An Overview of Fair Use Copyright in New York
Copyright Law and Its Effect on U.S. Creators3 min read
In the United States, copyright law governs the rights of the creators of original works, such as books, photographs, and music, to control how their creations are used. In certain circumstances, however, the use of copyrighted material without permission may be considered fair use and therefore legal. As part of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA) of 1998, the fair use doctrine has been codified into U.S. copyright law. This article provides an overview of the fair use doctrine in the context of copyright law in New York State, and outlines the considerations that should be taken into account when determining whether a particular use of a copyrighted work may be considered legal under the law.
What is Fair Use?
The fair use doctrine is a legal principle that allows certain limited uses of copyrighted materials without the permission of the author. This exception from copyright protection exists to ensure that the freedom of expression and the exchange of ideas and information that are essential to a healthy democracy are not unduly restrained by copyright laws. To this end, it permits certain limited uses of protected works for purposes such as news reporting, criticism, scholarship, and satire, as well as non-commercial uses for personal or educational purposes.
Under the fair use doctrine, the use of a copyrighted work must pass a four-factor test before it can be considered legal. The four factors used to evaluate a proposed use of a copyrighted work are: (1) the purpose and character of the use; (2) the nature of the copyrighted work; (3) the amount and substantiality of the portion used in relation to the copyrighted work as a whole; and (4) the effect of the use upon the potential market for or value of the copyrighted work.
Fair Use in New York State
In New York State, as elsewhere in the United States, the fair use doctrine is reflected in state and federal copyright laws. According to New York Civil Rights Law § 51, the fair use doctrine "provides for limited use of copyrighted material without conceding the rights of copyright holders." This statute explicitly notes that there is not an absolute right to fair use, and instead states that "when permission is granted, no royalty need be paid."
Although the fair use doctrine is given due respect in state and federal copyright law, the application of the doctrine can be difficult to assess in practice. In making a determination of fair use in any given circumstance, both the courts and copyright holders must take a number of factors into account. Because of the complexity of the legal issues involved, New Yorkers who wish to use a copyrighted work without permission should consult with a local attorney to ensure that their planned use complies with the law.
Concluding remarks
The fair use doctrine is an important part of U.S copyright law, and it is firmly established in the New York State legal system. For New Yorkers who wish to make use of a copyrighted work without acquiring permission from the rights holder, a determination of the legality of the proposed use must be carefully weighed. A local attorney with experience in copyright law can help ensure that a potential use of a copyrighted work complies with the fair use doctrine.
Topics:
