Key Takeaways

  • An exclusive agency listing allows a seller to retain the right to sell their property independently without paying a commission if they find the buyer themselves.
  • An exclusive right-to-sell agreement guarantees the listing agent a commission regardless of who finds the buyer.
  • Exclusive agency listings can reduce commission costs but may limit an agent’s motivation to market the property aggressively.
  • Open listings offer maximum flexibility but minimal agent commitment, while probate listings involve property sold through an estate.
  • Understanding the legal and financial implications of each listing type is crucial before signing an agreement.

Exclusive right vs. exclusive agency refers to two different types of listing agreements between real estate owners and the agent, listing broker, or another representative who is helping to sell the real estate. The main difference is the conditions under which the seller is required to pay a commission to the representative when the property sells.

The most widely used types of listing agreements that are used by sellers of real estate are:

  • Exclusive Right to Sell
  • Exclusive Agency
  • Open Listing
  • Probate Listing

Exclusive Right to Sell

When a real estate seller signs an exclusive right-to-sell agreement, the broker, agent, or another representative of the seller is entitled to receive a commission from the sale even if that person does not actually procure the buyer. If the buyer comes from the efforts of the seller or someone else instead of the agent, the seller must still pay the commission.

In this type of contract, the seller is allowed to name certain people or entities as exemptions, so that if that person or entity purchases the property, the listing agent is not entitled to a commission. This is the most common arrangement with a full-service real estate agency.

Exclusive Agency

Exclusive agency listing agreements are most often used with flat-fee listing brokers who provide limited service to their clients. In this type of agreement, the listing broker serves as the real estate seller's agent or representative. However, they are only paid a commission if the property sells through their efforts. If the seller is acquired in another way, such as by the marketing efforts of the seller, the agent is not due a commission.

Pros and Cons of an Exclusive Agency Listing

An exclusive agency listing strikes a balance between professional representation and seller autonomy. Because the seller retains the right to sell the property on their own, this agreement type is often attractive to owners who are confident in their ability to market the property themselves while still wanting the exposure that comes with a broker’s services.

Pros of an Exclusive Agency Listing:

  • Potential cost savings: If the seller finds a buyer independently, they avoid paying the commission.
  • Flexibility: Sellers can pursue their own leads without breaching the agreement.
  • Market exposure: The property is still marketed through the multiple listing service (MLS) and professional networks.

Cons of an Exclusive Agency Listing:

  • Less agent motivation: Because commission is not guaranteed, agents might devote less time and resources to marketing the property.
  • Lower priority: Agents may prioritize exclusive right-to-sell listings where they are certain to earn a commission.
  • More work for the seller: Sellers may need to engage in significant marketing and negotiation efforts themselves.

Open Listing

Another type of listing agreement is “open listing.” In an open-listing agreement, more than one agent may be working for the seller. Only the agent or broker who brings the buyer to the seller, and helps to complete the sale, gets the commission.

Probate Listing

If the owner of the real estate property has died, the estate may be represented by an agent or broker with a probate listing. These are typically full-service agents because they are most likely to negotiate the best price for the property with no effort required by the heirs or other involved parties.

Differences Between the Listing Agreements

If you are selling real estate, you must pay attention to the language of the written agreement you are signing with an agent. Only a few words, which may be buried in the agreement, can make a vital difference in how the agreement works.

Other than the small bit of text that defines the type of agreement, and how the agent is entitled to compensation, all listing agreements are similar. If the agreement is an Exclusive Right to Sell, it states that the seller will pay the agent a certain amount of money if that agent is able to produce a buyer for the real estate. However, in an Exclusive Agency listing, the agreement states that the seller must pay the agent a certain amount of money regardless of the source of the buyer.

The Exclusive Right-to-Sell agreement means that it doesn't matter who found the buyer for the real state; even if it was another agent, or if the seller managed to find a buyer for the property themselves, the broker must still be paid. Even if, for example, a friend or family member of the seller decides to buy the property — or the seller mentioned on social media that the house was for sale — the agent must be paid, even if they had nothing to do with the ultimate buyer of the property.

In an Exclusive agency agreement, it's possible that the agency that lists and markets the property might not receive any commission when the property is sold. If the seller manages to find the buyer themselves, as long as the agent was not involved in the sale, they are not required to be paid a commission. Use caution when signing a listing agreement, especially when there is a possibility that you may find a buyer yourself or would like to use the services of more than one agent or representative.

How to Choose the Right Listing Agreement

The decision between an exclusive right-to-sell and an exclusive agency listing depends largely on the seller’s priorities, resources, and comfort level with the selling process.

  • Choose an exclusive right-to-sell if you want a hands-off process with maximum agent involvement, marketing, and negotiation. This is the most common type of listing for sellers who value convenience and expert support.
  • Choose an exclusive agency listing if you prefer to retain control over the sale and are confident in your ability to find a buyer, but still want MLS exposure and professional assistance if your own efforts don’t succeed.
  • Consider an open listing if you want complete freedom and flexibility, though this often results in less agent commitment and reduced marketing efforts.

For high-value properties, complex sales, or probate sales, sellers often prefer exclusive right-to-sell agreements due to the full-service approach. On the other hand, sellers familiar with real estate transactions or those with an existing buyer network might benefit from the cost savings and flexibility of an exclusive agency arrangement.

Legal Considerations and Best Practices

Before signing any listing agreement, carefully review the terms, duration, commission structure, and termination clauses. Small language differences — such as how “procuring cause” is defined or how exceptions are handled — can significantly impact commission obligations.

Best practices include:

  • Defining exceptions: Specify any potential buyers you’ve already contacted to avoid paying commission if they complete the purchase.
  • Clarifying marketing responsibilities: Outline what marketing services the agent will provide under the agreement.
  • Understanding dual agency: Some states allow an agent to represent both buyer and seller. Understand how commissions and representation duties are affected if this occurs.
  • Setting a termination clause: Ensure there’s a clear process for ending the agreement early if expectations are not met.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. What is an exclusive agency listing?
    An exclusive agency listing allows a broker to represent the property, but the seller can still sell it independently without paying a commission.
  2. Why do agents prefer exclusive right-to-sell agreements?
    Because their commission is guaranteed regardless of who finds the buyer, agents are often more motivated to invest time and resources into marketing.
  3. Can I list my property with multiple agents under an exclusive agency listing?
    No. Only one broker is authorized to market the property under an exclusive agency agreement, though you can still sell it yourself.
  4. How long does an exclusive agency listing last?
    The duration is negotiable, typically ranging from 3 to 6 months. Review the agreement carefully before signing.
  5. Are there legal risks with exclusive agency listings?
    Yes. Misunderstanding the terms, especially around commission entitlement and procuring cause, can lead to disputes. Always review the contract thoroughly or consult a real estate attorney before signing.

If you need more information or help with exclusive agency listing, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.