LLC vs S Corp vs C Corp: Key Differences Explained

Key Takeaways

• LLCs, S corps, and C corps differ significantly in structure, taxation, ownership, compliance, and growth potential. Understanding these differences is crucial to selecting the best entity for your business goals.
• LLCs offer maximum flexibility, simple pass-through taxation, and minimal compliance but may face funding challenges.
• S corps combine corporate structure with pass-through taxation but have ownership restrictions and stricter IRS rules.
• C corps provide the best framework for raising capital, scaling, and going public but face double taxation and more regulatory obligations.
• The right choice depends on tax strategy, ownership goals, industry, funding needs, and exit plans. Consulting a legal or tax professional is recommended before deciding.

It can be difficult to navigate the C corp, S corp, LLC differences for new business owners. You will need to know about these different business structures and how they are alike and different from one another so that you choose the option that best fits your needs.

What Is an LLC?

An LLC is a structure that protects your personal assets from any liability from your business. It makes you separate your business and personal finances. LLCs are allowed in every state as well as the District of Columbia. It is a very flexible business structure with regard to management. You have some flexibility with reporting taxes.

LLCs are similar in nature to S corps regarding taxes. Both business income and expenses are dealt with on your own personal taxes. The owner of an LLC is seen as a disregarded entity. That means that you are to report the income and expenses of the LLC on a Schedule C Form 1040, which is also used for sole proprietorships.

An LLC may be an ideal business structure if:

·      You stand to suffer from losses for the first two years and you want to pass those through to your own taxes and the taxes of the other members.

·      You want some flexibility regarding accounting, as LLCs do not use the accrual method like C corps.

·      Your business owns real estate.

·      You want flexibility with management, as LLCs are more flexible than corporations.

·      You do not want to deal with organizational formalities, such as director or shareholder meetings. Corporations are required to hold these meetings.

·      You do not want to deal with the documentation requirements necessary with corporations.

·      You want flexibility regarding paying profits to owners.

An LLC combines parts of a partnerships and corporations. It is an unincorporated structure that will protect company liability. Some startups choose to not form an LLC, particularly with technology startups. They want the opportunity to provide employees and consultants with different options. It is harder to get investors on board with just an LLC, as they cannot provide those options.

The good news is that a startup can convert their LLC to a C corporation. There can be some statutory limits in some states where additional requirements are necessary.

Advantages and Disadvantages of an LLC

While LLCs are popular for their flexibility and simplicity, understanding both their strengths and limitations is essential before deciding if this structure suits your business:

Advantages:

• Pass-through taxation: Profits and losses are reported on the owners’ individual tax returns, avoiding double taxation.
• Liability protection: Owners’ personal assets are protected from business debts and lawsuits.
• Flexible ownership: No restrictions on the number or type of members.
• Management flexibility: Members can choose to manage the business themselves or appoint managers.
• Fewer formalities: LLCs face fewer reporting and record-keeping requirements than corporations.

Disadvantages:

• Self-employment taxes: Owners typically pay self-employment taxes on the company’s entire net income.
• Limited investor appeal: Venture capitalists often prefer investing in corporations.
• Potential for dissolution: In some states, an LLC may dissolve upon the departure of a member unless otherwise specified in the operating agreement.

What Is a Corporation (Inc)?

A corporation shields your personal liability from your business liability. You have to separate your own personal finances from those of your business. Corporations are allowed in every U.S. state as well as the District of Columbia. A corporation is more attractive to investors. A corporation is also preferred for IPO. They are recognized outside of the U.S.

When deciding on which type of corporation to use, many owners take into consideration the way it will be taxed, particularly between S corporations and C corporations.

C Corporation Taxation and Compliance

C corporations are subject to double taxation: the company pays taxes on its profits, and shareholders pay taxes again on dividends received. However, this structure offers several tax planning opportunities and advantages:

• Lower corporate tax rate: Since the 2017 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act, C corporations benefit from a flat 21% federal tax rate, often lower than individual rates for high earners.
• Retained earnings: Profits can be retained and reinvested in the business at the corporate level without triggering additional tax.
• Tax-deductible benefits: C corps can deduct the cost of employee benefits such as health insurance and retirement contributions.

C corporations must also meet stricter compliance and governance requirements:

• Regular board and shareholder meetings
• Detailed record-keeping and annual reports
• Issuance of stock and maintenance of shareholder records

While more complex to operate, C corps are the preferred structure for raising capital, issuing multiple classes of stock, attracting venture funding, and going public.

What Is an S Corporation?

Once you decide to create a corporation or LLC, you may choose which way you prefer your business to be taxed. A new corporation, like LLCs using corporate taxation, may opt to file as a C corporation or an S corporation.

An S corporation is a pass-through entity. This means that the business is not taxed by the IRS. The money that is made is instead reported on the owner’s personal taxes. A C corporation is not taxed in this way. Instead, it is taxed at the corporate level. The dividends are then distributed.

You can choose to file as an S corp by filling out a form with the IRS along with your state government. All profits and losses of the business will then pass through the business and on to you so that you can deal with them on your taxes.

S corps are ideal if:

·      You want to have the benefits of a corporate business but with pass through taxation.

·      You want the ability to set salaries for your employees and yourself to minimize taxes.

·      Flexible accounting methods, as corporations must use the accrual method unless they are a small business. S corps do not have to use the accrual method unless inventory is involved.

·      Less likelihood of IRS audit, as S corps will file an informational tax return.

Choosing Between LLC, S Corp, and C Corp

Choosing between LLC vs S Corp vs C Corp depends on your business goals, growth plans, and tax strategy:

General guidelines:

• Choose an LLC if you prioritize simplicity, flexibility, and low compliance.
• Choose an S corp if you want tax savings and plan to pay yourself a salary.
• Choose a C corp if you plan to scale, raise capital, or go public.

S Corporation Rules, Restrictions, and Tax Advantages

S corporations are ideal for small to medium-sized businesses seeking corporate liability protection while maintaining pass-through taxation. However, they must follow strict IRS requirements, including:

• No more than 100 shareholders
• All shareholders must be U.S. citizens or residents
• Only one class of stock is permitted

Tax Benefits:

• Pass-through taxation: Income is reported on shareholders’ individual returns, avoiding double taxation.
• Salary and distribution strategy: Owners who are also employees can pay themselves a reasonable salary and receive remaining profits as dividends, potentially reducing self-employment taxes.
• Lower audit risk: S corps often face less IRS scrutiny compared to sole proprietorships or partnerships.

However, S corps are less flexible than LLCs and cannot attract foreign investors or institutional venture capital. Additionally, violating IRS eligibility rules can result in automatic termination of S corp status.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Can an LLC become an S corp or C corp later?
   Yes. An LLC can elect to be taxed as an S corp or C corp by filing the appropriate IRS forms, often to reduce taxes or attract investors.
2. Which is best for minimizing taxes: LLC, S corp, or C corp?
   S corps often offer the most tax-efficient structure for small businesses, while C corps can benefit from lower corporate tax rates and deductions for reinvested profits.
3. Can foreign investors own shares in an S corp?
   No. S corp shareholders must be U.S. citizens or permanent residents.
4. Which structure is best for attracting venture capital?
   C corporations are usually preferred by investors because they can issue multiple stock classes and have no shareholder restrictions.
5. Can a single-owner business form an S corp?
   Yes. A single-owner S corp is known as a single-shareholder corporation and is common for small businesses seeking tax benefits and liability protection.

If you need help with understanding c corp s corp LLC differences, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel’s marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.