Contractors involved in construction use many different kinds of release clauses to protect themselves from legal liability if a dispute should occur between parties. Such release clauses may be between the contractor and their client, the contractor and their suppliers, or even with employees of the contractor.
  • Business Contracts: Business partners often sign contracts that involve release clauses. Disputes in the course of conducting business are common, and release clauses may be used to encourage parties to work out alternative ways to solve problems, such as mediation or negotiation.
  • Real Estate Development: A release clause allows for the release of collateral when the borrower pays off at least part of a loan. Such clauses are widely used in mortgages for subdivision developers. The lender has to release its lien on the property when a potential purchaser of one of the subdivision homes applies for their own mortgage.
  • Real Estate Sales: Another type of real estate release clause exists between a buyer and seller. It's common for a buyer to accept an offer but still allow the seller to seek other offers for a certain time period. In this case, the release applies to the seller, who is released from their exclusive obligation to the buyer while they try to find better offers. Typically the time limit is 72 hours.

Drafting Tips and Best Practices

When drafting or reviewing a release clause, attention to detail is crucial. A poorly worded clause can lead to unintended consequences, including loss of legal rights or exposure to unforeseen liabilities. Here are best practices to follow:

  • Define Trigger Conditions Clearly: Specify exactly what events or actions will trigger the release, such as payment milestones, regulatory approvals, or alternative offers.
  • Limit the Scope: Ensure the release applies only to certain obligations or claims, not to unrelated matters.
  • Use Mutual Releases Carefully: Mutual release clauses, where both parties waive rights, should be balanced and clearly understood by both sides.
  • Include Governing Law and Dispute Resolution: State which jurisdiction’s laws apply and how disputes regarding the release clause will be resolved.
  • Document Consideration: Ensure there is adequate consideration supporting the release, such as payment, services, or mutual concessions, to maintain enforceability.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. What is a release clause in a contract?
    A release clause allows one or both parties to be released from certain contractual obligations once specific conditions are met, often limiting their ability to pursue legal action.
  2. How does a meet-or-release clause work?
    It lets a party terminate a contract if the other cannot match a competitor’s offer. If the match is made, the contract continues under the new terms.
  3. Are release clauses legally binding?
    Yes, provided they meet contract law requirements such as capacity, consent, legality, offer, acceptance, and consideration.
  4. Can a release clause be challenged in court?
    It can be challenged if it is ambiguous, unconscionable, or violates public policy, but well-drafted clauses are usually enforceable.
  5. Where are release clauses most commonly used?
    They are common in real estate, supplier agreements, personal injury waivers, construction contracts, and business partnership deals.

If you need more information or help with what is a release clause, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.