Is an LLC a sole proprietorship? This is a commonly asked question. The potential of an LLC to be taxed as a sole proprietorship is why many people wonder if they are the same thing. They are distinct business organization types, but they may be taxed the same in some circumstances.

Understanding Business Organizations Types

Businesses that only have one owner are allowed to form a sole proprietorship, which does not distinguish between the owner and the business itself. The downside is the owner's personal assets are not protected and may be seized to pay business debts and liabilities.

Partnerships are business organizations that have two or more owners and operate with a "for-profit" model. They are similar to sole proprietorships in that they are easy to form with little upfront costs.

LLCs are a relatively new business organization type. They are governed by local state laws, and the owners must declare how they want to be taxed. Options include sole proprietorship, partnership, or a corporation. LLCs offer flexibility with taxation and the security of liability protection for personal assets. If there are multiple members, profits and losses are divided between members based on what percentage of the business they own. Members are required to write off their individual portions on their own personal income taxes. Single member LLCs claim all income and losses on their tax returns, much like a sole proprietorship.

Corporations can be C or S corporations. Corporations are separate legal entities, and owners' personal assets are protected against company debts and liabilities. C corporations are subject to double taxation. They are taxed once at the corporate level, and then dividends are taxed at the shareholder level. In comparison to C corporations, S corporations offer small businesses some tax relief. They offer tax benefits similar to a sole proprietorship and the liability protection of a corporation. An organization has a lot of regulations to satisfy in order to qualify as an S corporation, unlike C corporations.

Can an LLC be an Individual?

LLCs with only one member can operate similarly to a sole proprietorship in regards to taxation and management. The difference is the owner is not personally liable for debts and liabilities. You need to verify with your respective state on the rules and regulations set forth on how to form an LLC. A sole-member LLC can hire either freelancers and independent contractors or employees to run the business. Contractors and employees are not allowed to manage the business, however.

Single member LLCs can opt for taxation status as a corporation or sole proprietorship. If you choose a sole proprietorship, you report the LLC income on your 1040 Schedule C. And, you may be required to pay self-employment tax. Sole proprietorships don't pay corporate tax prior to personal income taxes. If you opt for taxation as a corporation, you will be double taxed as a regular C corporation.

If you opt for sole proprietorship taxation, it doesn't change the legal standing of the business. You would still enjoy the benefits of LLC status, even if you choose a different business organization type for tax purposes. Single owners of LLCs need to take extra steps to ensure they don't wind up legally responsible for the business's debts.

In certain scenarios, if a single-member LLC doesn't sufficiently capitalize the business or co-mingles personal and business assets, the court will treat it as a sole proprietorship, therefore removing the liability protections. Capitalizing a business is when it has enough assets and capital to function independently as a business. This is why it's important that single-member LLCs take adequate steps to have enough money to function independently and not co-mingle business and personal assets.

Differences between LLCs and Sole Proprietorships

  • LLCs are subject to specific state LLC laws and are required to pay annual fees.
  • Depending on the state, you may also be required to have an operating agreement and/or a registered agent on file.
  • Regulations may require additional paperwork such as annual reports.
  • Sole proprietorships are not impacted by these regulations.
  • LLCs are required to follow a specific naming structure that includes some form of LLC.
  • Sole proprietorships only need to ensure they aren't using a name that conflicts with another business operating in the state.
  • LLCs require businesses to keep from co-mingling funds whereas sole proprietorships are treated as one in the same as the owner.
  • LLCs must maintain separation of LLC records and personal records.
  • Sole proprietorships are taxed as a self-employed person whereas LLCs can choose their taxation method.

If you need help with understanding if an LLC is a sole proprietorship, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel only accepts the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.