Key Takeaways

  • A handshake or verbal contract can hold up in court if it meets the legal requirements of a valid contract — offer, acceptance, consideration, and mutual intent.
  • Proving the terms of a verbal agreement is often the biggest challenge, making documentation, witnesses, or follow-up communications valuable evidence.
  • Certain types of agreements — such as those involving real estate, contracts lasting over a year, or large financial commitments — may require written documentation under the Statute of Frauds.
  • Courts evaluate the parties’ behavior, communications, and evidence to determine if a handshake agreement was intended as legally binding.
  • While enforceable, verbal agreements leave room for disputes. Having a written contract is almost always the safest way to protect your rights.

If you're wondering, "does a verbal contract hold up in court?" the answer is usually yes. However, it's usually better to put an agreement in writing to avoid any questions or problems down the road.

What Kind of Weight Do Verbal Contracts Carry?

In today's world of electronic communications, entering into a legally binding contract can be as simple as having a telephone conversation. You may not believe it, but a good old-fashioned handshake was all it used to take for two people to have confidence in the fact that neither party had a weapon on their person. Over time, the concept of the handshake began to evolve into a symbol that indicated a verbal agreement had been reached.

There has been a lot of speculation over the years over whether or not a verbal agreement is legally binding but, the fact is, they are. While it's normally preferable to put a contractual agreement in a written document that outlines the agreement's terms, verbal agreements can be upheld under established laws.

It's always best to get advice from an attorney with a good understanding of contracts when you need help with matters pertaining to the laws associated with contracts. It is worth noting that a lot of powerful people have participated in deals that were sealed by a simple handshake, including iconic figures like:

  • Bill Clinton
  • Bill Gates
  • Newt Gingrich
  • Steve Jobs

It's highly likely, however, that these deals were later followed up with extensive contracts that detailed important terms and points of the agreement in question. If you're the kind of person that prefers informal deals that only require a handshake to seal, you should at least consider having people present that can bear witness to the agreement being made. Having witnesses present is a solid way to guarantee your handshake agreement is more legally binding than it would be without anybody to confirm it was actually made.

When a Handshake Becomes a Binding Agreement

In many legal situations, the question “does a handshake hold up in court?” depends less on the physical gesture and more on the substance behind it. Courts are primarily concerned with whether the essential elements of a contract are present — not whether it was written down. These elements include:

  • Offer and acceptance: One party must clearly offer something, and the other must accept it.
  • Consideration: Each party must exchange something of value (money, services, goods, etc.).
  • Mutual intent: Both sides must intend for the agreement to be legally binding.
  • Capacity and legality: The parties must have the legal capacity to enter into a contract, and the agreement must not involve illegal activity.

If these conditions are met, a handshake can signify a legally enforceable contract — even without a single word written down. Courts often look beyond the gesture itself and focus on the parties’ conduct and communications to assess intent. For example, email exchanges, text messages, or invoices sent after a handshake deal can serve as powerful evidence that an agreement was reached.

What Is a Verbal Contract?

A contract can be either verbal or written. However, verbal contracts are agreements that have been made between two parties or more on a completely spoken basis, with no written communication taking place.

Say, for example, a contractor comes to your house and offers to remodel your bathroom for $10,000. If you both agree to these terms, you're entering into a verbal contract. If you later refuse to pay the agreed-upon price, the contractor has the right to take you to court and would likely win the case. Likewise, if the contractor does not complete the job according to your agreement, you can ask the court to order him to do so.

Keep in mind, though, that it's one thing to enter into a verbal contract and something else entirely to prove the agreement or specific terms of the agreement actually exist. This makes verbal contracts potentially dangerous from a legal point of view due to the fact that there is no concrete evidence they have actually taken place. If either of the involved parties in a verbal agreement has a disagreement regarding the terms of said agreement, they can take their concerns to court.

Without sufficient evidence that the contract exists, however, or what the specifics of the agreement entail, the court may be unable to enforce a contract that has been breached. In the event that neither involved party can offer evidence of the existence of the contract terms in question, such as a witness, there really aren't any practical means with which to enforce the agreement. Also, it's not possible to create a legally enforceable verbal agreement if any of the activities involved in the agreement are illegal.

For instance, you can't enter into a verbal contract with someone to procure illegal substances in exchange for money and expect to be able to take them to court if they fail to uphold their end of the deal. Despite the fact that you both agreed to the specific terms of the agreement, no court will enforce this agreement because the activities required to execute it are in violation of either state or federal laws.

Evidence That Strengthens a Handshake Agreement

One of the biggest hurdles with verbal contracts is proving they exist — and proving what was agreed to. Because there’s no written record, courts rely heavily on surrounding evidence to determine whether a contract was formed and what its terms were. The following can help establish and support a handshake agreement:

  • Witness testimony: Third parties who observed the agreement or heard discussions can confirm its existence.
  • Written communications: Emails, text messages, or letters referencing the deal can corroborate the verbal agreement.
  • Behavior and performance: If one party has already acted based on the agreement — for example, delivering goods or making a payment — this behavior can strongly support the claim.
  • Partial fulfillment: Even partial completion of an agreement can indicate mutual understanding and intent.

Because the burden of proof lies with the party claiming the contract exists, assembling as much supporting evidence as possible can make or break your case.

When a Handshake Agreement Won’t Hold Up

While many handshake deals are enforceable, there are important exceptions. Under the Statute of Frauds, certain contracts must be in writing to be legally valid. This includes agreements that:

  • Involve the sale of real estate
  • Cannot be performed within one year
  • Involve the sale of goods worth more than $500
  • Guarantee someone else’s debt

If a verbal agreement falls into one of these categories, it will not hold up in court — regardless of how firm the handshake was. Moreover, if essential terms are vague or never clearly agreed upon, a court may determine that no enforceable contract exists.

Practical Tips to Avoid Legal Pitfalls

While a handshake may feel like a sign of trust, it’s rarely enough to protect your interests in a dispute. To minimize risk:

  • Follow up in writing: Even a short email summarizing the agreement can provide critical evidence.
  • Clarify key terms: Clearly define payment, timelines, responsibilities, and conditions.
  • Use witnesses: If possible, have a neutral third party present during the agreement.
  • Consult an attorney: Legal counsel can help ensure your agreement meets all legal requirements and is enforceable in court.

Taking these steps doesn’t diminish the trust between parties — it strengthens it by preventing future misunderstandings.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. Does a handshake hold up in court as a legal contract?
    Yes, if the agreement meets basic contract requirements — offer, acceptance, consideration, and mutual intent — a handshake can be legally binding.
  2. What makes it hard to enforce a verbal agreement?
    The main challenge is proving what was agreed upon. Without written evidence, the case may rely on witness testimony, emails, or the parties’ behavior.
  3. Are there contracts that must be in writing?
    Yes. Real estate transactions, contracts over a year, and goods over $500 generally require written agreements under the Statute of Frauds.
  4. Can partial performance make a handshake agreement enforceable?
    Absolutely. If one party begins performing their side of the deal, courts often view that as strong evidence of a binding contract.
  5. How can I protect myself if I rely on a handshake deal?
    Follow up in writing, clarify key terms, and gather supporting evidence. Better yet, put the agreement in writing from the start.

If you need help with does a verbal contract hold up in court, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.