Key Takeaways

  • A domestic for-profit LLC is a limited liability company formed and operating in the same state, while a domestic profit corporation is a corporation registered within its state of formation.
  • Both LLCs and corporations provide limited liability protection but differ in ownership, management, taxation, and compliance requirements.
  • Corporations are more rigid in structure, requiring bylaws, annual meetings, and shareholder oversight, whereas LLCs are more flexible with member or manager management.
  • Domestic profit corporations must file articles of incorporation, which outline the company’s purpose, structure, and governance. LLCs instead file articles of organization and often adopt an operating agreement.
  • Taxation differs: LLCs are typically pass-through entities, while corporations (especially C corporations) face double taxation unless electing S corporation status.
  • Choosing between a domestic profit corporation and an LLC depends on goals like fundraising, compliance tolerance, and desired tax treatment.

A domestic for-profit LLC is a limited liability company that does business in the state where it was formed.

An Introduction to LLCs vs. For-Profit Corporations

In general, LLCs are not considered corporations. However, they may elect to be treated like corporations for tax purposes. Domestic corporations are able to conduct business in states outside of where they filed their formation documents, in which they're known as foreign corporations.

Except for sole proprietorships, business organizations must register as a specific business type in the state they're created. States recognize the following business types:

  • Corporations
  • Partnerships
  • Limited liability companies
  • Variations on these forms

LLCs and corporations share similarities, like providing limited liability protection to their owners.

Both business types are treated as separate legal entities from their owners. Each requires filing formation documents with the Secretary of State (or equivalent office) and paying necessary fees. However, corporations have more formalities compared to LLCs.

Formation Requirements for Domestic Profit Corporations

When forming a domestic profit corporation, business owners must file articles of incorporation with their state’s Secretary of State (or equivalent agency). These documents typically include:

  • The corporation’s name and principal office address
  • Its stated purpose (which can be general or specific depending on the state)
  • The number and type of shares authorized
  • Names and addresses of incorporators and initial directors

By contrast, an LLC is formed by filing articles of organization, which are generally less detailed. LLCs often supplement these filings with an operating agreement, while corporations rely on bylaws to set rules for governance.

LLCs vs For Profit Corporations: Key Differences

There's no such entity as a "limited liability corporation." LLC stands for “limited liability company.” Individuals don't incorporate a business as an LLC; they only incorporate corporations.

LLC owners are called members. LLC members may be corporations, other LLCs, individuals, or foreign entities. They can have an unlimited number of members.

Corporation owners are referred to as company shareholders. There are restrictions on corporate ownership, depending on the type of corporation. C corporations allow non-resident aliens, LLCs, and other corporations to act as shareholders. Like LLCs, C corps can have unlimited shareholders.

Ownership and Capitalization

A domestic profit corporation issues stock to shareholders, which can make raising capital easier through equity financing. Investors often prefer the predictability of corporate shares and the well-established rules governing corporations.

LLCs, however, do not issue stock. Ownership is expressed through membership interests, and raising capital may require amending the operating agreement or negotiating directly with new members. While this offers flexibility, it can be less attractive to institutional investors.

Management Type and Structure

LLCs may be managed by members or managers. In a member-managed company, members play an active role in day-to-day business affairs. In a manager-managed LLC, managers are employed to take care of daily business affairs.

Corporations have a detailed structure that consists of various corporate employees, officers, and board members. Corporations follow corporate bylaws that outline the company's governing rules and regulations. LLCs follow rules and regulations outlined in their operating agreement.

Corporations are required to file annual reports with the state and do the following:

  • Hold yearly board meetings
  • Hold stockholder meetings
  • Record corporate minutes

LLCs don't have to follow all of these formalities.

Compliance Obligations for Domestic Profit Corporations

Domestic profit corporations must observe formalities such as:

  • Holding annual shareholder and board meetings
  • Keeping detailed corporate minutes and records
  • Filing annual or biennial reports with the state
  • Maintaining a registered agent within the state

Failure to comply can risk piercing the corporate veil, which could expose shareholders to personal liability. LLCs, by comparison, enjoy fewer mandated formalities, making them easier to maintain for small businesses.

Taxation Differences

For tax purposes, businesses may fall into one of two camps.

  • Pass-through entities: In a pass-through business, company profits and losses pass through the business to the owners. Business income is treated like the owners' income, so the owners pay taxes on this income on their personal tax returns. LLCs, like partnerships and S corporations, are pass-through businesses.
  • Separate business entities: C corporations are treated as legally separate businesses entities. The corporation's profits and losses are taxable to the business, not to company shareholders. However, corporations are subject to double taxation: the business pays taxes on company profits, and the shareholders pay taxes on the dividends they receive from the corporation.

LLCs and corporations are taxed differently, and their owners have different tax consequences.

Corporations, since they're treated as separate entities, are taxed at a corporate rate. LLCs are taxed according to their owners' adjusted gross income. Sometimes, LLCs elect to be taxed as corporations if they feel it's beneficial to the company.

Corporation owners don't receive a salary; instead, they're paid in dividends. They pay taxes based on their dividend income.

LLC members are taxed like partnership partners. They receive a distributive share of company profits every year. They then pay taxes on their share of the profits on their individual tax returns.

LLC members are responsible for paying self-employment taxes on the income they receive from the business. Corporate owners who also work in the business are treated as employees. They pay FICA taxes and are taxed on their employment income.

You may choose your business structure based on a number of factors, including how you are taxed and paid.

Unlike nonprofit companies, which are designed to serve the public, for-profit companies are created to make a profit for their owners. The term “domestic” may apply to the specific jurisdiction where a company starts, or it may apply to the country. Knowing the pros and cons that come with creating an LLC may help you make the right decision for the business structure you choose to operate.

Choosing Between an LLC and a Domestic Profit Corporation

When deciding between an LLC and a domestic profit corporation, consider:

  • Growth plans: Corporations are often better for businesses planning to attract venture capital or go public.
  • Administrative burden: LLCs offer flexibility and fewer record-keeping requirements.
  • Tax preferences: LLCs provide pass-through taxation by default, but corporations may benefit from certain deductions and retained earnings strategies.
  • Liability protection: Both structures shield owners from personal liability, but courts may scrutinize corporations more strictly regarding compliance.

Understanding these differences helps entrepreneurs align their choice of entity with long-term business strategy.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. What is a domestic profit corporation?
    A domestic profit corporation is a corporation formed and registered in its home state for the purpose of generating profits for shareholders.
  2. How is a domestic profit corporation different from a domestic for-profit LLC?
    A domestic profit corporation issues stock, requires bylaws, and follows stricter compliance rules, while an LLC offers flexible management and pass-through taxation.
  3. What documents are required to start a domestic profit corporation?
    You must file articles of incorporation with the state, outlining the company’s name, purpose, share structure, and initial directors.
  4. Can a domestic profit corporation operate in other states?
    Yes, but it must register as a foreign corporation in any state where it conducts business outside its state of incorporation.
  5. Which is better for small businesses: an LLC or a domestic profit corporation?
    For small businesses prioritizing flexibility and simple taxation, an LLC is often preferable. For companies planning to raise capital through investors, a corporation may be better.

If you need help with a domestic for-profit LLC, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.